codearranger avatar

claude-legal-immigration-laws

Shared U.S. immigration-law plugin: INA (8 U.S.C. ch. 12), 8 CFR + 22 CFR, and the Foreign Affairs Manual mirrored verbatim, plus an EOIR court-rules corpus; an on-demand case-law index for the federal circuits, the Board of Immigration Appeals, and the USCIS AAO, backed by two bundled free MCP servers (CourtListener + Legal Data Hunter) and an immigration-case-law skill that routes the agent to them; and a 12-skill, venue-independent, document-producing self-help layer. Full detail in the plugin README.

GitHub stars
26

Install

/plugin install claude-legal-immigration-laws@claude-legal

Run it inside Claude Code after adding the marketplace with /plugin marketplace add codearranger/claude-legal.

Contents

Discovered from source

Skills 12

BIA Appeals — Appealing an Immigration Judge's Decision

NOT LEGAL ADVICE. This skill produces drafting aids, checklists, and document scaffolds — not legal advice, and no attorney-client relationship is created. A removal appeal can be the last chance to stay in the United States. The 30-day appeal deadline is jurisdictional and cannot be cured, extended, or reopened for being late (8 CFR § 1003.38(b), (d)) — there is no good-cause exception. Verify every deadline, form edition, fee amount, and citation against current law, and strongly consider a licensed immigration attorney or an EOIR-accredited representative before filing.

What this skill is for

When an immigration judge (IJ) rules against the respondent — denial of relief, an order of removal, a denied bond, certain motions — the respondent may appeal to the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA), the single nationwide appellate body of EOIR. The BIA reviews the IJ's record; it is not a new trial and (with narrow exceptions) takes no new evidence. This skill assembles the filing package. The structural/format conventions for EOIR filings are in eoir-immigration-courts.

The Form EOIR-26 and the 30-day deadline

  • The appeal is taken by filing a Notice of Appeal from a Decision of an Immigration Judge (Form EOIR-26) directly with the Board (8 CFR § 1003.3(a)(1)).
  • It must be received by the Board within 30 calendar days after the IJ states an oral decision or mails / electronically serves a written decision (8 CFR § 1003.38(b)). Filing = receipt at the Board, not mailing (§ 1003.38(c)) — build in mailing time. If day 30 is a Saturday, Sunday, or legal holiday, it rolls to the next business day (§ 1003.38(b)). Run immigration-deadlines to compute and double-check the date.
  • The EOIR-26 must include proof of service on the opposing party — DHS/ICE Office of the Principal Legal Advisor (OPLA) for the court that decided the case — and be in English or with a certified translation (8 CFR § 1003.3(a)(1), (a)(3)).
  • Fee or fee waiver. The Notice must be accompanied by the fee set in 8 CFR § 1103.7 or an Appeal Fee Waiver Request (Form EOIR-26A) (8 CFR § 1003.8(a)). If neither the fee nor the EOIR-26A is filed within the 30 days, the appeal is not properly filed and the IJ's decision becomes final as though no appeal had been taken (§ 1003.38(d)). Some appeals need no fee — e.g., a custody/bond appeal, or a matter tied to a no-fee application (§ 1003.8(a)(2)).
  • A party who waived appeal before the IJ cannot file an EOIR-26 (§ 1003.38(b)); so can a person whose departure waived the appeal (§ 1003.3(e)).

Statement of issues — and the summary-dismissal trap

The single most common self-represented error is a vague Notice of Appeal. The Board will summarily dismiss an appeal whose Notice fails to "meaningfully apprise the Board of the specific reasons for the appeal" (8 CFR § 1003.1(d)(2)(i)(A)) — a generic "the IJ was wrong" is not enough. The statement of the basis of appeal (8 CFR § 1003.3(b)) must:

  • Specifically identify the findings of fact, the conclusions of law, or both, that are challenged.
  • For a question of law, cite supporting authority.
  • For a factual dispute, identify the specific contested facts.
  • For discretionary relief, state whether the error goes to statutory eligibility or to the exercise of discretion, and name the specific finding(s) challenged.
  • Check the two boxes: whether oral argument is requested, and whether a separate written brief will follow.

Caution on the brief box. If the EOIR-26 says a brief will be filed and then none is filed (and no reasonable explanation is given by the deadline), the appeal can be summarily dismissed on that ground alone (8 CFR § 1003.1(d)(2)(i)(E)). Promise a brief only if it will be filed. Other summary-dismissal grounds include an untimely appeal, lack of Board jurisdiction, and an appeal filed for an improper purpose or with no arguable basis (§ 1003.1(d)(2)(i)).

Briefing schedule and page limits

  • Brief vs. EOIR-26 alone. A brief is optional — a well-drafted statement of issues on the EOIR-26 can stand alone — but a brief is usually where the real argument lives.
  • Schedule. For transcribed cases, the Board sets the briefing schedule after the transcript is available (8 CFR § 1003.3(c)(1)); the appellant typically gets 21 days (non-detained) or 21-day simultaneous briefing (detained). The Board may, on written motion for good cause, extend up to 90 days (§ 1003.3(c)(1)). Reply briefs are by leave of the Board.
  • Page limits / format. Page limits, the cover page, and formatting come from the BIA Practice Manual (procedural guidance, not law) — confirm the current limit there before filing. Cite the regulation for anything jurisdictional; use the manual only for mechanics.

Standard of review — what the Board may second-guess (8 CFR § 1003.1(d)(3))

Frame every issue to the correct standard:

Type of issueBIA standard of review
IJ's findings of fact (including credibility)Clearly erroneous — the Board does not review facts de novo (§ 1003.1(d)(3)(i))
Questions of law, discretion, and judgment (and all other issues)De novo (§ 1003.1(d)(3)(ii))

A factual challenge must show the finding was clearly erroneous — not merely that a different finding was possible. A legal/discretionary challenge gets fresh review. Mis-labeling a factual dispute as legal (or vice versa) weakens the appeal.

What is appealable — and what is NOT this skill

  • Appealable here: IJ decisions over which the Board has jurisdiction under 8 CFR § 1003.1 — removal orders, denials of relief, bond/custody determinations (§ 1003.38(a)), and certain IJ rulings. Some matters lie with the IJ, not the Board (§ 1003.1(d)(2)(i)(F)) — confirm jurisdiction.
  • Motion to reopen / reconsider — different route. A motion to reopen (new facts/evidence) or reconsider (legal/factual error) asks the same tribunal to revisit its own decision; it is not an appeal and runs on different deadlines and standards. Route those to eoir-motions-to-reopen-reconsider.
  • After the BIA — the petition for review. The BIA's decision is the administratively final order of removal and starts the 30-day clock to file a petition for review with the U.S. Court of Appeals under INA § 242 (8 U.S.C. § 1252). That clock is also jurisdictional and separate from this appeal. Route to circuit-petition-for-review immediately on a BIA loss.

Artifacts this skill drafts

  • An EOIR-26 cover + statement-of-issues scaffold — caption with name and A-number, the IJ / court, the decision date and 30-day deadline, a specific issue-by-issue statement keyed to the § 1003.1(d)(3) standard of review, the oral-argument and brief-to-follow elections, and a certificate of service on OPLA.
  • An appeal-brief outline — Statement of the Case; Statement of Facts (with record cites); Issues Presented; Standard of Review; Argument (one issue per heading, each tagged de novo vs. clear-error); Conclusion / relief requested; proof of service.
  • A fee-waiver (Form EOIR-26A) cover — the inability-to-pay declaration framing and a checklist to file it with the EOIR-26 inside the 30 days.

Related authority

Composition

Builds on eoir-immigration-courts (EOIR filing format / cover page / service on OPLA) and the record produced in eoir-removal-defense. Distinct from eoir-motions-to-reopen-reconsider (which revisits a decision rather than appealing it). Hands off to circuit-petition-for-review once the BIA issues its final order. immigration-deadlines computes the 30-day appeal and briefing clocks; immigration-fact-check verifies every regulation and record citation before filing.

Immigration — Circuit Petition for Review (PFR)

NOT LEGAL ADVICE. This skill produces drafting aids, checklists, and document scaffolds — not legal advice, and no attorney-client relationship is created. The 30-day deadline to file a petition for review is JURISDICTIONAL — it cannot be tolled, extended, or excused, and missing it is uncurable. A petition for review is federal appellate litigation on a closed administrative record; strongly consider retaining a licensed attorney experienced in circuit immigration practice before proceeding. Verify every date and citation against current law.

What a petition for review is — and is not

A petition for review (PFR) is the sole and exclusive means of obtaining judicial review of a final order of removal (8 U.S.C. § 1252(a)(5)). It is filed in a U.S. Court of Appeals (a circuit court) — not with EOIR, the immigration court, or the BIA. The "final order" is almost always the BIA's decision dismissing the appeal (or the IJ's order if no BIA appeal was taken and none is available).

The PFR document itself is short: a notice naming the petitioner, identifying the order under review (with a copy of the order attached — § 1252(c)), and stating the court. The merits are argued later, in an opening brief decided only on the administrative record the agency already made (§ 1252(b)(4)(A)); the court does not take new evidence and reverses fact findings only if "any reasonable adjudicator would be compelled" to the contrary (§ 1252(b)(4)(B)).

Deadline, venue, and exhaustion — the three jurisdictional gates

GateRuleAuthority
DeadlineFile no later than 30 days after the date of the final order of removal (usually the BIA decision). Jurisdictional — no tolling, no extension, no good-cause cure.§ 1252(b)(1)
VenueFile in the circuit covering the place where the immigration judge completed the proceedings — not where the petitioner now lives.§ 1252(b)(2)
ExhaustionThe court may review only if the petitioner exhausted all administrative remedies available as of right — i.e., raised the issue to the BIA. Issues not presented to the Board are generally unreviewable.§ 1252(d)(1)

Compute the 30 days against the date stamped on the final order, count calendar days, and confirm the circuit with immigration-deadlines. A motion to reopen or reconsider at the BIA does not restart this clock; if a PFR and a reopen/reconsider motion are both pending, the court consolidates them (§ 1252(b)(6)) — see eoir-motions-to-reopen-reconsider.

Scope of review — the § 1252(a)(2) bars and the (a)(2)(D) exception

Congress stripped circuit jurisdiction over two large categories of removal orders:

  • Criminal-offense bar — § 1252(a)(2)(C). No jurisdiction to review a final removal order against a noncitizen removable for certain crimes (offenses under § 1182(a)(2) or § 1227(a)(2)(A)(iii), (B), (C), (D), and the stacked-CIMT clause).
  • Discretionary-decision bar — § 1252(a)(2)(B). No jurisdiction to review judgments granting or denying the listed discretionary relief (e.g., cancellation under § 1229b, voluntary departure under § 1229c, adjustment under § 1255, certain § 1182 waivers), or other decisions specified to be in the agency's discretion.

The key exception — § 1252(a)(2)(D). Nothing in those bars precludes review of constitutional claims or questions of law raised in a petition for review to an appropriate court of appeals. A PFR that falls within a bar generally survives only if it is framed as a constitutional claim or a legal question (the application of law to settled facts can qualify). Frame the petition's issues accordingly and verify the controlling circuit construction via CourtListener (below) — do not rely on remembered case names.

No automatic stay — you must MOVE for a stay of removal

Filing a petition for review does NOT stay removal. Service of the petition does not stop the government from removing the petitioner while the case is pending unless the court orders otherwise (§ 1252(b)(3)(B)). To avoid removal during the appeal, the petitioner must file a separate motion for a stay of removal in the court of appeals and satisfy the stay standard (the Nken-type four-factor test — likelihood of success, irreparable harm, balance of equities, public interest). Some circuits operate a temporary administrative-stay practice on request; confirm the local rule and the government's forbearance policy. Treat the stay motion as urgent and parallel to the PFR, not as something that happens later.

Artifacts this skill drafts

  • PFR caption / notice scaffold — petitioner name(s) and A-number; respondent (the Attorney General / United States); the order under review and its date; the circuit; a statement that a copy of the order is attached (§ 1252(c)).
  • Filing checklist — the 30-day deadline (computed and flagged jurisdictional); correct venue (circuit of the IJ's completed proceedings); exhaustion confirmation; copy of the final order attached; the certified administrative record (CAR) request/expectation; filing fee or fee-waiver motion; service on the respondent.
  • Stay-of-removal motion outline — the four stay factors mapped to the record, an urgency banner, and a prompt to seek a temporary administrative stay where the circuit allows.
  • Exhaustion worksheet — issue-by-issue: was it raised to the BIA? where in the record? flagging any issue at risk of being deemed unexhausted under § 1252(d)(1).

Related authority

  • INA § 242 / 8 U.S.C. § 1252 (judicial review of orders of removal) — ../../references/immigration-statutes/INA-II-immigration.md (§ 1252; the INA ↔ 8 U.S.C. crosswalk is in that corpus's README).
  • Circuit immigration case law (constructions of the (a)(2) bars, the (a)(2)(D) exception, exhaustion, and the stay standard) is on-demand via CourtListener — see ../../references/legal-data-apis.md for the MCP search workflow and the per-circuit court ids (ca1–ca11; the Ninth, ca9, carries the largest immigration docket). Do not invent case names — pull and verify each cite, then confirm with immigration-fact-check.
  • Canonical filing URLs and the PFR framework pointer — ../../references/online-sources.md.

Composition

  • bia-appeals — establishes the final order that this PFR reviews; the BIA decision is the trigger for the 30-day clock.
  • eoir-motions-to-reopen-reconsider — a parallel reopen/reconsider motion does not toll the PFR deadline; if both are pending the court consolidates (§ 1252(b)(6)).
  • immigration-deadlines — compute and double-check the jurisdictional 30-day deadline and identify the correct circuit/venue.
  • immigration-fact-check — verify every statutory and case citation in the PFR and the stay motion before filing.

Consular Visa Refusal — Department of State

NOT LEGAL ADVICE. This skill produces drafting aids, checklists, and document scaffolds — not legal advice, and no attorney-client relationship is created. A consular refusal can carry a multi-year or permanent bar to reentry; a misstep on a waiver or an admission of a misrepresentation can foreclose options. Verify every ground, form edition, and deadline against current law, and strongly consider a licensed immigration attorney before submitting anything. Start with immigration-pro-se if you have not confirmed the forum.

The consular forum

A visa applied for abroad (DS-160 for a nonimmigrant visa, DS-260 for an immigrant visa) is adjudicated by a consular officer of the Department of State, governed by the INA, the State Department regulations at 22 CFR Parts 40–42, and the agency's internal guidance in the 9 FAM. This is a different forum from USCIS (benefits) and EOIR (removal). Under INA § 221(g) every refused applicant is handed (or emailed) a refusal sheet citing the section(s) of law the officer applied — read it first; it tells you which path below applies.

FAM is agency guidance, not binding law. The 9 FAM tells consular officers how the Department reads the statute, but it does not bind a court and is not itself the ground of refusal. Always pair a FAM cite with the controlling INA § 212 / 22 CFR provision that actually states the ground or the waiver. Cite, e.g., "INA § 212(a)(6)(C)(i) (8 U.S.C. § 1182(a)(6)(C)(i)); see 9 FAM 302.9" — never the FAM alone.

§ 221(g) vs. § 212(a) — read the refusal sheet

INA § 221(g) "refusal"INA § 212(a) ineligibility
What it meansApplication is incomplete or needs more review ("administrative processing")A substantive inadmissibility ground applies to the applicant
Typical causeMissing document, missing form, pending security/name check, requested evidenceUnlawful presence, misrepresentation, criminal record, public charge, prior removal
Curable howSubmit the missing item / information to the post — usually resolves itGenerally needs a waiver (if one exists) or the passage of time
AuthorityINA § 221(g) (8 U.S.C. § 1201(g)); 22 CFR 41.121 / 42.81; 9 FAM 302.1 (212(a)(7)/221(g) doc grounds)INA § 212(a) (8 U.S.C. § 1182(a)); 22 CFR 40.x; 9 FAM 302.2–302.14
StatusA "quasi-refusal" that stays open pending the missing pieceA refusal on the merits; the case is decided unless a waiver clears it

A § 221(g) hold is the common one and is usually fixable by supplying what was asked for — gather the requested document, transcribe the case/refusal number exactly, and submit it through the post's stated channel. The § 221(g) cover letter this skill drafts itemizes each requested item against an enclosure index.

The § 212(a) ineligibility framework and waivers

The substantive grounds live in INA § 212(a) (8 U.S.C. § 1182(a)) and are applied by consular officers per 9 FAM 302.2–302.14, paired with the 22 CFR Part 40 subparts:

Common groundINA citeFAMWaiver path
Unlawful presence (3-yr / 10-yr / permanent bar)§ 212(a)(9)(B)–(C)9 FAM 302.11I-601 (or I-601A provisional, before departure); none for permanent bar w/o 10-yr wait
Misrepresentation / fraud§ 212(a)(6)(C)(i)9 FAM 302.9I-601 under § 212(i); § 212(d)(3) for NIV
Criminal grounds (CIMT, controlled substance)§ 212(a)(2)9 FAM 302.3–302.4I-601 under § 212(h); § 212(d)(3) for NIV
Public charge§ 212(a)(4)9 FAM 302.8no formal waiver; cured by sufficient I-864 / circumstances
Prior removal§ 212(a)(9)(A)9 FAM 302.11Form I-212 (consent to reapply)

Waiver instruments:

  • Form I-601, Application for Waiver of Grounds of Inadmissibility — the general inadmissibility waiver (e.g., § 212(h) criminal, § 212(i) fraud, certain § 212(a)(9)(B) unlawful-presence cases), usually requiring extreme hardship to a qualifying U.S. citizen / LPR relative. Filed with USCIS, not the consulate.
  • Form I-601A, Provisional Unlawful Presence Waiver — waives only the § 212(a)(9)(B) unlawful-presence bar, before the applicant departs for the interview, so the bar does not strand them abroad. Filed with USCIS while still in the U.S.; the consular interview follows approval.
  • INA § 212(d)(3)(A) nonimmigrant waiver (8 U.S.C. § 1182(d)(3)) — a discretionary waiver for most grounds for a nonimmigrant visa applicant; the consular officer recommends it and CBP's Admissibility Review Office adjudicates. See 8 CFR Part 212 for the documentary-requirements / waiver framework and 9 FAM 302 for the field standard.

Which waiver (if any) exists depends on the exact ground and the visa type; confirm the controlling INA § 212 subsection against the corpus before assuming a waiver is available.

Consular nonreviewability — and what you actually can do

There is generally NO appeal of a consular refusal to a court. The doctrine of consular nonreviewability means a federal court will not second-guess a consular officer's visa decision. Do not draft a "court appeal" of a consular refusal. The real avenues are administrative:

  1. Submit the § 221(g) item. If the refusal sheet asks for a document or information, the fastest cure is to provide it through the post's stated channel. (This skill's § 221(g) cover letter.)
  2. Request reconsideration / supervisory review at the post. Under 22 CFR 41.121(c) (NIV) and 22 CFR 42.81(c) (IV), a refusal is reviewed — and may be referred to a supervisory officer. A concise, respectful letter to the post identifying a factual error or new evidence is the vehicle. (This skill's reconsideration letter.)
  3. LegalNet / Visa Office advisory opinion. For a legal-interpretation question (how the law applies to the facts — not the discretionary merits), the Department's Visa Office (LegalNet) advisory-opinion channel can be raised, typically through the post or counsel. It addresses interpretation of law, not the officer's discretion.

Reconsideration is not an appeal and the post is not obligated to change its decision; frame it as new facts / legal error, never as a demand.

Artifacts this skill drafts

  • A § 221(g) document-submission cover letter — caption with the post, case/refusal number, applicant name and DOB; an enclosure index mapping each requested item; a one-line statement that the submission responds to the § 221(g) request.
  • A waiver-assembly checklist — selects I-601 / I-601A / § 212(d)(3) by ground and visa type; lists the qualifying relative, the extreme-hardship evidence categories, and the filing destination (USCIS vs. ARO via the post).
  • A request-for-reconsideration / supervisory-review letter to the post — states the specific factual error or new evidence, cites the controlling INA § 212 / 22 CFR provision (with the FAM as supporting guidance), and requests supervisory review under 22 CFR 41.121(c) / 42.81(c).

Related authority

Composition

Routed to from immigration-pro-se (which confirms this is the Department of State forum, not USCIS or EOIR). Use uscis-benefit-requests to assemble and file the I-601 / I-601A waiver packets, which are USCIS filings even though the refusal is consular. Run immigration-fact-check to verify every INA § 212 / 22 CFR cite and to confirm each FAM cite is paired with controlling law. Run immigration-deadlines for the one-year § 221(g) follow-up clock (22 CFR 41.121(a) / 42.81(e) — failure to pursue within one year may require a new application) and any waiver / reapplication timing.

EOIR — The Immigration Courts and Their Rules

NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Drafting aids and checklists only — not legal advice, no attorney-client relationship. The practice-manual conventions below change; confirm the current Immigration Court Practice Manual and the controlling 8 CFR provision, and check your specific court's standing orders, before filing.

The court system in one page

The Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR) is part of the Department of Justice — not DHS. DHS (through ICE counsel) is the opposing party in removal proceedings; EOIR is the neutral adjudicator. Structure:

  • Immigration courts (~70 nationwide), supervised by the Office of the Chief Immigration Judge (OCIJ). Each court has one or more Immigration Judges (IJs); larger courts have an Assistant Chief Immigration Judge (ACIJ).
  • The Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) — the single, nationwide appellate body that reviews IJ decisions (see bia-appeals).
  • Appeals from the BIA go to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the circuit where the immigration court sat (see circuit-petition-for-review).

A removal case is filed when DHS files a Notice to Appear (NTA, Form I-862) with an immigration court. Venue is the court where the NTA is filed; it can be moved (below).

Two layers of procedural authority — cite the right one

LayerWhat it isWhere
Binding regulations (LAW)8 CFR Part 1003 (EOIR, the Board, IJ proceedings, motions), Part 1240 (removal proceedings), Part 1208 (asylum before EOIR)Verbatim in ../../references/immigration-regulations/
Practice manuals (guidance)Immigration Court Practice Manual (ICPM) and BIA Practice Manual (BIAPM) — filing format, page limits, deadlines, e-filing../../references/court-rules/ (pointer stubs + canonical URLs)

Rule of thumb: cite the 8 CFR regulation for anything jurisdictional or substantive (e.g., the IJ's authority, motion standards, the appeal right); use the practice manual only for mechanics (format, tabs, page limits, service). Never rely on the manual where a regulation governs.

Hearings — master calendar vs. individual

  • Master calendar hearing (MCH). Short, often high-volume scheduling/pleading hearing. The respondent pleads to the NTA (admits/denies the factual allegations, concedes or contests the charge(s) of removability) and designates relief sought. See eoir-removal-defense for the pleading mechanics.
  • Individual / merits hearing. The evidentiary hearing on the application(s) for relief — testimony, exhibits, witnesses. Filing deadlines (the "call-up" / submission deadline set by the IJ or the ICPM default) are firm; late exhibits can be refused.

Filing format — the conventions EOIR expects

The ICPM sets the format. Confirm current specifics in ../../references/court-rules/Immigration-Court-Practice-Manual.md; the durable conventions a filing should follow:

  • Cover page / caption identifying the respondent by full name and A-number, the immigration court (city), the IJ if assigned, the proceeding type, and the next hearing date.
  • A signed proof / certificate of service on the opposing party — DHS/ICE Office of the Principal Legal Advisor (OPLA) counsel for that court — for every filing.
  • Exhibits tabbed and labeled (alphabetical for the respondent; numeric for DHS), with a table of contents and consecutive pagination; a proposed-order / cover where required.
  • Page limits and the "call-up" filing deadline per the ICPM / the IJ's standing order.
  • A certificate of translation for any non-English document.
  • E-filing through ECAS (EOIR Courts & Appeals System) where the court is on ECAS; paper filing otherwise. A self-represented respondent registers for an ECAS pro-se account or files paper.

Use the eoir-immigration-courts cover-page + proof-of-service scaffold below; the substantive motion bodies come from eoir-removal-defense / eoir-motions-to-reopen-reconsider.

Venue and change of venue

Venue is the court where DHS filed the NTA. A motion to change venue (decided under the 8 CFR Part 1003 framework and the ICPM) is filed when the respondent has moved or for convenience-of-the-parties reasons; it typically requires pleading to the NTA and stating a fixed address in the new location. Route the motion through eoir-removal-defense.

Artifacts this skill drafts

  • A filing-format checklist (cover page, caption, service on OPLA, tabbed exhibits, page limits, translation certificate, ECAS vs. paper).
  • A cover-page + caption + certificate-of-service scaffold for an immigration-court filing.
  • A venue / change-of-venue worksheet.

Related authority

Composition

The structural/format anchor for EOIR work. eoir-removal-defense, eoir-motions-to-reopen-reconsider, and bia-appeals supply the substantive filings; immigration-deadlines supplies the clocks; immigration-fact-check verifies citations.

EOIR — Motions to Reopen and Motions to Reconsider

NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Drafting aids and checklists only — not legal advice, no attorney-client relationship. These deadlines are short, numerically limited, and often uncurable. A missed or mis-filed motion is frequently the last chance to act, and the wrong forum (IJ vs. Board) defeats the filing outright. Verify the controlling 8 CFR provision, the current deadline, and your court's standing orders before filing, and strongly consider a licensed immigration attorney or EOIR-accredited representative.

Two motions, two jobs — do not conflate them

A motion to reconsider says the prior decision got the law or facts wrong on the record that already existed. A motion to reopen says there are new facts or evidence the adjudicator never saw. They have different standards, deadlines, and limits.

Motion to RECONSIDERMotion to REOPEN
StandardSpecify the errors of fact or law in the prior decision, supported by pertinent authorityPresent new, material facts/evidence that was not available and could not have been discovered or presented at the prior hearing; attach affidavits + the relief application
Deadline30 days from the final administrative order90 days from the final administrative order
LimitOne per proceedingOne per proceeding (numerically limited)
AuthorityINA § 240(c)(6) / 8 U.S.C. § 1229a(c)(6); 8 CFR § 1003.23(b)(2) (IJ) / § 1003.2(b) (Board)INA § 240(c)(7) / 8 U.S.C. § 1229a(c)(7); 8 CFR § 1003.23(b)(3) (IJ) / § 1003.2(c) (Board)

A motion to reconsider may not seek reconsideration of an order denying a prior motion to reconsider (8 CFR § 1003.23(b)(2)). New evidence belongs in a reopen motion, not a reconsider motion. Run the clock through immigration-deadlines before drafting — the 30/90-day periods run from the final administrative order, which can be the IJ's decision or the Board's.

Where to file — IJ or Board

File where the body that last had jurisdiction rendered the decision under review:

  • Before the immigration judge — 8 CFR § 1003.23 — when the IJ entered the final order and no appeal was taken to the Board (or the appeal was withdrawn). File with the immigration court that has administrative control over the Record of Proceeding; serve the ICE Office of the Principal Legal Advisor (OPLA) for that location; include an EOIR-28 if represented.
  • Before the Board — 8 CFR § 1003.2 — when the Board issued the last decision (it decided an appeal, or summarily affirmed). A motion directed at a decision the Board reviewed goes to the Board, not back to the IJ.

If unsure which body holds jurisdiction, resolve it first — filing in the wrong forum wastes a single-use motion. See eoir-immigration-courts for the jurisdictional map and bia-appeals for Board mechanics.

Exceptions that escape the time / number limits

The 30/90-day deadlines and the one-motion cap do not apply in these postures. Plead the exception explicitly and cite it:

  • In-absentia removal orders (INA § 240(b)(5)(C); 8 CFR § 1003.23(b)(4)(ii)). A removal order entered in absentia may be rescinded by a motion to reopen filed within 180 days if the failure to appear was due to "exceptional circumstances" (§ 240(e)(1) — e.g., serious illness, death of an immediate relative; "not less compelling circumstances"). There is NO time limit if the respondent did not receive notice under INA § 239(a)(1)/(2) or was in Federal or State custody and the failure to appear was through no fault of their own. Filing this motion does stay removal pending disposition (§ 1003.23(b)(4)(ii)).
  • Changed country conditions for asylum / withholding / CAT (INA § 240(c)(7)(C)(ii); 8 CFR § 1003.23(b)(4)(i)). No time or number limit where the motion seeks asylum, withholding, or CAT protection based on changed conditions in the country of removal, the evidence is material, and it could not have been discovered or presented before. (Note: a prior frivolous-application finding bars this route.)
  • Jointly filed motions (8 CFR § 1003.23(b)(4)(iv)). Time/number limits do not apply to a motion agreed to by all parties and filed jointly (often used after DHS agreement).
  • Agency sua sponte authority (8 CFR § 1003.23(b)(1) / § 1003.2(a)). The IJ or Board may reopen or reconsider on its own motion at any time — a request invoking this authority is discretionary and not a substitute for a timely motion, but it is the only path once the deadlines and exceptions are exhausted.

Ineffective-assistance-of-counsel reopening — the Lozada checklist

A motion to reopen premised on ineffective assistance of prior counsel must satisfy the threshold requirements of Matter of Lozada (verify the exact case name and citation via immigration-fact-check before filing). Treat this as a gating checklist — incomplete compliance is a common ground for denial:

  • Affidavit from the respondent setting out the agreement with former counsel — what was retained for, what counsel was told, and what counsel did or failed to do.
  • Notice to former counsel of the allegations, with a chance to respond, and the response (or a statement that none was received) attached.
  • Bar complaint filed against former counsel with the appropriate disciplinary authority — or a reasoned explanation why no complaint was filed.
  • Showing of prejudice — how the deficient performance affected the outcome.
  • If filed after the 90-day reopen deadline, a basis for equitable tolling of the deadline (verify the controlling circuit's tolling standard via immigration-fact-check).

Stays — filing a motion does NOT pause removal (mostly)

By regulation, the filing of a motion to reopen or reconsider does not automatically stay the execution of the removal decision (8 CFR § 1003.23(b)(1)(v) / § 1003.2(f)). Removal proceeds unless a stay is specifically granted by the IJ, the Board, or an authorized DHS officer. Exception: the in-absentia rescission motion under § 1003.23(b)(4)(ii) does stay removal pending disposition. In every other posture, request a stay expressly and, where removal is imminent or a final order is under judicial review, route stay relief to circuit-petition-for-review (a petition for review plus a motion for stay in the court of appeals). A departure from the U.S. after filing is treated as withdrawal of the motion (§ 1003.23(b)(1)).

Artifacts this skill drafts

  • A motion-to-reopen scaffold — caption + A-number, statement of jurisdiction and forum, the new/previously-unavailable/material facts with affidavits and the relief application, exception pled if applicable, certificate of service on OPLA, proposed order.
  • A motion-to-reconsider scaffold — the enumerated errors of fact or law with pertinent authority keyed to the prior decision, 30-day timeliness statement, service, proposed order.
  • An in-absentia-rescission variant — the § 240(b)(5)(C) / § 1003.23(b)(4)(ii) motion (exceptional circumstances within 180 days, or lack-of-notice / custody with no time limit), with the automatic-stay note.
  • A Lozada compliance checklist for an ineffective-assistance reopening.

Related authority

Composition

Pairs with eoir-removal-defense (the underlying proceeding and the relief application a reopen motion carries) and bia-appeals (when the Board held last jurisdiction or to appeal a denial). immigration-deadlines computes the 30 / 90 / 180-day clocks; circuit-petition-for- review handles judicial review and stays of removal; immigration-fact-check verifies every citation — especially the Matter of Lozada name and any equitable-tolling authority — before filing.

EOIR — Removal Defense (Respondent Filings)

NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Drafting aids, scaffolds, and checklists only — not legal advice, and no attorney-client relationship is created. Removal proceedings are high-stakes: an order of removal can mean permanent separation, multi-year or permanent bars to reentry, and loss of status — and many steps (especially concessions and missed deadlines) are hard or impossible to undo. A licensed immigration attorney or an EOIR-accredited representative is strongly advised before you plead or file anything. Verify every form edition, deadline, and citation against current law.

This skill produces the respondent's substantive filings; filing format, the caption/cover page, service on DHS/ICE OPLA, exhibit tabbing, and ECAS vs. paper come from eoir-immigration-courts. Statutory text lives in the ../../references/immigration-statutes/ corpus — cite by the INA → 8 U.S.C. crosswalk in its README (INA § 240 = 8 U.S.C. § 1229a, § 240A = § 1229b, § 240B = § 1229c, § 208 = § 1158, § 245 = § 1255, § 237 = § 1227, § 212 = § 1182), not from memory.

Entering an appearance

  • A representative enters with Form EOIR-28 (the EOIR equivalent of a court appearance) — attorneys and EOIR-accredited reps only (see immigration-pro-se for who may appear and the notario-fraud warning).
  • A pro se respondent files no appearance form — you are already a party. Format and signature-block mechanics defer to eoir-immigration-courts.

Pleading to the Notice to Appear (the master calendar hearing)

At the master calendar hearing (MCH) the respondent pleads to the NTA (Form I-862). The pleading has three moving parts, and the IJ takes them on the record under 8 CFR § 1240.10:

  1. The factual allegations (numbered ¶¶ in the NTA — alienage, manner of entry, status, any convictions). For each allegation: admit or deny (or "deny for lack of knowledge").
  2. The charge(s) of removability — cited as grounds of deportability under INA § 237 / 8 U.S.C. § 1227 (for someone admitted) or inadmissibility under INA § 212 / 8 U.S.C. § 1182 (for an arriving alien or one not admitted). For each charge: concede or contest.
  3. Designate the relief sought and the country of removal (or decline to designate).

Why concessions are high-stakes — flag this to the user. Admitting the factual allegations and conceding the charge establishes removability and shifts the burden to the respondent to prove eligibility for relief in the exercise of discretion (8 CFR § 1240.8(d)). A concession is generally binding and hard to undo. By contrast, if the respondent contests removability, DHS must prove a deportability charge by clear and convincing evidence (8 CFR § 1240.8(a)); for an applicant for admission, the respondent bears the burden of proving admissibility (§ 1240.8(b)/(c)). Do not concede reflexively — the choice drives the whole case. The burden framework is statutory at INA § 240(c) / 8 U.S.C. § 1229a(c).

The relief menu — designate, then route to the application

Relief is requested in proceedings; each form of relief has its own application and is handed off to the skill that drafts it:

ReliefStatuteApplication formRoutes to
Asylum / withholding / CATINA § 208 / 8 U.S.C. § 1158 (asylum); withholding & CAT in proceedingsForm I-589eoir-removal-defense (this skill) + the asylum reference at 8 CFR Part 1208
Cancellation of removal — LPRINA § 240A(a) / 8 U.S.C. § 1229b(a)Form EOIR-42Athis skill
Cancellation of removal — non-LPRINA § 240A(b) / 8 U.S.C. § 1229b(b)Form EOIR-42Bthis skill
Adjustment of statusINA § 245 / 8 U.S.C. § 1255Form I-485 (filed in proceedings)this skill; uscis-benefit-requests for the underlying petition
Voluntary departureINA § 240B / 8 U.S.C. § 1229c(oral/written request; pre- or post-conclusion)this skill

The relief-application cover/index scaffold below assembles the application, the supporting exhibits (tabbed per eoir-immigration-courts), and the proof of service. Eligibility analysis is NOT in scope — verify the substantive bars and thresholds against the statute and 8 CFR.

Motions in proceedings

  • Motion to continue. Filed on a good-cause showing (8 CFR § 1003.29; the continuance/filing-extension limits at 8 CFR § 1240.10(h)). State the specific cause (e.g., retaining counsel, awaiting a pending USCIS petition, gathering evidence), the length sought, and whether DHS opposes.
  • Motion to change venue. Decided under the 8 CFR Part 1003 / § 1240.10 framework and the ICPM; typically requires pleading to the NTA, stating a fixed new address, and a good-cause showing (usually a move). Route format through eoir-immigration-courts.
  • Motion to administratively close or to terminate. Administrative closure removes the case from the active docket; termination ends proceedings (e.g., a defective NTA, or DHS lacks a sustainable charge). Both are decided by the IJ under the Part 1003 framework.
  • Prehearing statement + the call-up deadline. Before the individual / merits hearing, the IJ (or the ICPM default) sets a filing "call-up" deadline for exhibits, witness lists, and a prehearing statement. The deadline is firm — late exhibits can be refused (8 CFR § 1240.7(g)). Run immigration-deadlines to fix the date.

Motions to REOPEN or RECONSIDER are a separate skill — route those to eoir-motions-to-reopen-reconsider.

Artifacts this skill drafts

  • A pleading scaffold — allegation-by-allegation admit/deny plus concede/contest per charge, with the burden-shift warning surfaced.
  • A motion-to-continue scaffold (good-cause statement + length + DHS position).
  • A motion-to-change-venue scaffold (plea to the NTA + fixed new address + good cause).
  • A relief-application cover/index (application form + tabbed exhibits + proof of service).

Related authority

Composition

Builds on eoir-immigration-courts (format, caption, service on OPLA, ECAS) for every filing's mechanics. immigration-deadlines supplies the MCH, call-up, and motion clocks; immigration-fact-check verifies citations. Reopen/reconsider go to eoir-motions-to-reopen-reconsider; appeals of the IJ's decision go to bia-appeals. Where relief depends on an underlying USCIS petition (adjustment) or a consular step, composes with uscis-benefit-requests and consular-visa-refusal.

Immigration Case-Law Research (bundled MCP servers)

NOT LEGAL ADVICE. This skill retrieves and organizes legal sources as a research and drafting aid; it does not evaluate whether an authority is good law on the user's facts and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Immigration consequences are severe and often irreversible — pair research with review by a licensed immigration attorney or EOIR-accredited representative.

Purpose

This plugin snapshots the rules (INA, 8 CFR, 22 CFR, FAM) verbatim, but case law is on-demand — ../../references/legal-data-apis.md indexes the sources, and the plugin bundles two free remote MCP servers (declared in ../../.mcp.json) to serve that layer. Never cite a case from memory — every cited authority must be retrieved and read before it enters a draft.

Forum-aware routing

AuthorityWhere to get it
Circuit courts (petitions for review under INA § 242 / 8 U.S.C. § 1252) and the Supreme CourtCourtListener MCP — court IDs ca1–ca11, cadc, scotus. The Ninth Circuit (ca9) carries the largest immigration docket; circuit law is not uniform, so always scope the search to the circuit where the petition lies (or the IJ sits)
BIA precedent (Matter of …, cited "I&N Dec.")CourtListener indexes many BIA decisions (court ID bia); the EOIR Virtual Law Library is the publisher of record — confirm the precedent there, and check it has not been certified to or overruled by the Attorney General
AAO (USCIS appeals, non-precedent + adopted decisions)Not on CourtListener — the USCIS decision reading room per legal-data-apis.md
District courts (habeas, APA / mandamus delay suits) and their docketsCourtListener MCP — opinions + the RECAP/PACER docket collection (find the complaint, the government's response, the order)
Country-of-origin law — penal codes, statutes criminalizing the protected ground, family/nationality law, foreign case lawLegal Data Hunter MCP — multi-jurisdictional coverage of 100+ countries; often decisive for asylum (e.g., whether the applicant's conduct or identity is criminalized at home), and for nationality / statelessness questions

CourtListener playbook (immigration-flavored)

  • Search both section numbers. Opinions cite the same provision as INA § 240 or 8 U.S.C. § 1229a inconsistently — search both forms (crosswalk in ../../references/immigration-statutes/README.md); never compute the offset.
  • Scope by court and date. Pre-BIA-deference-era and pre-amendment cases mislead; filter by date when a provision was amended (e.g., post-REAL ID Act credibility law).
  • Read before citing — use the document-reading tools to pull the opinion text and quote-check the holding; restrict response fields to what you need.
  • Citation verification — run a draft's citations through the citation-lookup tools in bulk; the citation network (who cites this case) is a first-pass treatment check, not Shepard's/KeyCite. For load-bearing authority, recommend a citator check before filing.
  • Link every retrieved case with its courtlistener.com URL next to the reporter cite.

Legal Data Hunter playbook (country-of-origin law)

  • Discover the country's available sources and filters first, then run scoped hybrid search; retrieve full text before quoting and cite inline with the document link.
  • Pair foreign-law findings with the U.S. legal element they support (e.g., a penal-code section criminalizing the protected ground → the persecution / "particular social group" analysis; a nationality statute → derivative-citizenship or statelessness analysis).
  • Foreign law in an asylum filing is evidence, not binding authority — present it as a documented country-conditions exhibit, translated where required, alongside (not instead of) State Department and NGO country reports.

Output discipline

  • Inline citation to a retrieved document for every legal claim; holding vs. dicta distinguished; operative language quoted, not paraphrased.
  • Confidence flags: GREEN (retrieved, read, supports), YELLOW (partial/arguable support), RED (could not retrieve — do not cite). Hand the finished draft to immigration-fact-check for the four-pass audit before filing.
  • Repeat the NOT LEGAL ADVICE disclaimer in any deliverable this research feeds.

If the tools are missing

Both servers need a one-time sign-in (CourtListener: free account, OAuth; Legal Data Hunter: GitHub/Google). If their tools are absent, tell the user to run /mcp and authenticate — do not fall back to memory. Hard fallbacks: the REST sources indexed in ../../references/legal-data-apis.md and ../../references/online-sources.md.

Composition

Finds and verifies authority for circuit-petition-for-review (circuit scoping + exhaustion arguments), bia-appeals (BIA precedent + circuit law), eoir-removal-defense (relief-eligibility case law + country-of-origin evidence), and eoir-motions-to-reopen-reconsider (changed-country-conditions evidence). Runs before immigration-fact-check, which audits the finished draft. The matter-neutral counterpart for non-immigration research is case-law-research in claude-legal-federal-laws.

Immigration — Deadline Catalog & Computation

NOT LEGAL ADVICE. This skill produces a deadline-triage worksheet and computation notes — not legal advice, and no attorney-client relationship is created. Immigration deadlines are short, vary by forum, and are frequently jurisdictional and uncurable: a missed BIA-appeal or petition-for-review deadline usually cannot be fixed by any later motion. Verify every date, form edition, and citation against current law and the actual notice in hand, and strongly consider consulting a licensed immigration attorney or an EOIR-accredited representative before relying on any computed date.

What this skill does

It maps a matter's posture to the clock(s) that control it, ties each clock to its statutory or regulatory authority, and computes candidate dates. Run it immediately after immigration-pro-se identifies the forum — the deadline often decides which downstream skill even matters. Cite from the INA → 8 U.S.C. crosswalk in ../../references/immigration-statutes/, not from memory.

Deadline catalog

ClockLengthAuthorityNotes
Asylum one-year filing bar1 year from arrivalINA § 208(a)(2)(B) / 8 U.S.C. § 1158Exceptions for changed circumstances materially affecting eligibility or extraordinary circumstances explaining the delay (§ 1158(a)(2)(D)).
Appeal IJ → BIA30 days from the IJ decision8 CFR § 1003.38 (filing) / § 1003.3Form EOIR-26, received (not mailed) at the Board. Not extendable.
Petition for review → U.S. Court of Appeals30 days from the final order of removalINA § 242(b)(1) / 8 U.S.C. § 1252Jurisdictional; no tolling, no extension. Filed in the circuit where the IJ completed proceedings.
Motion to reopen90 days from the final administrative decision8 CFR § 1003.23(b) (before IJ) / § 1003.2(c) (before BIA)Generally one motion; number/time limits. Exceptions below.
Motion to reconsider30 days from the final administrative decision8 CFR § 1003.23(b) (before IJ) / § 1003.2(b) (before BIA)Generally one motion; states an error of law or fact in the prior decision.
Reopen in-absentia (exceptional circumstances)180 days from the in-absentia orderINA § 240(b)(5)(C) / 8 U.S.C. § 1229aTime-limited motion to reopen the in-absentia removal order.
Reopen in-absentia (lack of notice)No time limitINA § 240(b)(5)(C) / 8 U.S.C. § 1229aFiled "at any time" if the NTA / hearing notice was not received.
Reopen — changed country conditions (asylum)No time / number limit8 CFR § 1003.23(b)(4) / § 1003.2(c)(3)Materially changed conditions in the country of removal; evidence must be previously unavailable.
Voluntary departure — post-conclusionup to 60 daysINA § 240B(b) / 8 U.S.C. § 1229cGranted at the conclusion of proceedings; bond required.
Voluntary departure — pre-conclusionup to 120 daysINA § 240B(a) / 8 U.S.C. § 1229cGranted before/at master calendar, before merits.
NTA → first hearingat least 10 days noticeINA § 239 / 8 U.S.C. § 1229Minimum time between NTA service and the first removal hearing (waivable by the respondent).
Cancellation — continuous presence10 years (non-LPR) / 7 years continuous residence + 5 years LPRINA § 240A / 8 U.S.C. § 1229bSubject to the stop-time rule: presence ends at NTA service or certain offenses (§ 1229b(d)).
USCIS RFE responseset on the notice (commonly up to ~87 days)8 CFR § 103.2(b)(8)Read the notice — the date printed there controls, not this estimate.
USCIS NOID responseset on the notice (commonly ~33 days)8 CFR § 103.2(b)(8)Read the notice — the printed date controls.
Naturalization — continuous residence / physical presence5 yr residence + 30 mo physical presence (3 yr / 18 mo for § 319 spouses)INA §§ 316 / 319 — 8 U.S.C. §§ 1427 / 1430Continuous-residence and physical-presence are distinct tests; long absences may break continuity.

How to compute (read this before computing anything)

  • There is NO universal mailbox rule in immigration. Do not assume a filing is "timely if mailed." Each forum sets its own receipt/filing rules: the BIA and immigration courts generally count the day the filing is received (8 CFR § 1003.38 / § 1003.3); a circuit petition for review must be filed with the court within 30 days; USCIS counts receipt of the response. Confirm the rule for the specific forum before you compute.
  • Jurisdictional vs. curable. Treat the petition-for-review (INA § 242(b)(1)) and the 30-day BIA appeal (8 CFR § 1003.38) as hard, uncurable deadlines — there is no tolling and no "good cause" extension. Statutory filing bars (the asylum one-year bar) have narrow, enumerated exceptions only. Flag any near-miss loudly in the worksheet.
  • Anchor to the right trigger date. Identify what starts the clock — date of the IJ oral decision, date the written decision was served, date of the final order, date the notice was issued vs. received. The trigger, not "today," controls.
  • Count carefully and conservatively. When a forum's day-counting rule is unclear, compute the earliest plausible due date and treat it as the deadline. Never round in the filer's favor on a jurisdictional clock.
  • Always reconcile against the actual notice. RFE/NOID windows, hearing dates, and voluntary- departure periods are stated on the paper the person holds; the catalog above gives only typical ranges. The notice wins.

Artifacts this skill drafts

  • A deadline-triage worksheet: each applicable clock, its trigger date, its authority, the computed due date, and a jurisdictional / curable flag.
  • A forum-rule note stating how the controlling forum counts time (receipt vs. filing; no mailbox rule) for the specific filing contemplated.
  • A near-miss alert when any computed date is within a short window or already passed, routing to the appropriate motion or review skill.

Related authority

Composition

Runs right after immigration-pro-se and feeds every drafting skill. Hands off to eoir-removal-defense (hearing and relief deadlines, voluntary departure), bia-appeals (the 30-day EOIR-26 clock), circuit-petition-for-review (the jurisdictional 30-day § 1252(b)(1) clock), and eoir-motions-to-reopen-reconsider (the 90-/30-day motion clocks and the in-absentia and changed-country-conditions exceptions). Verify any computed date with immigration-fact-check before filing.

Fact-Check an Immigration Filing

The fastest way to lose credibility before an immigration judge, the Board, a USCIS officer, or a circuit panel is to cite a provision that doesn't exist, confuse the INA section with the 8 U.S.C. section, cite the DHS regulation when the EOIR one governs, or file a brief whose facts contradict the sworn declaration. This skill runs a four-pass check and produces a human-reviewable verification report.

NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Fact-checking verifies the surface — it does not tell the user whether the underlying legal position is sound, nor whether a cited case is still good law on the facts. Immigration consequences are severe and often irreversible; pair this with substantive review by a licensed immigration attorney or an EOIR-accredited representative.

Never silently rewrite. This skill flags issues; the user (and, as needed, the drafting skills) fix them. Silent edits to citations or facts are how hallucinations get filed.

Inputs to gather

  1. Scope — a single document, or the whole packet?
  2. Path(s) — absolute paths to each file.
  3. Forum — USCIS, EOIR immigration court, BIA, circuit, or consular. The forum decides which of the duplicated regulations governs (see traps).
  4. Intended filing date — for catching post-snapshot amendments.

Pass 1 — Citation verification

Parse the document for every citation type — INA (INA § 240), U.S. Code (8 U.S.C. § 1229a), CFR (Title 8 and 22), FAM (9 FAM), BIA/AG precedent (28 I&N Dec. 199), and circuit / Supreme Court (F.3d / U.S.) — then verify each resolves to a real source that supports the stated proposition.

1a. INA ↔ 8 U.S.C. cross-check (the #1 trap)

For every statutory cite, verify both the INA number and the 8 U.S.C. number against the crosswalk in ../../references/immigration-statutes/README.md. The offset is not constant — never compute it. The common right answers: INA § 240 = 8 U.S.C. § 1229a; INA § 212 = 8 U.S.C. § 1182; INA § 245 = 8 U.S.C. § 1255; INA § 208 = 8 U.S.C. § 1158; INA § 242 = 8 U.S.C. § 1252. A brief that says "INA § 240 (8 U.S.C. § 1182)" is mismatched — flag it. Confirm the verbatim text in the matching ../../references/immigration-statutes/ subchapter file actually says what the draft claims.

1b. CFR cross-check against the regulation corpus

Resolve each CFR cite against the file in ../../references/immigration-regulations/ (e.g., 8CFR-1240-removal-eoir.md, 22CFR-042-immigrant-visas.md). Confirm the part/section exists and supports the proposition.

1c. Case-law verification (CourtListener)

Case law is not snapshotted — verify on demand per ../../references/legal-data-apis.md. Use the bundled CourtListener MCP server (declared in this plugin's .mcp.json; if its tools are absent, have the user run /mcp to sign in) — the citation-lookup / search tools, per the immigration-case-law skill — to confirm a circuit opinion is real and says what the draft claims — watch for circuit misattribution (the Ninth Circuit ca9 has the largest immigration docket). BIA precedent is cited "I&N Dec." (e.g., Matter of A-B-, 28 I&N Dec. 199 (BIA 2021)) — EOIR's Virtual Law Library is the publisher of record and CourtListener indexes many; confirm the precedent has not been certified/overruled by the Attorney General.

Flag each cite RED (does not resolve — possible hallucination), YELLOW (resolves but does not support the proposition / overstates it), ORANGE (resolves and supports, but the provision was amended since the quoted version), or GREEN (resolves, supports, current).

The three immigration citation traps

  • INA-vs-8-U.S.C. mismatch. See Pass 1a. Verify both numbers; never assume a constant offset.
  • DHS-vs-EOIR regulation duplication. Several regulations exist in two parallel versions — the DHS copy and the EOIR copy — and the draft must cite the one that governs its forum:
    SubjectDHS (USCIS / CBP / ICE)EOIR (court / BIA)
    Asylum8 CFR Part 2088 CFR Part 1208
    Removal proceedings8 CFR Part 2408 CFR Part 1240
    EOIR / BIA procedure—8 CFR Part 1003
    A removal-defense brief filed in immigration court that cites "8 CFR § 208.13"
    (DHS) instead of "8 CFR § 1208.13" (EOIR) is citing the wrong sovereign's
    rule — flag it YELLOW and point to the forum-correct part in the
    regulation corpus.
  • FAM is guidance, not law. A 9 FAM / 8 FAM / 7 FAM cite is State Department internal guidance, not binding authority. Never let a FAM cite stand alone — flag any FAM cite that is not paired with the controlling INA / 8 CFR / 22 CFR provision, and verify the FAM text against ../../references/foreign-affairs-manual/.

Pass 2 — Internal consistency

Within a single document, verify:

  • A-number (A2NN-NNN-NNN) is identical every time it appears, and matches the NTA / receipt notice. A drifting A-number is a blocker.
  • Receipt numbers (XYZ + 10 digits), priority dates, and A-file references are consistent.
  • Dates agree (date of entry, NTA service date, hearing date, deadline math). A "30 days from service" claim should compute correctly.
  • Party / declarant names and country of nationality are styled consistently throughout.
  • Paragraph and exhibit cross-references ("as stated in ¶ 12") actually point where they claim.

Pass 3 — Packet consistency

Across every document in the filing (brief, motion, declaration, exhibit index, proposed order, certificate of service):

  • Caption — identical forum/court, A-number, and party names on every page.
  • Cross-referenced facts — the brief's fact recitation matches the declaration's sworn content; exhibits cited in the brief match the exhibit index.
  • Relief requested — the motion's prayer matches the proposed order.
  • Service — the certificate lists every party (and, in EOIR matters, DHS / the ICE Office of the Principal Legal Advisor).

Pass 4 — Sworn-vs.-argued consistency

The brief contains arguments; the declaration / affidavit contains sworn facts. Verify:

  • Every factual assertion in the brief has a sworn source (declaration ¶ or exhibit) — flag unsupported assertions.
  • No argument contradicts a sworn statement (e.g., brief says "entered in 2019"; declaration swears "2018").
  • Each declarant attests only within personal knowledge; flag hearsay.

Producing the report

Output a structured report with a summary count (GREEN / ORANGE / YELLOW / RED + consistency issues), one section per pass with the exact location and suggested fix, and a prioritized fix list tagged BLOCKER (hallucinated cite, INA/USC mismatch, wrong-forum regulation, A-number drift, sworn-vs-argued contradiction), IMPORTANT (amended text, unpaired FAM cite, internal inconsistency), or SUGGESTED (stronger authority available; stylistic drift). Keep it readable — a 2-page report that prioritizes blockers beats a 50-page dump.

Handling fetch failures

If a canonical fetch fails, flag the item UNVERIFIED (fetch failed) — distinct from RED (hallucination) — and continue. Report unverified items separately so the user can confirm them manually. Do not silently rewrite.

Artifacts this skill drafts

  • A verification report (the four-pass output above).
  • A citation table mapping each cite to its INA/USC pair, forum-correct regulation, and verification status.
  • A prioritized fix list (BLOCKER / IMPORTANT / SUGGESTED).

Related authority

Composition

Runs after any drafting skill and before filing. Composes with immigration-pro-se (orientation), eoir-removal-defense, eoir-motions-to-reopen-reconsider, bia-appeals, uscis-benefit-requests, consular-visa-refusal, and circuit-petition-for-review (re-draft flagged items by handing back to the originating skill), and with immigration-deadlines (to confirm any deadline math the draft asserts).

Immigration — FOIA / Privacy Act for Your Own Records

NOT LEGAL ADVICE. This skill produces FOIA/Privacy Act request scaffolds and checklists — not legal advice, and no attorney-client relationship is created. A FOIA request does not pause any deadline: an upcoming hearing date, a BIA-appeal clock, or a petition-for-review clock keeps running while the agency processes the request. Verify the current form edition, the correct FOIA office address/portal, and every deadline against current law, and consider consulting a licensed immigration attorney or an EOIR-accredited representative.

FOIA goes first

You usually cannot defend a case well — or even know what you are defending against — without the underlying government record. The Notice to Appear (NTA), every prior application and its adjudication, the inspecting officer's narrative (the Form I-213, Record of Deportable / Inadmissible Alien), interview notes, the entry/inspection history, and any derogatory information the government will rely on all live in agency files. Pulling them is the foundation for eoir-removal-defense, uscis-benefit-requests, and any reopening motion.

The record is split across agencies, and each has its own FOIA channel. A single request to one agency will not give you the whole picture — match the record you need to the office that holds it.

The four record sources

RecordAgency / officeHow to requestWhat you get
A-file (Alien File — the master file)USCIS (DHS)Form G-639 via the USCIS FOIA online portal (FIRST) or by mail to the USCIS National Records CenterThe consolidated immigration history: prior petitions/applications, approvals/denials, RFEs, biometrics, the NTA copy, interagency referrals
Record of Proceedings (ROP)EOIR (DOJ) FOIA officeWritten request (no special form) to EOIR's FOIA Service Center, by mail or the DOJ portalWhat is actually before the immigration court / Board: the IJ's file, hearing record, filings, orders — the document set your removal case turns on
Enforcement / detention recordsICE (DHS) FOIA officeLetter or the DHS/ICE FOIA portalDetention records, enforcement actions, custody/bond history, ICE narratives
Entry / inspection recordsCBP (DHS) FOIA officeLetter or the CBP FOIA portalBorder-inspection and admission records, the I-213, travel/entry history, secondary-inspection notes

Practical mechanics: file with USCIS through the online FOIA portal when possible (faster intake and status tracking than mail); USCIS sorts requests into processing tracks (simple vs. complex, plus an expedite track). Always cite the A-number (A2NN-NNN-NNN) on every request — it is the file key across DHS and EOIR and prevents misrouting. If you do not yet have the A-number, see immigration-pro-se for how to locate it.

The legal basis

  • FOIA — 5 U.S.C. § 552 gives any person the right to request agency records.
  • Privacy Act — 5 U.S.C. § 552a gives a U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident the right to records the agency keeps about them, and is the stronger first-party access route where it applies.
  • These two statutes are the general federal access framework; they are not part of this plugin's corpus, so cite them by number (do not link them as corpus files).
  • The DHS-component disclosure framework is at 6 CFR part 5, cross-referenced from the immigration regulations at 8 CFR § 103.42 (FOIA/Privacy Act rules) — see ../../references/immigration-regulations/8CFR-103-powers-fees.md. Published precedent decisions are separately made available under 8 CFR § 103.10(e).
  • First-party records require identity verification + the requester's signature. A G-639 (or an equivalent letter) must include the requester's signed certification of identity; a request by someone other than the subject needs the subject's notarized/sworn consent or proof of authority (e.g., the representative's G-28). Without a valid signature/identity proof the agency will narrow the release to non-personal material or deny it.

Expedite when there is a hearing date

EOIR runs an expedited FOIA track for people with a scheduled hearing date. State the date, time, and immigration-court location prominently at the top of the EOIR ROP request and ask for expedited processing on that basis. The same expedite ask can be made to USCIS, ICE, and CBP when a near-term hearing or filing deadline creates urgency — but remember a FOIA request does not toll any deadline, so file the substantive defense work in parallel; do not wait on the records to act.

Artifacts this skill drafts

  • A USCIS A-file FOIA request in Form G-639 style (signed identity certification; A-number; scope description), routable to the online portal or the National Records Center.
  • An EOIR Record-of-Proceedings FOIA request to the EOIR FOIA Service Center, with expedite language keyed to the upcoming hearing date.
  • ICE and CBP FOIA request letters for enforcement/detention and entry/inspection records (including a specific ask for the I-213).
  • A "records I need" checklist — NTA, prior applications and adjudications, I-213, officer narratives, entry/inspection history, biometrics, prior orders — mapped to the agency that holds each.

Related authority

Composition

Comes early — typically right after immigration-pro-se establishes the forum and the A-number. Feeds the record it obtains into eoir-removal-defense (to plead to the NTA and build relief applications), uscis-benefit-requests (to reconcile prior filings before a new one), and any reopening work. Run immigration-deadlines in parallel, because the FOIA request never stops the clock.

Immigration — Pro Se Orientation

NOT LEGAL ADVICE. This skill and everything in this plugin produce drafting aids, checklists, and document scaffolds — not legal advice, and no attorney-client relationship is created. Immigration consequences (removal, bars to reentry, loss of status) are severe and often irreversible. Verify every deadline, form edition, and citation against current law, and strongly consider consulting a licensed immigration attorney or an EOIR-accredited representative before filing anything.

Why this skill goes first

U.S. immigration practice is split across four forums that do not share rules, deadlines, or filing systems. Picking the wrong one wastes the (often single) chance to act. Identify the forum before drafting:

ForumWhat it decidesGoverning rulesRoute to
USCIS (DHS)Benefit requests — petitions, applications, status8 CFR ch. I; the INAuscis-benefit-requests
EOIR immigration court (DOJ)Removal / deportation; relief in proceedings8 CFR Part 1003 / 1240 / 1208; ICPMeoir-removal-defense, eoir-motions-to-reopen-reconsider
Board of Immigration Appeals (DOJ)Appeals from immigration-judge decisions8 CFR § 1003.1–§ 1003.8; BIAPMbia-appeals
U.S. Court of AppealsJudicial review of a final removal orderINA § 242 / 8 U.S.C. § 1252circuit-petition-for-review
Department of State (consular)Visa issuance / refusal abroadINA; 22 CFR 40–42; 9 FAMconsular-visa-refusal

The full EOIR court system is described in eoir-immigration-courts; the master deadline catalog is in immigration-deadlines. Statutory text lives in ../../references/immigration-statutes/ — cite by the INA → 8 U.S.C. crosswalk in that corpus's README (INA § 240 = 8 U.S.C. § 1229a, INA § 212 = 8 U.S.C. § 1182, etc.), not from memory.

First three things to establish

  1. The A-number. The "A-number" (Alien Registration Number, A2NN-NNN-NNN) is the person's file key across DHS and EOIR. It is on the NTA, USCIS notices, and the green card. Every filing and FOIA request keys off it.
  2. Where the case actually is. A person can have matters in more than one forum at once. Locate each:
    • In removal proceedings? Check the EOIR automated case-information system (by A-number) for the next hearing date and the filing deadline.
    • A pending USCIS case? Check the USCIS online account / receipt number (XYZ + 10 digits) and the case-status tool.
    • Pull the record before drafting — see immigration-foia for getting the A-file (USCIS) and the Record of Proceedings (EOIR).
  3. The controlling deadline. Immigration deadlines are short and frequently jurisdictional (a missed BIA-appeal or petition-for-review deadline usually cannot be cured). Run immigration-deadlines immediately.

Representation — who may appear, and the fraud warning

  • You may represent yourself ("pro se" / "self-represented") in any forum.
  • In EOIR proceedings, a representative enters via Form EOIR-28; before USCIS, via Form G-28. Only (a) licensed attorneys in good standing and (b) EOIR-accredited representatives at recognized organizations may represent you (8 CFR Part 1292 / § 1003.16). Free / low-cost providers are listed on EOIR's pro-bono and recognized- organization rosters.
  • Notario / "immigration consultant" warning. In much of Latin America a notario público is a licensed attorney; in the U.S. a "notary" is not a lawyer and may not give legal advice or select forms for you. Notario fraud is a leading cause of lost cases and missed deadlines. A non-attorney who fills in forms for a fee, claims special government connections, or tells you to hide facts is a red flag — document it (consumer-harm-documentation in the federal plugin can scaffold the record).
  • Language access. EOIR provides interpreters at hearings at no cost; request the correct language in advance. Translated documents filed with the court or USCIS need a certificate of translation.

How to use the rest of this plugin

  • Format / filing mechanics for immigration court & the BIA → eoir-immigration-courts (the ICPM / BIA Practice Manual conventions and the binding 8 CFR Part 1003 rules).
  • Verify any citation a draft makes → immigration-fact-check.
  • Removal defense filings (EOIR-28, pleadings to the NTA, continuances, change of venue, applications for relief) → eoir-removal-defense.
  • Reopen or reconsider a removal order (including in-absentia orders) → eoir-motions-to-reopen-reconsider.
  • Appeal an IJ decision to the Board → bia-appeals.
  • USCIS cover letters, evidence indexes, RFE/NOID responses → uscis-benefit-requests.
  • Visa refused at a consulate (§ 221(g), § 212(a) ineligibility, waivers) → consular-visa-refusal.
  • Judicial review of a final removal order → circuit-petition-for-review.

Artifacts this skill drafts

  • A forum / posture worksheet (which forum(s), A-number, receipt numbers, next dates).
  • A case-location checklist (EOIR portal, USCIS account, FOIA to pull the file).
  • A deadline triage note that hands off to immigration-deadlines.

Related authority

Composition

Goes first, then routes to the forum-specific skills above. Composes with the state *-pro-se skills (for any parallel state-court matter) and with the federal consumer-harm-documentation skill (to log notario fraud or agency misconduct).

USCIS Benefit Requests — Cover Letters, Evidence Indexes, RFE/NOID Responses

NOT LEGAL ADVICE. This skill produces drafting aids, checklists, and document scaffolds — not legal advice, and no attorney-client relationship is created. USCIS deadlines (especially RFE / NOID response dates) are unforgiving and a defective filing can sink an otherwise approvable case. Verify every form edition, fee, deadline, and citation against current USCIS instructions and strongly consider consulting a licensed immigration attorney or an EOIR-accredited representative before filing.

USCIS is its own forum — not immigration court

USCIS (within DHS) adjudicates benefit requests — petitions and applications — almost entirely on the papers, under 8 CFR § 103.2. This is a different forum from EOIR immigration court (removal), the Board of Immigration Appeals, the consulates, and the circuit courts; see immigration-pro-se for the four-forum map. Because USCIS rarely holds a hearing, the written package is the case: what you enclose, how it is organized, and how completely you answer a request is usually all the adjudicator sees.

A request is "received" on the date USCIS actually receives it at the designated filing location, paper or electronic (8 CFR § 103.2(b)(7)), and USCIS issues a receipt notice (Form I-797) with a receipt number (3 letters + 10 digits). Track it on the USCIS case-status tool and online account, and keep a complete copy of everything filed — you will need it to respond to any later RFE or NOID.

Common benefit contexts (route substantive eligibility elsewhere — this skill only builds the paperwork):

FormBenefitStatute
I-130Family petition (relative)INA § 204 / 8 U.S.C. § 1154
I-140Employment-based immigrant petitionINA § 204 / 8 U.S.C. § 1154
I-485Adjustment of status to LPRINA § 245 / 8 U.S.C. § 1255
N-400NaturalizationINA §§ 316 / 319 / 8 U.S.C. §§ 1427 / 1430

The cover letter and the evidence index

Cover letter. Every package opens with a one- to two-page cover letter that lets the adjudicator orient instantly. It should state:

  • Petitioner / applicant and beneficiary by full legal name, with the A-number (A2NN-NNN-NNN) and any prior receipt number.
  • The form and the benefit sought (e.g., "Form I-130, Petition for Alien Relative, on behalf of [spouse]") and the classification claimed.
  • The filing fee enclosed (or fee-waiver request) and the form edition date.
  • An itemized list of enclosures, keyed to the tabs of the evidence index.
  • A signature block (petitioner pro se, or G-28 representative of record).

Evidence index / exhibit list. Behind the cover letter, list every supporting document as a numbered or lettered exhibit (Tab A, Tab B, … or Exhibit 1, 2, …), with a one- line description and the physical tab/label that matches the document in the packet. Put translations with a certificate of translation next to each foreign-language original. A clean, tabbed index is what makes a package easy to approve — and is exactly what you re- use when responding to an RFE.

Initial evidence. USCIS expects the required initial evidence for the benefit with the filing; if it is missing or doesn't demonstrate eligibility, USCIS may deny outright or issue an RFE (8 CFR § 103.2(b)(1)–(2), (b)(8)(ii)). Build the index against the form instructions' evidence list so nothing required is omitted.

Responding to an RFE or a NOID — the cardinal rules

An RFE (Request for Evidence) asks for more evidence; a NOID (Notice of Intent to Deny) signals USCIS is inclined to deny and gives a last chance to rebut. Both are governed by 8 CFR § 103.2(b)(8). The rules that decide cases:

  1. Respond by the deadline PRINTED ON THE NOTICE. Never assume a fixed number of days — read the notice and diary that exact date. The regulation caps the maximum response window (RFE no more than twelve weeks; NOID no more than thirty days) and provides that additional time may not be granted (§ 103.2(b)(8)(iv)). The notice's own date controls; run it through immigration-deadlines.
  2. Address every item. Answer each numbered request point-by-point; an unanswered item is treated as not established.
  3. Submit ALL evidence at once. All requested materials must be filed together in a single response, along with the original RFE/NOID notice on top (§ 103.2(b)(11)). A partial response is adjudicated on the record as filed — submitting only some of the requested evidence "will be considered a request for a decision on the record." There is no second bite.
  4. Failing to respond = abandonment. No timely response means the request "may be summarily denied as abandoned, denied based on the record, or both" (§ 103.2(b)(13)).

Structure an RFE/NOID response as: a cover letter re-identifying the case and receipt number; a copy of the original notice on top; then a point-by-point response mirroring the notice's numbering, each item cross-referenced to a tab in a fresh evidence index.

Expedite requests

USCIS may, in its discretion, expedite a pending case that meets one of the published expedite criteria (e.g., severe financial loss to a person or company; an emergency or urgent humanitarian situation; a nonprofit's cultural/social-interest request; a clear USCIS error; certain government interests). An expedite request is made through the USCIS contact channels for the pending receipt number and should: identify the case and receipt number, name the specific criterion invoked, and attach documentary proof of the urgency (it is discretionary — assertion without evidence rarely succeeds). Frame it tightly to the criterion; do not pad it.

Artifacts this skill drafts

  • USCIS cover letter — petitioner/beneficiary, A-number, receipt number, form + benefit sought, fee, and an itemized enclosure list.
  • Evidence index / exhibit list — tabbed (Tab A… or Exhibit 1…), one line per item, with translation-certificate placement.
  • RFE response scaffold — original notice on top + point-by-point answers keyed to a new evidence index, built to the deadline on the notice.
  • NOID response scaffold — rebuttal addressing each stated basis for the proposed denial, with all evidence submitted at once.
  • Expedite-request letter — receipt number, the specific expedite criterion, and the proof of urgency attached.

Each artifact ends with the NOT LEGAL ADVICE disclaimer.

Related authority

Composition

  • Start with immigration-pro-se to confirm USCIS is the right forum and to capture the A-number / receipt number.
  • Run every RFE / NOID deadline through immigration-deadlines — the date on the notice controls and cannot be extended.
  • Pull the underlying file (A-file / receipt-history) via immigration-foia before responding to an RFE or NOID.
  • Verify every citation and form edition a draft makes with immigration-fact-check.

Sponsors

Details

Marketplace
codearranger/claude-legal
Source
plugins/claude-legal-immigration-laws
Category
Legal
Keywords
legal, immigration, immigration-law, ina, 8-usc, 8-cfr, 22-cfr, foreign-affairs-manual, fam, eoir, bia, aao, uscis, circuit-courts, petition-for-review, removal, asylum, naturalization, shared-references, courtlistener, legal-data-hunter, mcp

More from codearranger/claude-legal

All 15