
ny-court-docs
New York court documents: 22 NYCRR § 202.5 / § 202.5-b NYSCEF formatting; five flagship Supreme Court venues plus District / City / Justice / Family / Housing courts; five subject bundles (consumer-debt, landlord-tenant, personal-injury, employment, commercial-disputes). Full detail in the plugin README.
- GitHub stars
- 26
Install
/plugin install ny-court-docs@claude-legalRun it inside Claude Code after adding the marketplace with /plugin marketplace add codearranger/claude-legal.
Contents
Discovered from sourceSkills 35
Bronx County Supreme Court
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Verify the assigned Justice's Part Rules before every filing.
At a glance
- Court: Supreme Court of the State of New York, Bronx County (12th Judicial District)
- Courthouse: 851 Grand Concourse, Bronx NY 10451 (Mario Merola Building)
- Commercial Division threshold: $150,000
- E-filing: NYSCEF mandatory for most civil case types
- Hearings: Microsoft Teams for routine; in-person for trials; remote Mandatory Settlement Conferences
Distinctives
Personal-injury volume
Bronx County has historically been New York's highest-volume personal-injury trial venue. The county has a dedicated Personal Injury Part (IAS) calendar with its own calendaring practices. Pro se litigants in non-PI matters should expect substantial scheduling pressure as a consequence.
CPLR 3408 foreclosure conferences
Bronx County, like Kings and Queens, runs a Foreclosure Settlement Conference Part for home-loan foreclosures under CPLR 3408.
Trial-readiness practice
Bronx Justices typically enforce strict Note-of-Issue deadlines and aggressive trial calendars. The county has been a Civil Differentiated Case Management (DCM) pilot jurisdiction.
Filing checklist
- NYSCEF: Summons + Complaint via NYSCEF; $210 fee
- RJI: UCS-840 filed before motion practice
- Service: CPLR 306-b — within 120 days
- Preliminary Conference: scheduled by IAS Part under 22 NYCRR § 202.12
Part Rules
Bronx County Part Rules: https://ww2.nycourts.gov/courts/12jd/supreme/civil/PartRules.shtml
Verify the assigned Justice's current rules every filing.
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-statewide-format— baseline formatny-discovery— CPLR Article 31 discovery mechanicsny-first-30-days— answer / pre-answer motion triageny-file-packet— NYSCEF assemblyny-consumer-debt— foreclosure / debt-buyer defenseny-landlord-tenant— Bronx Housing Court cross-reference
Upstate City Courts (UCCA / 22 NYCRR Part 210)
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Verify the specific City Court's local rules, dollar caps, and e-filing rollout before every filing.
At a glance
- Court system: City Courts established under the
Uniform City Court Act (UCCA) of 1965 with procedural
rules at 22 NYCRR Part 210. Each city of population
10,000 outside NYC operates a City Court.
- Civil jurisdiction: up to $15,000 (UCCA § 202)
- Small claims: up to $5,000 in most cities; $3,000 in the smaller City Courts (UCCA § 1801); check the local court rules
- Commercial claims: up to $5,000 in cities where the Commercial Claims Part has been established (UCCA § 1801-A)
- L&T (summary proceedings): where the City Court has a Housing Part, RPAPL Article 7 summary proceedings; in smaller cities without a Housing Part, L&T goes to the Civil Part with RPAPL Article 7 procedure
- E-filing: NYSCEF mandatory or available in Buffalo, Rochester, Syracuse, Albany, Yonkers, White Plains, and expanding; many smaller City Courts still rely on paper filings
~60 City Courts statewide
The major ones (by civil filing volume):
| City Court | County | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Buffalo City Court | Erie | Largest upstate; Housing Part; NYSCEF mandatory |
| Rochester City Court | Monroe | Housing Part; NYSCEF expanding |
| Syracuse City Court | Onondaga | Housing Part; NYSCEF available |
| Albany City Court | Albany | Civil + Criminal Parts; NYSCEF |
| Yonkers City Court | Westchester | Largest in Westchester; NYSCEF |
| White Plains City Court | Westchester | NYSCEF |
| New Rochelle City Court | Westchester | NYSCEF |
| Mount Vernon City Court | Westchester | NYSCEF |
| Niagara Falls City Court | Niagara | NYSCEF |
| Schenectady City Court | Schenectady | NYSCEF |
| Utica City Court | Oneida | |
| Troy City Court | Rensselaer | |
| Binghamton City Court | Broome | |
| Auburn City Court | Cayuga | |
| Watertown City Court | Jefferson | |
| Glen Cove City Court | Nassau | Functions like a District Court Sixth District for civil |
| Long Beach City Court | Nassau | Functions like a District Court Fifth District for civil |
| Newburgh City Court | Orange | |
| Poughkeepsie City Court | Dutchess | |
| Beacon City Court | Dutchess |
Note: Long Beach City Court and Glen Cove City Court overlap with the Nassau District Court's Fifth and Sixth Districts — confirm which court the summons names before filing a response.
Distinctives
UCCA is parallel to the UDCA
The Uniform City Court Act tracks the Uniform District
Court Act closely. 22 NYCRR Part 210 mirrors 22 NYCRR Part
212 with City Court-specific terminology. A practitioner
who has handled a Nassau District Court matter (ny-nassau-dc)
will find the City Court procedural framework familiar.
CCFA applies in full
The 2022 Consumer Credit Fairness Act applies in City Courts the same way it applies in NYC Civil Court and the Long Island District Courts. CPLR 3015(e) heightened pleading, 22 NYCRR § 202.27-a default-judgment scrutiny (applied through the parallel Part 210 rule), and CPLR 214-i 3-year SOL all apply.
Housing Parts vary
Buffalo, Rochester, Syracuse, and Yonkers operate dedicated Housing Parts modeled on NYC Housing Court. Other cities hear L&T summary proceedings in the Civil Part. RPAPL Article 7 procedure (14-day rent demand under § 711(2), 30/60/90-day holdover notice under RPL § 226-c) applies statewide regardless of forum.
2024 Good Cause Eviction — opt-in outside NYC
NYS Good Cause Eviction (RPL Article 6-A) applies in NYC by default. Outside NYC, the law is opt-in by municipality. Cities that have opted in (as of mid-2025):
- Albany — opted in 2024
- Newburgh — opted in 2024
- Kingston — opted in 2024
- Poughkeepsie — opted in 2024
- Hudson — opted in 2024
- Beacon — opted in 2024
- Syracuse — opted in 2024
Buffalo, Rochester, Schenectady, and several others debated opt-in but had not adopted as of early 2026. Verify the specific municipality's status when drafting a Good Cause defense.
Right to Counsel — limited but expanding
NYC's universal Right to Counsel (Local Law 136 of 2017) is being modeled in upstate jurisdictions. Albany, Newburgh, and Rochester have piloted RTC programs for income-qualifying tenants. Most upstate cities still operate without universal RTC; legal aid organizations are the principal source of representation:
- Legal Aid Buffalo — Erie / Niagara
- Legal Assistance of Western New York (LawNY) — Rochester / Western NY
- Hiscock Legal Aid Society — Syracuse / CNY
- Legal Aid Society of Northeastern New York — Albany / North Country
- Legal Services of the Hudson Valley — Westchester / Putnam / Dutchess / Rockland / Ulster / Orange / Sullivan
- Mid-Hudson Legal Services — Dutchess
Trial-de-novo in Small Claims
City Court Small Claims Part trials are conducted by arbitrators (volunteer attorneys) under UCCA § 1804-A. The losing party has the right to a trial-de-novo before a sitting City Court judge under UCCA § 1808 — but the demand must be served before the arbitration begins.
Filing checklist
- Summons + Complaint — UCCA § 401, $45 filing fee (UCCA § 1911); affidavit of service per CPLR 308
- Answer — defendant has 20 days from personal service or 30 days from substituted service (CPLR 320(a))
- Pre-trial conference — most City Courts schedule within 60-90 days
- Trial — bench trial typically 6-9 months from filing for Civil Part actions
Format compliance: 22 NYCRR Part 210 governs filings here. Use
ny-statewide-formatas the baseline; Part 210 mirrors Part 202 with City Court-specific adjustments (caption uses "[City] City Court" instead of "Supreme Court").
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-statewide-format— baseline 22 NYCRR Part 202 format with Part 210 City Court adjustmentsny-nyc-civil-court— distinct court for cases inside NYCny-justice-courts— Town & Village Justice Courts for cases outside any city's territorial reachny-discovery— CPLR Article 31 mechanics (City Court Civil Part typically light on discovery)ny-first-30-days— Answer / pre-answer motion triageny-consumer-debt— CCFA pleading + default scrutinyny-landlord-tenant— RPAPL Article 7 mechanics for Housing Parts and Civil Parts handling L&Tny-pro-se— pro se frameworkny-file-packet— NYSCEF (where mandatory) or paper- filing assembly
Pro-se resources
- LawNY (rochester / WNY)
- Legal Aid Buffalo (erie / niagara)
- Hiscock Legal Aid Society (CNY)
- Legal Aid Society of Northeastern New York (capital region)
- Legal Services of the Hudson Valley (LSHV)
- NYS Office of Court Administration Pro Se forms —
nycourts.gov/courthelp/ - Each City Court runs a Pro Se Help Desk during clerk's hours
New York Commercial Litigation
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Commercial Division practice has rules that materially differ from general Supreme Court practice; verify the assigned Commercial Division Justice's Part Rules and the venue's Commercial Division threshold before filing.
SOL catalog (the most-used)
| Claim | SOL | Citation |
|---|---|---|
| Breach of contract (written or oral) | 6 years | CPLR 213(2) |
| Breach of fiduciary duty | 3 or 6 years — depends on remedy sought (3 yr if damages; 6 yr if equitable / fraud-adjacent) | CPLR 214(4) / 213(7); IDT Corp. v. Morgan Stanley |
| Fraud | 6 years (or 2 years from discovery, whichever is later) | CPLR 213(8) |
| Account stated | 6 years (tracks the underlying contract) | CPLR 213(2) |
| UCC Article 2 (sales) breach of warranty | 4 years | UCC § 2-725 |
| UCC Article 3 negotiable instrument | 6 years | CPLR 213(2) / UCC § 3-118 |
| Conversion | 3 years | CPLR 214(3) |
| Tortious interference with K | 3 years | CPLR 214(4) |
| Tortious interference with prospective economic advantage | 3 years | CPLR 214(4) |
| Breach of fiduciary duty (in BCL § 720 derivative action) | 6 years | CPLR 213(7); BCL § 720 |
| BCL § 1104-a oppression / judicial dissolution | no SOL — equitable | BCL § 1104-a |
The Commercial Division (22 NYCRR § 202.70)
The Commercial Division is a specialized Part within Supreme Court Civil Term — a single Justice (or rotating panel of designated Justices) hears commercial cases with their own procedural rule set. Different rules apply to Commercial Division cases than to regular Supreme Court cases.
County-by-county monetary thresholds
| County | Threshold |
|---|---|
| New York County | $500,000 |
| Westchester County | $200,000 |
| Nassau County | $200,000 |
| Queens / Kings / Bronx | $150,000 |
| Erie / Suffolk | $100,000 |
| Albany / Onondaga | $50,000 |
| Monroe | $50,000 |
(Verify the current 22 NYCRR § 202.70(a) table before filing — thresholds adjust periodically.)
Subject-matter qualification (22 NYCRR § 202.70(b))
Commercial Division qualifying matters include (non- exhaustive):
- Breach of contract / business dealings
- UCC transactions
- Transactions between commercial entities
- Joint venture / partnership disputes
- Internal-affairs disputes of business entities
- Breach of fiduciary duty by directors / officers
- Statutory shareholder oppression / dissolution
- Securities disputes (subject to federal preemption)
- Antitrust under NY Donnelly Act (Gen Bus Law § 340)
- Commercial real-property disputes (not residential L&T)
Excluded even if over the threshold: PI, wrongful death, matrimonial, residential L&T, criminal, consumer-debt collection.
Commercial Division-specific rules
The Comm Div has its own rule set at 22 NYCRR § 202.70 with Appendix A containing 36 specific rules. Highlights:
- Rule 1 (Appearance by Designated Counsel) — partner / designated attorney must appear at conferences
- Rule 8 (Consultation Prior to Preliminary Conference) — meet-and-confer on the scheduling order template
- Rule 11-a (25-Question Interrogatory Cap) — even more restrictive than CPLR 3130's 25-question default
- Rule 11-c (Proportionality in Discovery) — the proportionality test for ESI / document production
- Rule 11-d (Privilege Logs) — categorical privilege logs accepted instead of document-by-document
- Rule 16 (Direct Testimony By Affidavit) — bench-trial direct examination by affidavit
- Rule 17 (Length of Papers) — 25 pages for memos of law (more than the 22 NYCRR § 202.8-b 10-page default in regular Supreme Court); 5 pages for affirmations in support; 35 pages for memos on dispositive motions
- Rule 19 (Adjournments) — strict adjournment policy
- Rule 33 (Accelerated Adjudication) — opt-in expedited procedure with discovery limits + early-trial scheduling
Substantive frameworks
CPLR 3016(b) — heightened fraud pleading
Fraud allegations must be pled with particularity under CPLR 3016(b). The complaint must specify:
- The specific misrepresentation (precise words, date, speaker, audience)
- The falsity of the statement
- The scienter (knowledge of falsity or reckless disregard)
- The reliance (justifiable)
- The damages caused by reliance
A complaint that pleads fraud in general terms is subject to dismissal under CPLR 3211(a)(7) for failure to state a cause of action.
BCL § 720 — derivative action for fiduciary breach
Shareholders may bring a derivative action on behalf of the corporation against directors and officers for:
- Breach of fiduciary duty
- Self-dealing / conflict of interest
- Waste of corporate assets
Demand requirement: under Marx v. Akers, 88 N.Y.2d 189 (1996), the shareholder must either make a demand on the board or plead demand-futility with particularity.
BCL § 1104-a — judicial dissolution / shareholder oppression
Holders of 20%+ shares in a closely-held corporation can petition for judicial dissolution on grounds of:
- Illegal, fraudulent, or oppressive actions toward the petitioner
- Looting, wasting, or diverting of corporate assets
The corporation can avoid dissolution by electing to purchase the petitioner's shares at fair value under BCL § 1118 — a procedural escape valve used in many cases.
LLC Law § 702 — LLC judicial dissolution
LLCs have an analogous dissolution remedy under LLC Law § 702 — judicial dissolution available when it is "not reasonably practicable" to carry on the LLC business. Matter of 1545 Ocean Avenue LLC, 72 A.D.3d 121 (2d Dep't 2010), is the leading interpretation.
Faithless Servant Doctrine
NY recognizes the Faithless Servant Doctrine — an employee who commits substantial disloyalty during employment forfeits all compensation paid during the period of disloyalty, even if some work was actually performed. Phansalkar v. Andersen Weinroth & Co., 344 F.3d 184 (2d Cir. 2003) is the key articulation.
Pre-judgment interest (CPLR 5001 / 5004)
NY pre-judgment interest in contract cases is 9% per annum (CPLR 5004) — substantially higher than market rates. The interest accrues from the date of breach. The plaintiff in a long-running contract dispute may recover substantial interest at trial.
For tort claims, pre-judgment interest runs from the date the cause of action accrues (CPLR 5001(a)) — but is not available for personal-injury pain-and-suffering damages.
Choice of law + forum selection (GOL §§ 5-1401, 5-1402)
NY General Obligations Law makes NY especially friendly to commercial parties choosing NY law / NY forum:
- GOL § 5-1401: a NY choice-of-law clause is enforceable in contracts involving at least $250,000 even if the contract has no other NY contact
- GOL § 5-1402: a NY choice-of-forum clause is enforceable in contracts involving at least $1,000,000 even if the parties have no other NY contact
These rules make NY a destination forum for sophisticated commercial contracts — many M&A agreements, large financing arrangements, and tech deals choose NY law and forum specifically for the GOL §§ 5-1401 / 5-1402 enforceability.
Account stated — debt-collection adjacent
In commercial-debt-collection actions, the account stated doctrine is a major cause of action. The elements:
- Account rendered (typically by invoice or statement)
- Express or implied acknowledgment of the account by the debtor
- Failure to object within a reasonable time (silence may be acknowledgment)
The 6-year SOL under CPLR 213(2) governs. Default-judgment practice in commercial collections often combines breach of contract + account stated for redundant pleading.
BCL § 624 — books-and-records inspection
Shareholders can compel a corporation to permit inspection of books and records by proper purpose demand under BCL § 624. Common in lead-up to derivative actions or shareholder oppression petitions.
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-statewide-format— caption + Notice of Motion formatny-discovery— CPLR Article 31; Commercial Division proportionality rule + privilege log + interrogatory cap are stricter than general Supreme Courtny-first-30-days— Answer + CPLR 3211(a) pre-answer motionsny-deadlines— SOL + 22 NYCRR § 202.8-b page limits (vs. Comm Div Rule 17 25/35-page rules)ny-hearings— motion practice and trial structureny-fact-check— citation patterns (Marx v. Akers; 1545 Ocean Avenue; IDT Corp. v. Morgan Stanley; Reed, Roberts Associates)ny-nyco(1st JD Comm Div $500k threshold),ny-kings($150k threshold),ny-bronx,ny-nassau($200k threshold),ny-queens($150k threshold) — venue selection for Commercial Divisionny-pro-se— pro se practice in Comm Div is rare due to the $50k-$500k thresholds + complexity
High-yield commercial checks
- Commercial Division eligibility? Monetary threshold
- subject-matter qualification + statement at filing?
- CPLR 3016(b) particularity met for fraud claims?
- CPLR 213(2) 6-year breach vs CPLR 213(8) 6/2-year fraud discovery rule?
- GOL §§ 5-1401 / 5-1402 forum/choice-of-law for contract enforceability?
- BCL § 720 derivative-action demand requirement or demand-futility pleading?
- BCL § 1104-a / LLC § 702 dissolution petition with § 1118 buyout-election triage?
- Comm Div Appendix A rule-set differences (25-page memo limit, proportionality, designated counsel, accelerated adjudication)?
- Pre-judgment interest 9% under CPLR 5004 calculated from breach date?
- Faithless Servant Doctrine applicable to a disloyal-employee fact pattern?
Pro-se resources
Commercial Division pro se practice is uncommon — the $50k-$500k thresholds plus the complexity of Comm Div Rules mean most parties retain counsel. For solo / pro se inquiries:
- NYS Bar Association Commercial and Federal Litigation Section — referral
- NYC Bar Lawyer Referral Service — Commercial Division panel
- Comm Div Justices' Part Rules — published at
nycourts.gov/courts/comdiv/
New York Consumer-Debt Defense
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Consumer-debt defense is a specialty with high stakes; this bundle is a drafting aid for pro se defendants. Verify every statute and rule before filing.
Federal corpora.
ny-law-references/references/federal-debt-laws/,federal-bankruptcy/, anducc-model/are links into theclaude-legal-federal-lawsdependency. If one is missing or a dangling link (some install methods copy only this plugin's folder), read the same file fromclaude-legal-federal-lawsvia itsfederal-law-referencesskill; file names are identical.
The New York consumer-debt landscape
Three filing forums:
- Civil Court of the City of New York — under $50,000;
the largest consumer-debt forum in the state by case
count. Covered by
ny-county-courts. - Supreme Court — over $50,000 (rare for pure consumer debt; common for mixed claims or judgment-revival). The five flagship counties.
- Nassau / Suffolk District Court + upstate City Courts — long-tail jurisdictions for smaller debts.
The 2022 Consumer Credit Fairness Act (CCFA)
L 2021, ch 593, effective April 7, 2022. The most significant consumer-debt reform in NY in decades. Four key provisions:
CCFA § 1 — CPLR 213(a) — 3-year SOL on consumer credit
Before: 6 years (CPLR 213(2) general contract SOL) After: 3 years (new CPLR 213(a)) on any "action arising out of a consumer credit transaction where a purchaser, borrower or debtor is a defendant"
The SOL runs from the default date — the first missed payment that triggered acceleration (case law: Costa v. Deutsche Bank, 22 NY3d 159 (2013); Lubonty v. U.S. Bank, 34 NY3d 250 (2019)). Once the SOL runs, revival is limited to written acknowledgment under N.Y. GOL § 17-101; partial payment does NOT revive (Lew Morris Demolition Co. v. Bd. of Educ., 40 NY2d 516 (1976)).
Practice point: For any complaint filed on/after April 7, 2022 on a debt that defaulted 3+ years earlier, file a CPLR 3211(a)(5) motion to dismiss on SOL grounds.
CCFA § 2 — CPLR 3015(e) — heightened pleading
The complaint in any consumer-credit action must allege:
- (a) The complete chain of title from the original creditor to the plaintiff
- (b) The date and substance of any account agreement
- (c) The account number (last 4 digits OK)
- (d) The date of default and the amount due as of charge- off
- (e) An itemization of fees/charges/interest added since charge-off
- (f) A statement of the date of the last payment received if any
Missing any of these is grounds for CPLR 3211(a)(7) motion to dismiss.
CCFA § 3 — 22 NYCRR § 202.27-a — heightened default-judgment
In any consumer-credit case (as defined at CPLR 105(f)):
- The plaintiff must submit specific evidence with the default application — not just an affidavit of merit
- Required documents:
- The chain-of-title documents
- The original creditor's records
- The bill of sale and assignment
- Required affidavits:
- The affidavit of merit from a person with personal knowledge — not a robo-signer
- The CPLR 3215(g)(3) additional-notice mailing affidavit
Default judgments entered without compliance are routinely vacated under CPLR 5015(a)(4) (lack of jurisdiction over the person — defective service or process) or under (a)(1) (excusable default + meritorious defense — easy to show when § 202.27-a was not satisfied).
CCFA § 4 — CPLR 308(six) — additional notice mailing
In consumer-credit actions, the plaintiff must mail an additional notice to the defendant under CPLR 308(six) (the provision was renumbered; originally CPLR 308(5)). The notice must be in plain language and identify the original creditor + the assignor chain.
Substantive defenses checklist
| Defense | Authority |
|---|---|
| Statute of limitations | CPLR 213(a) (3 yrs); CPLR 3211(a)(5) |
| Failure to state a cause of action (no CCFA pleading) | CPLR 3015(e); CPLR 3211(a)(7) |
| Lack of standing / chain of title | N.Y. UCC § 9-203; case law |
| Sewer service | CPLR 308; CPLR 3211(a)(8); CPLR 5015(a)(4) |
| Lack of capacity to sue | N.Y. GBL § 601-a (NYC license); CPLR 3211(a)(3) |
| Account stated — no agreement to account | CPLR 3018(b) |
| Payment / accord and satisfaction | CPLR 3018(b) |
| Small-print contract | CPLR 4544 (8-pt type) |
| Usury | Penal Law § 190.40 (criminal); GOL § 5-501 (civil 16%) |
| TILA violation (in original transaction) | 15 USC § 1640 |
| FDCPA violation by collector | 15 USC § 1692 — see references |
| Reg F violation by collector | 12 CFR § 1006 — see references |
Counterclaims checklist
| Counterclaim | Authority |
|---|---|
| FDCPA (federal — $1,000 cap + actual + atty fees) | 15 USC § 1692k |
| GBL § 349 (NY deceptive acts — $50 min; $1,000 cap on willful) | N.Y. GBL §§ 349, 350 |
| GBL § 600 et seq. (collection-agency licensing) | N.Y. GBL §§ 600-606 |
| Common-law abuse of process | NY common law |
| Common-law malicious prosecution (post-dismissal) | NY common law |
| Defamation (if reported to credit bureau falsely after dispute) | CPLR 215(3) — 1-year SOL |
Fact-pattern triage
The table below describes recurring fact patterns in New York consumer-debt practice and the procedural mechanisms the CPLR makes available for each. It is not a recommendation that any particular litigant pursue any particular motion — the choice of pleading, motion, or response belongs to the litigant (and any counsel the litigant retains). Use the table as a map of options, not as a prescription.
| # | Pattern | Procedural mechanisms commonly considered |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Stale credit-card debt (charge-off > 3 yrs before filing) | CPLR 3211(a)(5) motion to dismiss on SOL grounds |
| 2 | Debt buyer plaintiff missing chain-of-title docs | CPLR 3211(a)(7) motion (non-compliance with CPLR 3015(e)) |
| 3 | Default judgment entered, never served (or sewer service) | CPLR 5015(a)(4) motion to vacate |
| 4 | Default judgment entered post-CCFA without § 202.27-a evidence | CPLR 5015(a)(1) motion to vacate (excusable default + meritorious defense) |
| 5 | Active case, debt-collector calls violate Reg F | Verified answer; FDCPA / GBL § 349 counterclaim |
Reference files
references/fdcpa.md— NY-specific framing for the FDCPA (verbatim text inny-law-references/references/federal-debt-laws/FDCPA.mdsymlinked to the shared plugin)references/reg-f.md— NY-specific framing for Reg Freferences/ccfa.md— Consumer Credit Fairness Act 2022 text + commentaryreferences/cplr-213a.md— 3-year SOL deep divereferences/cplr-3015e.md— heightened pleading deep divereferences/202-27-a.md— heightened default-judgment rule deep divereferences/gbl-349.md— NY deceptive-acts statutereferences/gbl-600.md— collection-agency licensingreferences/cplr-4544.md— small-print contractsreferences/chain-of-title.md— N.Y. UCC Article 9 + bill-of-sale-and-assignment foundationreferences/evidence-debt-buyer.md— CPLR 4518 business- records foundation under People v. Kennedy, 68 NY2d 569 (1986) and Bank of NY Mellon v. Gordon, 171 AD3d 197 (2d Dept 2019)references/ny-sols.md— NY SOLs by claim typereferences/key-cases.md— controlling precedentsreferences/recent-decisions.md— post-2022 CCFA case lawreferences/fees-consumer-debt.md— fee shifting in NY consumer-debt (FDCPA mandatory + GBL § 349 discretionary)references/rfp-debt-buyer.md— RFP bank targeting chain of titlereferences/rfa-debt-buyer.md— Notice to Admit bankreferences/interrogatories-debt-buyer.md— 25-interrogatory bank targeting chain of title (CPLR 3130 / 3133(b))references/meet-and-confer-debt-buyer.md— 22 NYCRR § 202.20-f conferral templatesreferences/ucc-article-9.md— N.Y. UCC Article 9references/online-sources-consumer-debt.md— canonical URLs
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-statewide-format— format baselineny-first-30-days— answer triage on a consumer-debt complaintny-discovery— RFP/RFA/Interrogatory draftingny-post-judgment— CPLR 5015 vacate + Article 52 defenseny-deadlines— CPLR 213(a) 3-year SOL clockny-county-courts— NYC Civil Court is the primary forumny-kings/ny-bronx/ny-queens— high-volume Supreme Court consumer-debt counties (especially mortgage- foreclosure cases)
New York County Courts — Long-tail Roll-up
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Verify the specific court's local rules before filing.
This skill is the Supreme Court Civil Term roll-up for
counties outside the five flagship venues (ny-nyco,
ny-kings, ny-bronx, ny-nassau, ny-queens). Other
NY civil-court layers each have their own dedicated skill —
see the Other civil-court layers
section below to route to the right one.
Supreme Court (other counties)
The Supreme Court is New York's court of general jurisdiction in every county. Beyond the five flagship counties, the next-largest civil-trial venues:
| County | JD | Courthouse | Comm Div threshold |
|---|---|---|---|
| Suffolk | 10th | Riverhead | $100,000 |
| Westchester | 9th | White Plains | $200,000 |
| Richmond (Staten Island) | 2nd (admin); separate filing | St. George Courthouse | $150,000 |
| Erie | 8th | Buffalo | $100,000 |
| Monroe | 7th | Rochester | $50,000 |
| Onondaga | 5th | Syracuse | $50,000 |
| Rockland | 9th | New City | $100,000 |
| Albany | 3rd | Albany | $50,000 |
| Orange | 9th | Goshen | $100,000 |
| Dutchess | 9th | Poughkeepsie | (no Comm Div) |
| Saratoga | 3rd | Ballston Spa | $50,000 |
| Oneida | 5th | Utica | (no Comm Div) |
Filings use NYSCEF in nearly all counties. Confirm the assigned Justice's Part Rules before motion practice. Individual Assignment System under 22 NYCRR § 202.3 applies — case stays with one Justice from RJI through judgment.
For Commercial Division-eligible matters (see the
threshold table above), use ny-commercial-disputes for
the substantive 22 NYCRR § 202.70 rule overlay.
Other civil-court layers
NY has an unusually fragmented trial-court system — far more layers than most states. This skill no longer covers the non-Supreme-Court layers. Each layer has its own dedicated skill:
| If your matter is in... | Use this skill |
|---|---|
| NYC Civil Court (Civil Court Act, $50k cap) | [ny-nyc-civil-court] |
| NYC Housing Court (RPAPL Article 7 summary proceedings) | [ny-nyc-housing-court] |
| Nassau District Court (UDCA, $15k cap) | [ny-nassau-dc] |
| Suffolk District Court (UDCA, $15k cap, western towns + Brookhaven only) | [ny-suffolk-dc] |
| Upstate City Court (UCCA, $15k cap, Buffalo/Rochester/Syracuse/Albany/Yonkers/etc.) | [ny-city-courts] |
| Town or Village Justice Court (UJCA, $3k cap, ~1,250 courts) | [ny-justice-courts] |
| Family Court (FCA: custody, support, family offense, PINS, JD, abuse/neglect) | [ny-family-court] |
| Surrogate's Court | wills/estates/guardianship — outside the ny-court-docs scope; consult ny-law-references for SCPA citations |
| Court of Claims (22 NYCRR Part 214; claims against the State of NY) | see ny-law-references for the 90-day notice-of-intention regime; specialized practice |
Cross-references
ny-statewide-format— format baseline (22 NYCRR Part 202 applies to Supreme/County Court; the other civil-court layers use their parallel parts in 22 NYCRR with per-court adjustments)ny-commercial-disputes— Commercial Division substance for over-threshold cases routing to one of the Supreme Courts aboveny-personal-injury,ny-employment— subject-matter overlays applicable in Supreme Court Civil Termny-consumer-debt,ny-landlord-tenant— subject-matter bundlesny-file-packet— NYSCEF assembly for Supreme Court filings
New York Case Deadlines
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Missing a deadline can be fatal. Run the case-calendar script (
scripts/case-calendar.py) for mechanical verification before relying on a hand-computed deadline.
Core time-computation rules
CPLR 2103 — Service of papers
| Mode | Add-on |
|---|---|
| Personal delivery | None |
| Overnight delivery service (CPLR 2103(b)(6)) | 1 day |
| Mail (CPLR 2103(b)(2)) | 5 days |
| Facsimile (CPLR 2103(b)(5)) | None (counted on transmittal day) |
| Email (CPLR 2103(b)(7) and (8)) | None (counted on transmittal day) when authorized by consent or court order |
| Electronic filing through NYSCEF (22 NYCRR § 202.5-bb(b)(2)) | None — service occurs on the date the document is filed |
The 5-day mail rule is the most-mistaken in NY. Filers used to FRCP 6(d) (3 days) over-count or under-count when porting practice. Apply the 5-day add-on when:
- Papers are served by mail
- The recipient's response deadline depends on the date of service
- The response is one for which the rule allows an add-on
The 5-day add-on is added at the back end of the response period — i.e., the recipient has the normal CPLR- specified response window plus 5 days.
CPLR 2103-a — Email service
Added 2022. Allows email service if:
- The recipient consented to email service (in writing, in a stipulation, in an NYSCEF appearance with email address provided)
- Or the court ordered email service
Email service is complete on transmission; no add-on.
NY court holidays (NY Gen. Constr. Law § 24)
| Holiday | Date |
|---|---|
| New Year's Day | January 1 |
| Martin Luther King Jr. Day | 3rd Monday in January |
| Lincoln's Birthday | February 12 |
| Washington's Birthday (Presidents' Day) | 3rd Monday in February |
| Memorial Day | Last Monday in May |
| Flag Day | June 14 (not a court-closing day per CPLR; included in NY Gen. Constr. Law § 24) |
| Juneteenth | June 19 (added 2020 + 2024 amendments) |
| Independence Day | July 4 |
| Labor Day | 1st Monday in September |
| Columbus Day / Indigenous Peoples' Day | 2nd Monday in October |
| Election Day (general) | Tuesday after first Monday in November (every year) |
| Veterans Day | November 11 |
| Thanksgiving Day | 4th Thursday in November |
| Christmas Day | December 25 |
| Saturdays + Sundays | Excluded under CPLR 2103(c) |
Distinctive NY court holidays:
- Lincoln's Birthday (Feb 12) — NY-specific; not a federal court holiday
- Election Day — every year (federal courts open on off-year election days)
- Flag Day (June 14) — listed in NY Gen. Constr. Law but courts generally open
Substitutes (NY Gen. Constr. Law § 25-a):
- When a holiday falls on Saturday, the Friday before is the legal holiday for "public business"
- When a holiday falls on Sunday, the Monday after is the legal holiday
For CPLR purposes (CPLR 2103(c)): "When a deadline falls on a Saturday, Sunday or public holiday, the time is extended to the next succeeding business day." So you generally forward-roll (not back-roll) to the next business day.
Named NY deadlines
| Event | Deadline | Authority |
|---|---|---|
| Answer (personal service in-state) | 20 days | CPLR 3012(a) |
| Answer (substituted / out-of-state / mail) | 30 days | CPLR 3012(c) |
| Service of summons under CPLR 306-b | 120 days from filing | CPLR 306-b |
| Notice of Motion service period | 8 days minimum / 16 days with cross-motion | CPLR 2214(b) |
| Notice of Motion service + 5-day mail add-on | 13 days (8+5) | CPLR 2214 + 2103(b)(2) |
| Cross-motion service | 7 days before return date | CPLR 2215 |
| Bill of Particulars demand response | 30 days | CPLR 3042(a) |
| Notice for Discovery and Inspection response | 20 days | CPLR 3120(2) |
| Interrogatories response | 20 days | CPLR 3133(a) |
| Notice to Admit response | 20 days | CPLR 3123(a) |
| Deposition (EBT) notice | 20 days | CPLR 3107 |
| Motion to vacate default | 1 year from notice of entry | CPLR 5015(a)(1) |
| Notice of Appeal (Appellate Division) | 30 days from notice of entry | CPLR 5513(a) |
| Motion for reargument | 30 days from notice of entry | CPLR 2221(d) |
| Restraining notice duration | 1 year | CPLR 5222(b) |
| Consumer-credit SOL (new CCFA) | 3 years | CPLR 213(a) |
| General contract SOL | 6 years | CPLR 213(2) |
| Personal injury SOL | 3 years | CPLR 214(5) |
| Defamation SOL | 1 year | CPLR 215(3) |
| Money judgment enforcement | 20 years | CPLR 211(b) |
| Foreclosure (post-FAPA) | 6 years; no acceleration unilateral revival | CPLR 213(4) + L 2022, ch 821 |
Pitfalls
- 5-day mail rule vs. federal 3-day — port practice correctly
- Lincoln's Birthday — Feb 12 closure is NY-specific
- Election Day — every year, not just presidential
- Saturday/Friday rollback — NY Gen. Constr. Law § 25-a rolls back for public business (Saturday → Friday) but CPLR 2103(c) rolls forward for deadlines (Saturday → Monday). Don't confuse them.
- NYSCEF filing as service — under 22 NYCRR § 202.5-bb(b)(2), filing through NYSCEF on a registered party counts as service on the filing date; no add-on. This is increasingly the default in NY Supreme Court.
- Substituted service "complete 10 days after filing affidavit" — when computing the answer deadline from substituted service (CPLR 308(2)), service is complete 10 days after the affidavit of service is filed, not when delivery was attempted.
case-calendar.py
The scripts/case-calendar.py script encodes:
- CPLR 2103 add-ons (5 days mail, 1 day overnight)
- NY Gen. Constr. Law § 24 holidays
- CPLR 2103(c) Saturday/Sunday/holiday forward-roll
- Named-rule deadline computations (answer due, RFP due, appeal due, etc.)
- SOL calculations by claim type with CPLR 213/214/215
Invoke:
python3 plugins/ny-court-docs/scripts/case-calendar.py \
--rule answer-substituted \
--service-date 2025-06-15
python3 plugins/ny-court-docs/scripts/case-calendar.py \
--rules # list all named rules
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-first-30-days— answer-deadline triageny-discovery— discovery-response deadline computationny-post-judgment— CPLR 5015(a)(1) 1-year clockny-consumer-debt— CPLR 213(a) 3-year SOL on consumer creditny-quality-check— pre-filing deadline verification
New York Discovery
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Discovery practice in New York is driven by CPLR Article 31 plus the assigned Justice's Part Rules. Verify the Part Rules and any Preliminary Conference order before drafting or responding.
Scope of disclosure — CPLR 3101
CPLR 3101(a) sets the broadest scope of any U.S. jurisdiction: "full disclosure of all matter material and necessary in the prosecution or defense of an action." The Allen v. Crowell-Collier Publ'g Co., 21 NY2d 403 (1968) gloss reads "material and necessary" liberally — anything that may reasonably lead to admissible evidence.
Exceptions (CPLR 3101(b)–(d)):
- (b) — privileged matter (attorney-client, doctor- patient under CPLR 4504, etc.)
- (c) — attorney's work product (absolute)
- (d)(1) — expert disclosures (statutory expert exchange)
- (d)(2) — materials prepared in anticipation of litigation ("trial-preparation materials") — qualified immunity, available on substantial-need showing
Discovery devices
1. Notice for Discovery and Inspection (CPLR 3120) — "RFPs"
The NY analog to FRCP 34 / state-rule document requests. Serve a written notice describing the documents/items with "reasonable particularity"; the receiving party has 20 days to serve a response under CPLR 3120(2) (default under CPLR 2103, plus mail-rule add-ons; the Preliminary Conference order often fixes a different response date).
2. Interrogatories (CPLR 3130–3134)
- CPLR 3130: written interrogatories available, but not alongside an EBT (deposition) in personal-injury, property-damage, or wrongful-death cases (CPLR 3130(1))
- CPLR 3133(b): 25-interrogatory limit — counted per discrete subject; subparts can count separately
- CPLR 3133(a): response due 20 days after service
- CPLR 3133(b): response in writing, signed and verified by the responding party (corporate parties: an officer)
The 25-cap is the same as the federal limit under FRCP 33.
3. Notice to Admit (CPLR 3123)
The NY analog to FRCP 36 / RFAs. Serve a notice with discrete requests; 20-day response window; non-response is deemed an admission. Limitations: cannot demand admission of ultimate issues (Tomasino, 22 AD3d 540) and not appropriate for genuinely disputed material facts.
4. Depositions (CPLR 3106–3119) — "EBT" (Examinations Before Trial)
- CPLR 3106: priority of EBT — plaintiff usually goes first
- CPLR 3107: notice on 20 days' notice; non-party by subpoena under CPLR 3119
- 22 NYCRR § 202.7(a): meet-and-confer attempt required before motion practice related to depositions
- Sanctions for EBT non-attendance: CPLR 3126
5. Other devices
- Bill of Particulars (CPLR 3041–3044) — clarifies pleading; not technically "discovery" but functionally used to flesh out allegations
- Notice for Production of Statements (CPLR 3101(e))
- Independent Medical Examination (CPLR 3121)
Meet-and-confer — 22 NYCRR § 202.20-f (Feb 2021)
In Supreme/County Court civil actions, before moving to compel or for a protective order, the movant must:
- Confer in good faith with the opposing party in person or by phone (a single email exchange typically doesn't satisfy)
- File an affirmation of good-faith conferral — identifying the dates and substance of conferral attempts
Some Justices' Part Rules impose additional pre-motion- letter requirements before filing a motion to compel — a short letter to chambers laying out the dispute, with the opposing party's letter in response, before any formal motion is permitted.
Motion to compel — CPLR 3124
If the opposing party fails to respond or provides inadequate responses, move to compel under CPLR 3124.
Process:
- Meet and confer per 22 NYCRR § 202.20-f
- Notice of Motion returnable before the assigned IAS Part (CPLR 2214)
- Affirmation detailing the discovery served, the responses received (or non-response), and the inadequacy; attach the discovery requests and any response as exhibits
- Memorandum of Law (optional but often expected by Commercial Division Justices)
- Proposed Order — see
ny-draft-order
Available relief under CPLR 3124 + 3126:
- Order compelling disclosure
- Conditional order of dismissal/preclusion (CPLR 3126)
- Striking the pleading (drastic; CPLR 3126(3))
- Default judgment (CPLR 3126(3))
- Costs and counsel fees (22 NYCRR § 130-1.1)
Preliminary Conference (22 NYCRR § 202.12)
Within 45 days of RJI, the IAS Part holds a Preliminary Conference. The PC order sets a discovery schedule:
- Bill of Particulars demanded/served
- Document discovery (CPLR 3120) demanded/served
- Interrogatories (CPLR 3130) demanded/served
- Depositions noticed/taken
- Note of Issue filing date
The PC order supersedes the CPLR 3120(2) 20-day default response window; rely on the PC order's dates.
Compliance Conference + Note of Issue
- Compliance Conference — mid-discovery; verify schedule adherence
- Note of Issue (22 NYCRR § 202.21) — certifies discovery complete; triggers the dispositive-motion window (typically 60–120 days, set per Part Rules)
- Certificate of Readiness — filed with the Note of Issue; affirms discovery complete
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-statewide-format— format for discovery papersny-draft-motion+ny-draft-declaration— scaffolders for motion to compel + supporting affirmationny-deadlines— CPLR 3133/3107/3123 timing computationny-consumer-debt— debt-buyer-specific RFPs and notices to admitny-nyco/ny-kings/ etc. — county-specific Part Rule variations
Draft a New York Affirmation or Affidavit
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Sworn statements are subject to perjury sanctions. Verify every factual statement.
Affirmation v. affidavit — choose correctly
| Document | Authority | Notary? | Who can sign |
|---|---|---|---|
| Affirmation | CPLR 2106 (as amended 2023) | No | Any person, attorney or layperson |
| Affidavit | CPLR 2309 | Yes | Any person |
2023 amendment (L 2023, ch 559) democratized affirmation: before, only attorneys (and certain medical/dental professionals) could affirm without a notary. Now any person may use the CPLR 2106 affirmation form, ending the notary-bottleneck for pro se filers.
When to choose each:
- Affirmation: default for nearly all situations in Supreme Court / Civil Court motion practice
- Affidavit: required in specific contexts — verification
of pleading under CPLR 3020 (some statutes require notary);
affidavit of service when not by NY-licensed process
server; affidavit in support of attachment under CPLR
6212; affidavit of merit in default judgment under CPLR
3215(b) — historically required (but the CCFA 2022 changes
shifted this — see
ny-consumer-debt)
CPLR 2106 affirmation template
SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF [COUNTY]
----------------------------------------- X
[CAPTION]
----------------------------------------- X
AFFIRMATION OF [NAME] IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
[NAME], being duly affirmed, hereby affirms the truth of
the following under penalty of perjury pursuant to CPLR
2106:
1. I am the [Plaintiff/Defendant] in this action. I am
over 18 years of age and competent to testify to the
matters set forth herein. I make this affirmation in
support of [PARTY]'s motion [DESCRIBE].
2. [Fact paragraphs — numbered, one fact each]
3. [Continue numbered]
4. Attached as Exhibit A is a true and accurate copy of
[DESCRIPTION]. The exhibit is in the form I received
it from [SOURCE].
[...]
[FINAL PARAGRAPH — the "ask":]
N. For the reasons set forth in this Affirmation and in
the accompanying Memorandum of Law, [PARTY] respectfully
requests that the Court [SPECIFIC RELIEF].
Dated: [CITY], New York
[Month Day, Year]
_______________________________
[PRINT NAME]
Self-Represented [Plaintiff/Defendant]
[Street Address]
[City, State ZIP]
[Phone]
[Email]
CPLR 2309 affidavit template
For situations where notary is required (or strongly preferred):
SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF [COUNTY]
----------------------------------------- X
[CAPTION]
----------------------------------------- X
AFFIDAVIT OF [NAME] IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
STATE OF NEW YORK )
) ss.:
COUNTY OF [COUNTY] )
[NAME], being duly sworn, deposes and says:
1. I am the [Plaintiff/Defendant] in this action [...]
2. [...]
[FINAL PARAGRAPH]
N. For the reasons set forth herein, I respectfully request
that the Court [SPECIFIC RELIEF].
_______________________________
[PRINT NAME]
Sworn to before me this
___ day of __________, [YEAR].
_______________________________
Notary Public, State of New York
Commission expires: ____________
Drafting rules — facts only
The affirmation/affidavit is a sworn statement of facts — not legal argument. Per CPLR 3024(b), a court may strike scandalous or prejudicial matter; pure legal argument in an affirmation is also routinely stricken.
- One fact per paragraph — numbered
- First-person: "I served the notice" not "the defendant served"
- Personal knowledge: each fact must be within the affiant's personal knowledge unless explicitly "upon information and belief"
- Attach exhibits: every document referenced should be an Exhibit attached to the affirmation
- Cross-reference exhibits: "Attached as Exhibit A is a true and accurate copy of [...]"
- Avoid legal conclusions: "The plaintiff failed to serve proper process" → legal conclusion; rewrite as "Plaintiff's process server filed an affidavit stating service at [ADDRESS]; I did not reside at [ADDRESS] on that date" (factual)
Exhibit attachment conventions
- Lettered: Exhibits A, B, C... (NY convention; numbered exhibits are uncommon)
- Tabbed: for paper filings, tabbed dividers
- Bookmarked: for NYSCEF/PDF filings, PDF bookmarks at the start of each exhibit
- Bates-stamped (recommended): for filings with multiple exhibits, Bates-stamp pages
Common affirmation types
| Type | When |
|---|---|
| Affirmation in Support of Motion | With a Notice of Motion |
| Affirmation in Opposition | Responding to a motion |
| Affirmation in Reply | Replying to opposition |
| Affirmation in Support of OSC | With an Order to Show Cause |
| Affirmation of Service | After serving a paper |
| Affirmation of Engagement (CPLR 125) | Adjournment request |
| Affirmation of Good Faith (22 NYCRR § 202.20-f) | With a motion to compel |
| Affirmation of Merit | With a motion to vacate default (CPLR 5015(a)(1)) |
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-statewide-format— caption + paper formatny-draft-motion— coordinated with the motion's memony-pro-se— pro se signature block / verificationny-fact-check— pre-filing affirmation fact-check
Draft a New York Motion
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Applies the pro-se drafting framework adapted to New York. Verify the assigned Justice's Part Rules before finalizing — page limits, format, courtesy-copy requirements, and oral-argument practice vary.
The standard NY motion packet
A motion in New York Supreme/County Court typically consists of four documents:
- Notice of Motion (CPLR 2214) — the scheduling document
— see
ny-draft-note - Affirmation / Affidavit in Support — sworn statement
of facts plus the procedural history — see
ny-draft-declaration - Memorandum of Law in Support — legal argument
- Proposed Order — see
ny-draft-order
Alternative: Order to Show Cause (OSC) packet:
- Order to Show Cause — signed by a Justice; sets the hearing date and any TRO
- Affirmation / Affidavit in Support
- Memorandum of Law (optional but recommended)
- Proposed Final Order
OSC is used when:
- Emergency relief is needed (TRO, stay of sale)
- Standard CPLR 2214 notice period is insufficient
- A specific Justice's Part Rules require OSC for certain relief
Memorandum of Law structure
COVER PAGE (caption)
PRELIMINARY STATEMENT
[1-2 paragraphs: who, what, why this motion should be granted]
PROCEDURAL HISTORY / RELEVANT FACTS
[Cross-references to the supporting affirmation
paragraphs — do NOT restate facts the affirmation
already establishes]
POINT I — [HEADING STATING THE LEGAL CONCLUSION]
A. [Subheading]
[Argument with citations]
B. [Subheading]
[Argument with citations]
POINT II — [SECOND LEGAL CONCLUSION]
[Argument]
CONCLUSION
[The "ask" — the specific relief sought, restated]
Dated: ...
Signature block
Page limits — 22 NYCRR § 202.8-b (2021)
Statewide (since 2021):
| Document | Page limit | Word-count alternative |
|---|---|---|
| Memorandum of Law (initial) | 25 pages | 7,000 words |
| Reply Memorandum | 15 pages | 4,200 words |
| Affirmation/Affidavit | No page limit, but practical 25-page guideline | |
| Notice of Motion | Typically 1-2 pages |
Word-count alternative permits a more flexible format. Where the rule permits word-count, prefer it and add a word-count certification at the foot of the memo.
Commercial Division (22 NYCRR § 202.70(g) Rule 17): same limits.
CPLR 2214 service timing
| Service mode | Min. notice before return date |
|---|---|
| Personal delivery | 8 days |
| 8 + 5 = 13 days | |
| NYSCEF (registered parties) | 8 days |
Cross-motion (CPLR 2215): must be served at least 7 days before the return date.
Reply: per Part Rules; typically 1 to 7 days before the return date.
Affirmation v. affidavit choice
- Affirmation (CPLR 2106) — sworn statement by attorney, by certain professionals (medical, dental), and since the 2023 amendment, by any person. No notary required.
- Affidavit (CPLR 2309) — sworn statement notarized under oath. Required pre-2023 for any sworn statement by a non-attorney non-professional.
Pro se litigants since 2023 should use affirmation under penalty of perjury (CPLR 2106 as amended; L 2023, ch 559). The text:
[PRINT NAME], being duly affirmed, hereby affirms the truth of the following under penalty of perjury pursuant to CPLR 2106:
(Signature)
Memo opening template
PRELIMINARY STATEMENT
Defendant [NAME] respectfully submits this memorandum in
support of [his/her/their] motion pursuant to CPLR [SECTION]
to [RELIEF SOUGHT]. As set forth in the accompanying
[Affirmation/Affidavit] of [NAME] ("Defendant Aff."), this
action should be [dismissed/vacated/granted summary
judgment] because [ONE-SENTENCE LEGAL CONCLUSION].
pro-se drafting framework — NY adaptations
| Pro-se drafting framework rule | NY specific |
|---|---|
| Cite the rule | Use CPLR section numbers; Tanbook citation format |
| Cite the record | Cross-reference to Defendant Aff. ¶ X / Pl. Aff. ¶ X |
| Verb economy | NY judges parse closely — prefer active voice; cut adverbs |
| Conclude with the "ask" | Restate the precise relief sought in the prayer |
| Caption matches every document | Index number on every page |
Output format — DOCX
Generate DOCX with:
- 8.5 × 11 paper, 1-inch margins, double-spaced
- 12-point Times New Roman or equivalent serif
- Pagination footer
- Caption block per
ny-statewide-format - Tanbook-format citations
- Section heading style (Heading 1 for POINTs; Heading 2 for subsections)
Use the docx-js patterns documented in
ny-statewide-format/references/docx-generation.md (to be
authored).
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-statewide-format— formatting baselineny-draft-declaration— affirmation/affidavit draftingny-draft-note— Notice of Motion draftingny-draft-order— proposed order draftingny-fact-check— pre-filing fact-checkny-file-packet— packet assemblyny-consumer-debt— substantive content for debt-defense motions
Draft a New York Notice of Motion or OSC
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. The Notice of Motion or OSC is the document that gets your motion on the court's calendar. Errors here can cause the motion to be denied or the filing to be rejected by the clerk.
Choose: Notice of Motion or Order to Show Cause?
| Use | When |
|---|---|
| Notice of Motion (CPLR 2214) | Standard motion practice; no emergency; sufficient time to give 8-day minimum notice |
| Order to Show Cause (CPLR 2214(d), 6313) | Emergency relief (TRO); insufficient time for 8-day notice; specific Part Rule requires OSC for certain motion types; ex parte stay of execution; certain CPLR 5015(a) vacatur motions |
OSC requires a Justice's signature on the OSC itself, typically obtained ex parte; the signed OSC is then served on the opposing party. Notice of Motion is filed directly via NYSCEF without judicial pre-signature.
Notice of Motion template (CPLR 2214)
SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF [COUNTY]
----------------------------------------- X
[CAPTION] Index No. [#####/YYYY]
Hon. [JUSTICE]
Part [##]
[Plaintiff(s),]
NOTICE OF MOTION
-against- Return Date: [DATE]
Time: [TIME]
[DEFENDANT(S)], Place: [Courtroom / Teams]
[Defendant(s).]
----------------------------------------- X
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that upon the annexed Affirmation of
[NAME], affirmed [DATE], the accompanying Memorandum of
Law, and all prior pleadings and proceedings in this
action, Defendant [NAME] will move this Court at the
courthouse located at [ADDRESS], on [DATE] at [TIME],
or as soon thereafter as counsel can be heard, for an
order pursuant to:
1. CPLR [SECTION], [DESCRIBE RELIEF]; and
2. Such other and further relief as this Court deems
just and proper.
PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE that, pursuant to CPLR
2214(b), answering papers, if any, shall be served at
least seven (7) days prior to the return date of this
motion.
Dated: [CITY], New York
[Month Day, Year]
_______________________________
[Signature]
[PRINT NAME]
Self-Represented Defendant
[Address / phone / email]
TO:
[Name]
[Plaintiff's attorney address]
Filling in the return date
CPLR 2214(b): minimum 8 days notice; add 5 days for mail service (CPLR 2103(b)(2)). Add the assigned Justice's Part Rule additional notice period if any.
The return date must be on a day the Part hears motions —
typically a fixed weekday per Part Rules. Use
ny-schedule-hearing to pick the date.
OSC template
SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF [COUNTY]
----------------------------------------- X
[CAPTION]
Index No. [#####/YYYY]
Hon. [JUSTICE]
[Plaintiff(s),]
ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE
-against- FOR [RELIEF]
[Defendant(s).]
----------------------------------------- X
Upon the annexed Affirmation of [NAME], affirmed
[DATE], and the exhibits attached thereto, it is hereby
ORDERED that [Plaintiff/Defendant] show cause before
[the IAS Part] in the courthouse located at [ADDRESS],
on [DATE], at [TIME], or as soon thereafter as the
parties can be heard, why an order should not be
entered:
1. Pursuant to CPLR [SECTION], [RELIEF]; and
2. For such other and further relief as the Court
deems just and proper.
[TRO language if emergency relief sought:]
And it is further ORDERED that, pending hearing and
determination of this motion, [STAY/INJUNCTION], on
[CONDITIONS, e.g., posting of undertaking].
[Service direction:]
Sufficient service of this Order to Show Cause and the
underlying papers shall be made upon [Plaintiff/Defendant]
by [SERVICE METHOD] on or before [DATE], at least [#] days
prior to the return date hereof.
Dated: [CITY], New York
[Month Day, Year]
_______________________________
HON. [JUSTICE NAME]
[Title]
The OSC is brought to the Justice's chambers (or e-mailed to the Part email) ex parte with the supporting affirmation. The Justice signs the OSC, setting the return date and any TRO terms.
Court emergency-OSC procedure
Most NY counties have an emergency-application protocol for OSCs requiring same-day or next-day relief:
- NY County: 60 Centre Street, Room 130 — ex parte motion-support office
- Kings County: 360 Adams Street, Room 296 — ex parte motion-support office
- Other counties: chambers email; see Part Rules
Cross-motion notice (CPLR 2215)
If responding to a motion with a cross-motion, the cross-motion must be served at least 7 days before the return date (CPLR 2215). Format:
NOTICE OF CROSS-MOTION
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that upon the annexed Affirmation of
[NAME], affirmed [DATE], Defendant [NAME] will cross-move
this Court at the date and time set in Plaintiff's pending
Notice of Motion, returnable on [DATE], for an order
pursuant to CPLR [SECTION], [RELIEF].
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-statewide-format— caption + formatny-draft-motion— coordinated with the substantive motionny-draft-declaration— affirmation in support attachedny-schedule-hearing— selecting the return date per Part Rulesny-deadlines— CPLR 2214(b) 8-day minimum + 5-day mail add-on computation
Draft a New York Proposed Order
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. The proposed order is what the Justice signs after granting a motion. Errors are caught at signing time, so accuracy matters.
Order types in NY practice
| Type | Use |
|---|---|
| Short-form order | Justice writes decision on the proposed-order document itself ("Decision and Order"); typical for routine motion decisions |
| Long-form order / Decision and Order | Justice issues a separate written decision with detailed reasoning; the order is a separate document |
| Order on Submission | Order proposed by counsel after a motion is granted, submitted for signature |
| Settle Order | Court directs counsel to "settle order" — submit a proposed order within 60 days (22 NYCRR § 202.48) |
| So-ordered Stipulation | Parties' agreement signed by the Justice as an order |
| Counter-Order | Submitted by the opposing party in response to a settle-order |
Proposed-order template
SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF [COUNTY]
----------------------------------------- X
[CAPTION]
Index No. [#####/YYYY]
Hon. [JUSTICE NAME]
Part [##]
[Plaintiff(s),]
DECISION AND ORDER
-against-
[Defendant(s).]
----------------------------------------- X
[NAME OF JUSTICE], J.S.C.:
Upon the [Notice of Motion / Order to Show Cause] of
Defendant [NAME], dated [DATE], the affirmation of [NAME]
in support thereof, the memorandum of law in support
thereof, the exhibits attached, [Plaintiff's affirmation
in opposition dated [DATE], memorandum of law in
opposition, exhibits attached,] the [reply affirmation of
[NAME] dated [DATE],] [oral argument heard on [DATE],]
and all prior pleadings and proceedings, it is hereby
ORDERED that Defendant's motion is GRANTED to the extent
of [SPECIFIC RELIEF]; and it is further
ORDERED that [ADDITIONAL DECRETAL PARAGRAPH IF ANY]; and
it is further
ORDERED that this constitutes the decision and order of
the Court.
Dated: [CITY], New York
[Month Day, Year]
_______________________________
HON. [JUSTICE NAME], J.S.C.
Conventions
- Decretal paragraphs: each "ORDERED that..." is one paragraph; chain with "and it is further" between them; end the last with "and it is further ORDERED that this constitutes the decision and order of the Court"
- Capitalize the decretal phrase ("GRANTED", "DENIED")
- Title: "J.S.C." for Supreme Court Justice; "J." for trial-court judge in other courts
- Date: leave a blank for the Justice's signing date
Settle-order procedure — 22 NYCRR § 202.48
When the Justice's decision says "Settle order on notice":
- Within 60 days of the date of the decision, the prevailing party must submit a proposed order
- On notice means: serve the proposed order on the opposing party at least 10 days before submission
- Opposing party may serve a counter-order within 5 days of receipt
- Both proposed orders are submitted to chambers, who signs the appropriate one
Missing the 60-day deadline is fatal — the right to settle the order is deemed abandoned unless the court extends. Funk v. Barry, 89 NY2d 364 (1996). This is a recurring trap for pro se prevailing parties.
Short-form order — Justice writes on the proposed order
When the Justice signs the proposed-order document itself (rather than issuing a separate decision):
- Submit the proposed order with blank decretal paragraphs in the form expected
- Justice fills in or modifies the language
- The "Decision and Order" stamp is applied at the foot
So-ordered stipulation
A stipulation signed by all parties + "So Ordered" by the Justice. Used for:
- Discovery extensions
- Stipulated case-management changes
- Settlement on the record
- Adjournments of pending motions
Format:
SO ORDERED STIPULATION
WHEREAS [recitals];
IT IS HEREBY STIPULATED AND AGREED, by and between the
undersigned parties, that:
1. [Stipulated term]
2. [Stipulated term]
Dated: [...]
[Plaintiff signature]
[Defendant signature]
SO ORDERED:
_______________________________
HON. [JUSTICE NAME], J.S.C.
Date: ___________
Order on submission (no oral argument)
If the motion was decided on the papers and the Justice issued a written decision directing submission of an order, the proposed-order title is "Order on Submission" to distinguish from a decision-on-argument:
ORDER ON SUBMISSION
Tips for pro se litigants
- Use the Justice's exact phrasing from the decision — if the decision says "Defendant's motion is granted," the order says "Defendant's motion is granted" — not "the Court finds for defendant"
- Avoid additional ruling beyond what the decision granted — a proposed order seeking more than the decision authorized will be rejected
- Number paragraphs if multiple decretal items
- Format: 8.5×11, 1-inch margins, double-spaced, 12-pt
- Signature line: leave space for the Justice; do not pre-sign or pre-date
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-statewide-format— format baselineny-submit-order— post-hearing submission procedure (settle order, counter-order, 60-day rule)ny-draft-motion— proposed order is the fourth document in the motion packetny-quality-check— pre-submission QC
New York Employment Law
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Employment claims in NY are deadline-driven and forum-strategy-sensitive. Verify SOLs, administrative-exhaustion timelines (EEOC + DHR election- of-remedies), and venue choice before drafting.
SOL catalog (the most-used)
| Claim | SOL | Citation |
|---|---|---|
| NYS Human Rights Law (administrative) | 1 year from discriminatory act | NY Exec Law § 297(5) |
| NYS Human Rights Law (judicial) | 3 years | CPLR 214(2) |
| NYC Human Rights Law (judicial) | 3 years | NYC Admin Code § 8-502(d) |
| NYC Human Rights Law (administrative) | 1 year | NYC Admin Code § 8-109 |
| Labor Law § 198 wage-theft | 6 years | Labor Law § 198(3) |
| Labor Law § 740 whistleblower | 2 years (post-2022 amend; was 1 year) | Labor Law § 740(4)(a) |
| NYS WARN Act | 3 years | Labor Law § 860-g |
| Common-law wrongful discharge | varies (3 yr CPLR 214(5) negligence; 6 yr CPLR 213(2) breach of K) | |
| Title VII (federal, in NY) | 300 days to EEOC; 90 days after Right to Sue | 42 U.S.C. § 2000e-5 |
| ADA / ADEA (federal, in NY) | 300 days to EEOC | |
| FLSA (federal wage-hour) | 2 years (3 if willful) | 29 U.S.C. § 255 |
The three principal NY statutes
NYS Human Rights Law (NY Exec Law § 296)
The NYS HRL prohibits employment discrimination on the basis of:
- Age, race, creed, color, national origin, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, military status, sex, disability, predisposing genetic characteristics, familial status, marital status, status as victim of domestic violence
- Pregnancy and pregnancy-related conditions
- Reproductive health decision-making
- Lawful source of income (in employment contexts)
Coverage: As of the 2019 Human Rights Law reforms (L 2019, ch 160), the NYS HRL applies to all employers regardless of size for harassment claims (was 4+ employees pre-2019). For discrimination claims, the law applies to all employers as well after the 2020 amendments.
Forum: Plaintiff can elect either:
- Administrative: file with the NYS Division of Human Rights (DHR) within 1 year. DHR investigates and may hold a hearing. Election of administrative remedy generally bars subsequent court action under NY Exec Law § 297(9) — but permitted exceptions exist.
- Judicial: file directly in Supreme Court (or applicable trial court) within 3 years under CPLR 214(2). No exhaustion requirement for judicial path.
The 2019 reforms also eliminated the "severe or pervasive" standard for harassment — any discriminatory conduct (with limited exceptions for "petty slights or trivial inconveniences") can support liability.
NYC Human Rights Law (NYC Admin Code § 8-107)
The NYC HRL is widely considered the broadest civil- rights statute in the country. Key distinguishing features:
- Construed liberally: NYC Admin Code § 8-130 and the Williams v. NYC Housing Authority line of cases require courts to construe the NYC HRL liberally for the accomplishment of its remedial purposes even where federal and state law would not afford relief
- No "severe or pervasive" requirement: harassment liability attaches to conduct that simply treats the plaintiff "less well" because of a protected characteristic
- Broader protected categories:
- All NYS HRL categories above
- Caregiver status (NYC Local Law 9 of 2016)
- Status as victim of stalking
- Status as a salary-history-protected individual (NYC Local Law 67 of 2017 — bans salary-history inquiry)
- Pre-employment marijuana testing banned (NYC Local Law 28 of 2019)
- Punitive damages available without the Title VII / ADEA cap
- Mandatory attorney's fees to prevailing plaintiff under NYC Admin Code § 8-502(g)
Coverage: 4+ employees for most claims; harassment applies to all employers (the 4-employee threshold removed for harassment in 2019).
Forum: NYC HRL allows direct judicial action under NYC Admin Code § 8-502 with no exhaustion requirement, or an administrative complaint to the NYC Commission on Human Rights (NYCCHR) within 1 year.
Federal Title VII / ADA / ADEA (in NY context)
Federal discrimination claims must be filed with the EEOC within 300 days of the discriminatory act (NY is a "deferral state"). Plaintiff receives a Right-to-Sue letter and must file the federal action within 90 days.
Strategy note: NYS HRL and NYC HRL provide broader substantive protections than Title VII/ADA/ADEA, and have longer SOLs and lower bars to proof. Many NY employment lawyers file dual federal + state/city claims, removing the federal action to district court only if substantial federal issues compel.
Labor Law — wage and hour
Frequency of pay (Labor Law § 191)
Workers in NY must be paid on a specified schedule:
- Manual workers — weekly (§ 191(1)(a))
- Railroad workers — bi-weekly
- Commission salespersons — at least once per month
- Clerical and other workers — at least semi-monthly
Misclassification of a manual worker as a clerical worker (triggering bi-weekly instead of weekly pay) is a frequent litigation theme. The 2020 Vega v. CM & Associates Construction Management LLC decision opened a high-impact litigation path — even when wages were paid in full but late, the employee can recover liquidated damages equal to the underpayment.
Wage theft (Labor Law §§ 193, 195, 198)
Labor Law § 193 bars unauthorized deductions; § 195 imposes notice requirements (the "Wage Theft Prevention Act" annual notice + new-hire notice); § 198 provides civil remedies:
- Underpayment recovery — 100% of wages owed
- Liquidated damages — 100% of wages (200% in some cases)
- Pre-judgment interest — 9% (CPLR 5004)
- Attorney's fees — mandatory
- 6-year SOL — Labor Law § 198(3)
NYS Sexual Harassment Act (2018, amended 2019, 2022)
The 2018 / 2019 reforms — applicable to all employers regardless of size — require:
- Annual sexual harassment prevention training (Labor Law § 201-g)
- Posting of complaint mechanism + reporting procedures
- Prohibition on mandatory arbitration of harassment claims (Labor Law § 7515)
- Prohibition on non-disclosure agreements that conceal workplace harassment unless requested by the plaintiff
Labor Law § 740 — Whistleblower (post-2022 amendments)
The 2022 amendments (L 2021, ch 270) substantially expanded § 740:
- Coverage: now protects employees who report violations of any law, rule, or regulation (was previously limited to "substantial and specific danger" to health or safety)
- SOL: 2 years (was 1 year)
- Remedies: reinstatement + back pay + front pay + compensatory damages + civil penalty + attorney's fees
NYS WARN Act (Labor Law Article 25-A)
Larger than the federal WARN Act:
- Coverage: 50+ employees (federal threshold is 100+)
- Notice: 90 days advance notice (federal is 60)
- Triggering event: layoff of 25+ employees constituting 33%+ of workforce, or 250+ employees regardless
- Remedies: back pay for the notice-period shortfall + benefits + civil penalty
CROWN Act (NY Exec Law § 292(38))
Race discrimination definition includes traits historically associated with race, including hair texture and protective hairstyles (braids, locs, twists). NY adopted the CROWN Act in 2019; NYC HRL has equivalent protection.
Restrictive covenants — narrow enforceability
NY courts apply the "reasonableness" test from Reed, Roberts Associates v. Strauman, 40 N.Y.2d 303 (1976):
- Reasonable in time + geography + scope
- Protects legitimate employer interest (trade secrets, unique services, goodwill)
- Not unreasonably burdensome on employee
- Not injurious to public
The 2024 BSC § 5-3320 reforms (L 2023, ch 540) tightened non-compete enforceability for lower-wage workers and added notice requirements; a proposed full ban passed both chambers in 2023 but was vetoed by the Governor.
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-statewide-format— caption + format baselineny-discovery— CPLR Article 31 disclosure (employment cases typically aggressive on employer documents)ny-first-30-days— Answer + affirmative defensesny-deadlines— SOL + EEOC + DHR arithmeticny-nyco/ny-kingsetc. — venue routing (employment cases route to Supreme Court when over $25,000; SDNY / EDNY for federal-claim removal)ny-fact-check— citation patterns (Williams v. NYC Housing Authority; Vega v. CM & Associates)
High-yield employment checks
- Forum strategy: state HRL vs. NYC HRL vs. Title VII election; election-of-remedies bar under § 297(9)?
- Administrative exhaustion: EEOC charge filed within 300 days?
- SOL on each claim: 1 yr DHR / 3 yr judicial HRL / 6 yr Labor Law / 2 yr LL § 740?
- Coverage thresholds: 4-employee for some NYS HRL sections, all-size for harassment + NYC HRL?
- Severance / NDA carve-outs: harassment-NDA ban under Labor Law § 7515?
- Mandatory arbitration: harassment claim escape under Labor Law § 7515?
- Frequency of pay: manual-worker misclassification under § 191(1)(a)?
Pro-se resources
- NYS Division of Human Rights —
dhr.ny.gov; intake hotline 1-888-392-3644 - NYC Commission on Human Rights —
nyc.gov/cchr; intake 311 - NYS Department of Labor — wage and hour complaint intake
- EEOC New York District Office — federal exhaustion charges
- Pro bono employment-law clinics — Outten & Golden pro bono program; NYC Bar pro bono panel
Fact-Check New York Court Filings
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Use before filing. Fact-check catches errors that would otherwise be raised by the opposing party or the Justice.
Four-pass framework
Pass 1 — Citation verification
For every citation in the document, verify:
- Court of Appeals:
[Case], [Vol] NY3d [Page] ([Pinpoint]) ([Year])— verify the volume, page, and year; the case must be in NY3d (1st series 1956-2003; 2d 1956-2003; 3d 2003-present). NY2d cites should be pre-2003 cases. NY (1st series) should be pre-1956. - Appellate Division:
[Case], [Vol] AD3d [Page] ([Dept] [Year])— verify the volume, department, and year. AD2d → AD3d transition was 2003. - Misc. Reports:
[Case], [Vol] Misc 3d [Page] ([Court], [County] [Year])— verify court and county - CPLR citations:
CPLR [Section](sub)([sub-sub])— verify subdivision lettering matches the current code (CPLR has been amended frequently; verify the version currently in force when the action was commenced) - 22 NYCRR:
22 NYCRR § [Part].[Section]— verify Part number (Part 202 = Supreme/County; Part 208 = NYC Civil; Part 210 = City; Part 212 = District; Part 130 = attorney misconduct / sanctions) - Statutes: verify cite to N.Y. CPLR / N.Y. Gen. Bus. Law / N.Y. Real Prop. Acts. Law / etc.
Tools:
references/online-sources.mdinny-law-referenceslists canonical-source URLs- WebFetch against the source URL for verbatim quote check
- The Tanbook (NYLRSM) is the authoritative style manual
Pass 2 — Internal consistency
Within a single document:
- Defined terms — every defined term ("Plaintiff," "Debt," "Account") used consistently throughout
- Numbers — dollar amounts match across narrative, prayer for relief, and supporting exhibits
- Dates — chronology consistent; no events out of order
- Pronouns — gender consistent if not using they/them
- Paragraph numbering — sequential
- Cross-references — internal "(see ¶ 12)" actually points to the right paragraph
Pass 3 — Packet consistency
Across multiple documents in the same filing packet (motion + affirmation + exhibits + memo + proposed order):
- Caption: identical on every document (court name, county, parties, index number, Justice, Part)
- Index number: same on every document
- Title: matches NYSCEF document type
- Exhibit references: cross-referenced exhibits actually attached; numbering consistent ("Exhibit A" in the affirmation matches "Exhibit A" in the exhibit packet)
- Service date in the certificate of service or CPLR 2103(b)(7) certification matches the NYSCEF filing date
- Notice of Motion return date matches the affirmation's "returnable on [date]"
Pass 4 — Sworn-vs.-argued consistency
NY distinguishes sharply between sworn facts and legal argument:
- Affirmation / Affidavit: sworn statement of facts; cannot contain legal argument (CPLR 3024 strikes pure argument from sworn papers)
- Memorandum of Law: legal argument; cannot assert new facts not in the affirmation
Common pro se errors:
- Affirmation contains "Plaintiff has no standing" (legal argument) — should be moved to the memo
- Memo asserts "I sent payment on June 15" (fact) — should be in the affirmation
For each statement, verify:
| In affirmation? | In memo? | OK? |
|---|---|---|
| Fact | — | Yes |
| — | Argument | Yes |
| Argument | — | No — move to memo |
| — | Fact (not in affirmation) | No — add to affirmation |
Quick QC sweep
After running the four passes, do a final pass:
- Format check — run
scripts/format-check.pyagainst the PDF (seeny-statewide-format) - Pagination — every page numbered; no orphan headings
- Signature blocks — present on every signed document; pro se vs. attorney signature block correct
- NYSCEF metadata — document title and document type selected correctly
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-law-references— canonical reference corpora to fact-check againstny-statewide-format— format-rule verificationny-quality-check— broader pre-filing reviewny-file-packet— full packet assembly + consistency
New York Family Court (Family Court Act / 22 NYCRR Part 205)
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Family Court matters have strict procedural rules, court-appointed-counsel rights, and interplay with parallel Supreme Court matrimonial proceedings. Verify every petition's statutory predicate and the specific county's filing protocol before filing.
At a glance
- Court: New York Family Court — established by Art VI § 13 of the NY Constitution and the Family Court Act (NY Family Court Act, "FCA"), with procedural rules at 22 NYCRR Part 205
- Coverage: one Family Court per county (62 total);
larger counties have multiple courthouses + many Judges
- Support Magistrates + Referees
- Filing fee: no filing fee for most petitions (FCA § 217 / § 251) — Family Court is fee-waived by default to ensure accessibility
- E-filing: NYSCEF mandatory in many counties for divorce-adjacent matters; rolling out for support, custody, family-offense, and PINS as well; some petitions still filed in person
- Right to counsel: assigned counsel under FCA § 262 for parents in Article 10 abuse/neglect, Article 6 termination of parental rights, Article 7 PINS, Article 3 juvenile delinquency, and family-offense respondents in Article 8 proceedings facing the prospect of Order of Protection consequences
Court structure — Judges, Support Magistrates, Referees
Family Court has a unique three-tier adjudicative structure:
- Family Court Judges — full-time judicial officers elected/appointed under Art VI § 13; hear custody, visitation, family-offense, PINS, abuse and neglect, termination of parental rights, juvenile delinquency
- Support Magistrates — court attorneys appointed under FCA § 439 who hear all child support and spousal support matters. Their orders are subject to objection before a Family Court Judge under FCA § 439(e). All NY Child Support Standards Act ("CSSA") cases proceed through Support Magistrates first.
- Referees — Judicial Hearing Officers or court-appointed referees who hear specific matters under FCA § 161; usually handles paternity testing-result reviews, specific orderly-administration tasks
Article overview
The Family Court Act organizes Family Court jurisdiction by Article — each Article corresponds to a different proceeding type with its own procedure:
Article 3 — Juvenile Delinquency (FCA § 301 et seq.)
Persons under 18 (Raise the Age 2017 + 2018) charged with acts that would be crimes if committed by adults. Heard before a Family Court Judge. Pre-adjudicatory probation / ATD (Alternatives to Detention) common. Adjudication results in adjustment, dismissal, conditional discharge, probation, or placement with the OCFS.
Article 4 — Child Support (FCA § 411 et seq.)
The principal financial-support proceeding. CSSA at FCA § 413 governs the basic child-support obligation:
- 17% of combined parental adjusted gross income for 1 child
- 25% for 2 children
- 29% for 3 children
- 31% for 4 children
- 35% for 5 or more children
The 2024 statutory combined-income cap: $183,000 (adjusts every two years). Above the cap, the court may apply CSSA percentages or weigh paragraph (f) factors (financial resources, child's standard of living, tax consequences, etc.). Both parties' incomes are pooled and imputed where appropriate. Add-ons include:
- Child care
- Health insurance
- Unreimbursed medical
- Educational expenses
- Other (often clothes / extracurriculars by case-by-case)
Article 5 — Paternity (FCA § 511 et seq.)
Establishment of paternity for unmarried fathers. Father or mother may petition; court may order genetic-marker test (GMT) at no charge to the petitioner. The Article 5 Order of Filiation is a predicate for any subsequent Article 4 support proceeding.
Article 6 — Custody and Visitation; Adoption (FCA § 611 et seq.)
The principal custody / visitation forum. Family Court has concurrent jurisdiction with Supreme Court for custody; Supreme Court has exclusive jurisdiction over divorce itself but can refer custody to Family Court (or retain it under the Matrimonial Part). The best-interests standard from Eschbach v. Eschbach, 56 N.Y.2d 167 (1982), governs. Joint legal custody is the modern default unless parental conflict is so high that joint decision-making is unworkable (Friederwitzer v. Friederwitzer).
Sub-areas under Article 6:
- Custody petitions between unmarried parents, or between a parent and a non-parent who has assumed parental role (in narrow circumstances — Brooke S.B. v. Elizabeth A.C.C., 28 N.Y.3d 1 (2016), expanded "parent" definition for non-biological co-parents)
- Visitation petitions by grandparents under DRL § 72
- Adoption under FCA § 651 + DRL Article 7
Article 7 — Persons In Need of Supervision (PINS)
Persons under 18 (some jurisdictions extend to 21) deemed "in need of supervision" by behavior such as truancy, incorrigibility, running away, or other status offenses. NYC has substantially eliminated the PINS docket since 2018 in favor of diversion programs; outside NYC the PINS docket remains active.
Article 8 — Family Offenses + Orders of Protection
Family-offense petitions allow a victim to seek a civil Order of Protection against a respondent who has committed a qualifying offense. Two qualifying elements must both be met:
- Qualifying relationship: spouse, ex-spouse, parent in common with the victim's child, family member by blood/marriage, or person with whom the victim has had an "intimate relationship" (an expanding category; FCA § 812)
- Qualifying offense from the FCA § 812 catalog —
includes:
- Assault (Penal Law § 120)
- Aggravated harassment (PL § 240.30)
- Stalking (PL § 120.45-120.60)
- Menacing (PL § 120.13-120.15)
- Reckless endangerment (PL § 120.20-120.25)
- Strangulation (PL § 121.11-121.13)
- Identity theft (PL § 190.78-190.80)
- Forcible touching (PL § 130.52)
- Coercive control (PL § 121.05-121.07, added 2022)
- Many others — verify against the current § 812 list
Order of Protection types:
- Temporary — issued ex parte at the first appearance, pending the fact-finding
- Final — after fact-finding, can run up to 2 years (5 years on showing of aggravating circumstances)
- Stay-away clauses + no-contact clauses + firearm surrender are routine
Article 10 — Child Abuse and Neglect
ACS (NYC) or DSS (rest of state) is the petitioner. The fact-finding determines whether abuse / neglect occurred. Right to assigned counsel for the respondent parent (FCA § 262). Dispositional outcomes range from adjustment without finding to placement of the child with OCFS or relatives. Parallel Article 6 termination of parental rights (TPR) proceedings may follow if the parent fails to remediate.
Article 11 — Habeas Corpus for Children
Used historically for custodial-interference disputes. Less common today; supplanted by direct Article 6 custody petitions.
Distinctives
No divorce — Supreme Court matrimonial only
Family Court does not handle divorces. Divorce, legal
separation, annulment, and equitable distribution of marital
property route to Supreme Court Matrimonial Part (see
ny-nyco, ny-kings, ny-nassau etc.). Family Court has
concurrent jurisdiction with Supreme Court for custody,
visitation, and child support when no matrimonial action
is pending; once a matrimonial action is filed in Supreme
Court, the Supreme Court can retain custody / support or
refer to Family Court under DRL § 252.
Support Magistrate process + objection procedure
All Article 4 child support and Article 5 paternity matters are heard initially by a Support Magistrate — not a Family Court Judge. Within 35 days of the Support Magistrate's order, a party may file a written objection under FCA § 439(e) to be heard by the Family Court Judge. The objection process is the principal vehicle for correcting CSSA calculation errors and reviewing Magistrate findings.
CSSA presumption + rebutting it
CSSA's percentage-of-income formula is presumptively correct under FCA § 413(1)(g). A court can deviate only on findings that the presumptive amount is "unjust or inappropriate" considering the paragraph (f) factors. Magistrates routinely rubber-stamp the CSSA calculation absent specific deviation arguments.
Family-offense forum strategy
Family Court family-offense petitions run in parallel with any criminal prosecution. The respondent may face:
- Criminal Court order of protection (issued at arraignment under Criminal Procedure Law)
- Family Court order of protection (Article 8)
- Supreme Court order of protection (if matrimonial action pending)
The three forums issue overlapping but distinct orders. Family Court orders are civil; violations are punishable as contempt under Judiciary Law § 750 or criminal contempt under Penal Law § 215.50.
NYC vs. outside NYC differences
NYC Family Court is housed in 5 borough courthouses:
- New York County: 60 Lafayette Street, NY NY
- Kings County: 330 Jay Street, Brooklyn
- Bronx County: 900 Sheridan Avenue, Bronx
- Queens County: 151-20 Jamaica Avenue, Jamaica
- Richmond County: 100 Richmond Terrace, Staten Island
NYC operates a high-volume PINS / Article 10 / Article 3 docket with ACS (Administration for Children's Services) as the petitioner. Outside NYC, DSS (Department of Social Services, by county) is the equivalent petitioner.
Confidentiality + sealed records
Article 3 juvenile delinquency records are sealed by default under FCA § 375.1-375.3. Article 7 PINS records are also sealed. Article 10 abuse and neglect records are confidential by statute (FCA § 1043) but accessible to the parties + counsel. Family Court orders + petitions are generally not public in the way Supreme Court papers are — viewers must establish standing.
Filing checklist
- Identify the correct petition type — each Article
has its own petition form (most accessible via NYCourts
"Form Search" at
nycourts.gov/forms/) - Determine the proper county — generally where the child resides (FCA § 421); special venue rules for Article 8 (where parties reside or where offense occurred) and Article 10 (where the child resides)
- No filing fee (FCA § 217) for most petitions
- First appearance — typically within 2-4 weeks of filing
- Court-appointed counsel for the respondent on Article 10, Article 7, Article 3, Article 8 if Order of Protection sought
- Counsel for the child (formerly "law guardian") in custody, visitation, abuse / neglect, TPR (FCA § 241, § 1042)
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-statewide-format— caption + format baseline; Family Court uses 22 NYCRR Part 205 with simplified procedural rulesny-pro-se— pro se framework (Family Court is predominantly pro se for petitioners on family-offense, custody, support — Article 10 / juvenile delinquency respondents have assigned counsel right)ny-deadlines— Support Magistrate 35-day objection clock + Order of Protection 2/5-year durationny-first-30-days— Answer + counter-petitions in Family Court are less formal than in Supreme Court; the petition is usually answered orally at first appearanceny-nyco,ny-kingsetc. — Supreme Court Matrimonial Part for divorce + equitable distribution (Family Court handles parenting + support concurrently)ny-county-courts— appellate destination for some Family Court orders is the Appellate Division (the same Department as the Supreme Court for that county)
Pro-se resources
- NYS OCA Family Court forms —
nycourts.gov/forms/familycourt/ - Court Help —
nycourts.gov/courthelp/— extensive Family Court material with petition walkthroughs - NYC Family Justice Centers (Bronx, Brooklyn, Manhattan, Queens, Staten Island) — combined-services centers offering free legal assistance for family-offense matters
- Sanctuary for Families — NYC; family-offense focus
- Day One — NYC; family-offense / teen dating violence
- Pace Women's Justice Center — Lower Hudson; family-offense
- NYS OCFS Office of Children and Family Services — state-level oversight for foster care, adoption, juvenile justice; intake hotlines
High-yield Family Court checks
- Article identification: is this Article 3 (JD), 4 (support), 5 (paternity), 6 (custody), 7 (PINS), 8 (family offense), 10 (abuse and neglect)?
- Forum vs. matrimonial overlap: is there a parallel Supreme Court matrimonial action? Concurrent jurisdiction issue?
- CSSA application: cap of $183,000 (2024) reached? Deviation grounds under paragraph (f)?
- Support Magistrate 35-day objection clock for correcting calculation errors?
- Order of Protection scope: qualifying-relationship established? Qualifying offense pled with PL section cite? Duration (2 years default, 5 with aggravating circumstances)?
- Counsel rights: assigned counsel on Article 10 / TPR / Article 8 OP / JD requested + appointed?
- NYC-specific: ACS as petitioner in Article 10? Right- to-Counsel under NYS not applicable in NYC because of Family Justice Center coverage?
Assemble a New York Court Filing Packet
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Packet preflight catches errors that would otherwise cause a clerk rejection or in-court ruling against your motion.
NY court filing systems
| Court | System | URL |
|---|---|---|
| Supreme Court (all counties) + County Court | NYSCEF | https://iappscontent.courts.state.ny.us/NYSCEF/live |
| Civil Court of the City of New York | UCMS / CCEF | https://www.nycourts.gov/courts/nyc/civil/ |
| Family Court | UFC (Universal Family Court) | https://nycourts.gov/courts/nyc/family/ |
| Surrogate's Court | NYSCEF (mostly) | Same as Supreme |
| Nassau / Suffolk District Court | NYSCEF | Same |
| City Courts (upstate) | NYSCEF, variably | Court-by-court |
| Town & Village Justice Courts | Paper-only typically | Local |
Motion packet components
For a standard motion in Supreme Court via NYSCEF:
- Notice of Motion (or Order to Show Cause) — see
ny-draft-note - Affirmation / Affidavit in Support — see
ny-draft-declaration - Exhibits — separate PDFs or single bundled PDF with bookmarks (per Part Rules)
- Memorandum of Law in Support — see
ny-draft-motion - Proposed Order (if relief involves an order) — see
ny-draft-order - Affidavit of Service (or NYSCEF service certification)
NYSCEF assembly conventions
Bookmarks
Required for any multi-document or multi-exhibit filing. Bookmark to:
- Start of each document (e.g., "Affirmation of Smith")
- Start of each exhibit (e.g., "Exhibit A — Credit Agreement")
Document type selection
NYSCEF requires selecting a document type from a controlled dropdown for each upload:
| File | NYSCEF document type |
|---|---|
| Notice of Motion | "Notice of Motion" |
| Order to Show Cause | "Order to Show Cause" |
| Affirmation in Support | "Affirmation in Support" |
| Affidavit in Support | "Affidavit in Support" |
| Memorandum of Law | "Memorandum of Law" |
| Exhibits | "Exhibits" or "Exhibit [Letter]" |
| Proposed Order | "Proposed Order" |
| Affidavit of Service | "Affidavit of Service" |
| Stipulation | "Stipulation" |
| Counter-Order | "Counter Order" |
Mismatched document types are a common rejection cause.
File specifications
- Format: PDF
- OCR: text-searchable preferred (image-only allowed for true-paper exhibits)
- Size: ≤ 100 MB per upload
- Naming: descriptive; no special characters
- Bookmarks: per above
- Redaction: 22 NYCRR § 202.5(e) — redact SSNs, tax IDs, financial-account numbers (except last 4 of each), birthdates (except year), minors' names (use initials)
Cross-document consistency check
Before submission, verify every document in the packet shows:
| Item | Same across packet? |
|---|---|
| Court name | YES |
| County | YES |
| Plaintiff name + role | YES |
| Defendant name + role | YES |
| Index number | YES |
| Justice (if assigned) | YES |
| Part (if assigned) | YES |
| Notice of Motion return date | YES (matches the date in the affirmation's "returnable on") |
| Exhibit letter / number | YES (matches references in affirmation) |
Service requirement
Most NY motion filings require contemporaneous service:
| Method | Tracking |
|---|---|
| NYSCEF e-service (registered parties) | Auto-tracked; certification by NYSCEF |
| Mail (CPLR 2103(b)(2)) | Affidavit of service; 5-day add-on |
| Email by stipulation (CPLR 2103(b)(7), 2103-a) | Email + filed acknowledgment |
| Personal delivery | Affidavit of service |
For pro se filers: if the opposing party is also NYSCEF- registered, NYSCEF e-service is automatic and sufficient; no separate service required.
Preflight checklist
[ ] All 4-6 packet components present
[ ] Each component in correct format (single PDF per doc)
[ ] NYSCEF document types correctly selected
[ ] Bookmarks present for multi-exhibit filings
[ ] Caption consistent across all documents
[ ] Index number on every page
[ ] Pagination on every page
[ ] All cross-references resolve
[ ] Citations Tanbook-formatted
[ ] Signature blocks present and correct
[ ] CPLR 2106 affirmation language (post-2023)
[ ] Service mode determined; affidavit/cert ready
[ ] Service period satisfies CPLR 2214(b) + 2103(b)(2)
[ ] Redactions applied per 22 NYCRR § 202.5(e)
[ ] Final PDF size ≤ 100 MB
[ ] Justice's Part Rules consulted for special requirements
Filing instructions output
After preflight passes, the filing instructions look like:
NYSCEF FILING INSTRUCTIONS
Case: [Caption], Index No. [#####/YYYY]
Motion: [Description]
Return Date: [DATE]
STEP 1 — Log in to NYSCEF
Go to https://iappscontent.courts.state.ny.us/NYSCEF/live
Use your registered NYSCEF account.
STEP 2 — Upload documents (in this order)
[ ] notice-of-motion.pdf — type: "Notice of Motion"
[ ] affirmation-in-support.pdf — type: "Affirmation in Support"
[ ] memorandum-of-law.pdf — type: "Memorandum of Law"
[ ] exhibits-bundle.pdf — type: "Exhibits"
[ ] proposed-order.pdf — type: "Proposed Order"
[ ] affidavit-of-service.pdf — type: "Affidavit of Service"
STEP 3 — Confirm service
Check NYSCEF service-list to confirm opposing party is
NYSCEF-registered. If yes: NYSCEF e-service is automatic.
If no: mail per CPLR 2103(b)(2) and file affidavit of
service separately.
STEP 4 — Submit + pay fees
Fees: $45 (motion) per NYSCEF schedule (CPLR 8020).
Pay-as-you-go or stored credit card.
STEP 5 — Confirm receipt
NYSCEF returns a stamped confirmation; the return date
is locked in.
STEP 6 — Calendar follow-ups
- Opposition due: 7 days before return date (per CPLR 2214)
- Reply due: per Part Rules (typically 1-3 days before)
- Return date: [DATE] at [TIME]
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-statewide-format— format baselineny-draft-motion+ny-draft-declaration+ny-draft-noteny-draft-order— packet components
ny-fact-check+ny-quality-check— pre-packet QCny-schedule-hearing— return date reservation
First 30 Days — After Service in a New York Civil Case
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Missing the answer deadline can cause a default judgment under CPLR 3215. Compute the deadline carefully (see
ny-deadlines).
Answer deadlines — CPLR 3012
| Mode of service | Deadline |
|---|---|
| Personal delivery in-state (CPLR 308(1)) | 20 days from service |
| Substituted "leave and mail" (CPLR 308(2)) | 30 days from service being complete (service complete 10 days after filing affidavit of service) |
| "Nail and mail" (CPLR 308(4)) | 30 days from service being complete |
| Personal service out-of-state | 30 days from delivery |
| Service by publication (CPLR 308(5)) | 30 days from publication complete |
| Service on Secretary of State (corporation, CPLR 311) | 30 days from Secretary's mailing |
Important: under CPLR 308(2)/(4), service is complete 10 days after the affidavit of service is filed. The answer clock runs from completion, not from the date delivery was attempted. So substituted service has a built-in 40-day buffer (10 + 30) before the answer is due.
Pre-answer motion to dismiss — CPLR 3211
Instead of answering, a defendant can file a pre-answer motion to dismiss. Grounds under CPLR 3211(a):
| Sub | Ground |
|---|---|
| (1) | A defense founded upon documentary evidence |
| (2) | Court has no subject-matter jurisdiction |
| (3) | Party lacks legal capacity to sue |
| (4) | There is another action pending between the same parties |
| (5) | Cause of action may not be maintained because of arbitration / collateral estoppel / discharge / infancy / payment / release / res judicata / statute of limitations / statute of frauds |
| (6) | Court lacks jurisdiction over a counterclaim |
| (7) | Pleading fails to state a cause of action |
| (8) | Court has no personal jurisdiction over the defendant |
| (9) | Court has no jurisdiction in cases involving the State |
| (10) | Court should not proceed in the absence of a person who should be a party |
| (11) | Subject of the action is property which has been distributed by a receiver / fiduciary |
CPLR 3211(e) is the consolidation rule: most CPLR 3211 defenses must be raised in the first responsive paper or they are waived (especially (a)(1), (4), (5), (8) personal jurisdiction). (a)(2) and (a)(7) can be raised at any time.
Filing a CPLR 3211 motion extends the answer deadline until 10 days after service of the order deciding the motion (CPLR 3211(f)).
Common defenses by case type
Consumer-debt complaint (most common pro se case)
- CPLR 3211(a)(5) — Statute of Limitations: Post-CCFA (2022), credit-card and other consumer-credit debts have a 3-year SOL under CPLR 213(a). For older debt-buyer complaints, this is often the strongest defense.
- CPLR 3211(a)(7) — Failure to state a cause of action: Post-CCFA, the complaint must comply with CPLR 3015(e) — identifying the original creditor, chain of title, account number, default date, and amount as of charge-off. Non-compliance is fatal.
- CPLR 3211(a)(8) — Lack of personal jurisdiction: If service was defective (e.g., never received the summons), raise here.
- CPLR 3211(a)(3) — Capacity: Some debt buyers lack capacity if not registered/licensed where required (NY Gen. Bus. Law § 600).
Tort complaint (PI, defamation)
- CPLR 3211(a)(5) — Statute of Limitations: PI 3 years (CPLR 214(5)); defamation 1 year (CPLR 215(3))
- CPLR 3211(a)(7): failure to state a cause of action
Foreclosure complaint
- CPLR 3211(a)(3): standing (plaintiff must hold note and mortgage at commencement — see Aurora Loan Services v. Taylor, 25 NY3d 355 (2015))
- CPLR 3408: triggers mandatory foreclosure-settlement conference
Answer mechanics — CPLR 3018
If answering rather than moving to dismiss, the answer must:
- Admit or deny each allegation (CPLR 3018(a))
- Set forth affirmative defenses (CPLR 3018(b)) — must be specifically pleaded; common: SOL, payment, release, accord-and-satisfaction, license, illegality, fraud, contributory negligence
- Plead counterclaims as the answer (CPLR 3019(a))
- Verify if the complaint was verified (CPLR 3020(a))
Counterclaims — CPLR 3019
NY does not have a strict compulsory-counterclaim rule. CPLR 3019 says counterclaims may be asserted; the consequence of not asserting is res judicata only as to claims actually litigated. But waiting can be procedurally costly.
In consumer-debt defense: assert FDCPA, GBL § 349, GBL §
600 violations as counterclaims (see ny-consumer-debt).
Extension stipulation
CPLR 2104 allows the parties to stipulate to an extension. Typical practice: a 20-day or 30-day extension by emailed stipulation (signed by both sides). File via NYSCEF as "Stipulation Extending Time to Answer." No court approval required if filed before the original deadline.
Triage checklist
For a newly served defendant:
- Calendar the answer deadline (
ny-deadlines) - Verify service was proper (CPLR 308 — is the affidavit of service correct?)
- Run an SOL check — was the debt charged off more than 3 years ago (CPLR 213(a)) for consumer credit?
- CCFA compliance check — does the complaint identify the original creditor, chain of title, account number, default date (CPLR 3015(e))?
- Choose path: CPLR 3211 motion / verified answer with affirmative defenses + counterclaims / extension stipulation if more time needed
- Draft via
ny-draft-motionor write an answer using the pro-se drafting framework
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-statewide-format— format for the answer / motionny-deadlines— answer-deadline computationny-draft-motion+ny-draft-declaration— scaffoldersny-consumer-debt— substantive defenses + counterclaimsny-landlord-tenant— RPAPL 7-day answer in summary proceedings (a different deadline structure)ny-fact-check— pre-filing QC
New York Hearings
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Verify the assigned Justice's hearing protocol before every appearance.
NY hearing categories
| Category | When | Where |
|---|---|---|
| Motion hearing | Return date on Notice of Motion | Assigned IAS Part |
| Order to Show Cause hearing | Date set by signing Justice | Assigned IAS Part |
| Preliminary Conference | Per 22 NYCRR § 202.12 | Assigned IAS Part |
| Compliance Conference | Mid-discovery | Assigned IAS Part |
| Settlement Conference | CPLR 3408 (foreclosure) or as scheduled | Foreclosure Settlement Conference Part |
| Pre-trial conference | Pre-trial readiness | Assigned IAS Part |
| Trial | After Note of Issue + Certificate of Readiness | Assigned IAS Part |
| Evidentiary hearing | Re factual disputes | Assigned IAS Part |
| Default-judgment inquest | CPLR 3215(b) | Inquest part (varies) |
Submitted vs. argued motions
A distinctive NY practice: a motion can be either:
- "Argued" — counsel appears at the return date and argues the motion orally before the Justice
- "Submitted" (or "on submission") — no appearance; the motion is decided on the papers alone
Many NY Justices default to "submitted unless oral argument is requested by either party." Check Part Rules: some require an affirmation requesting oral argument; some require a separate letter; some allow argument on request at the return date.
When oral argument is granted, the Justice typically grants 5–10 minutes per side, sometimes more in complex Comm Div matters. Some Parts schedule oral argument on a calendar day distinct from the return date.
Remote hearings — Microsoft Teams
Since 2020, NY courts have used Microsoft Teams as the default remote-appearance platform (not Zoom, not WebEx — Microsoft Teams). The link is typically:
- Distributed via the NYSCEF docket as a Notice of Virtual Court Appearance
- Or distributed by the Part clerk by email after RJI
Pro se litigants commonly join from a personal computer or tablet via the Teams web client (no Teams account required). Smartphone is allowed but bandwidth is critical.
Pre-hearing checklist (remote):
- Test the Teams link 24 hours in advance
- Use the legal name (not a nickname) as the Teams display name
- Mute by default; unmute only when called
- Have all filing PDFs open in a separate window
- Dress as if appearing in person
In-person hearings
The Justice's Part Rules will indicate which categories default to in-person:
- Trials — in-person, with limited exceptions
- Evidentiary hearings — typically in-person
- Contested settlement conferences — often in-person
- Routine motion hearings — typically remote (Teams) by Part Rule
Courtroom etiquette
| Conduct | Notes |
|---|---|
| Stand when the Justice enters / exits | Standard |
| Address the Justice as "Your Honor" | Never "Judge" alone |
| Stand at the lectern (or counsel table) when speaking | Per Part Rules; some Parts allow seated |
| Begin with "May it please the Court, [Name] appearing pro se for [Plaintiff/Defendant]" | First appearance of the hearing |
| One advocate at a time | Wait for the Justice to recognize you |
| Phone off (silenced) | Standard |
| No food / gum | Bottle of water OK in most Parts |
Hearing-day preparation
24–48 hours before:
- Re-read the moving papers, opposition, and reply
- Brief outline of your argument:
- Two-sentence summary of your position
- Three strongest points (one cite each)
- Concession point (where opposing has a point — concede it but distinguish)
- "Ask" — what specific relief
- Prepare for likely questions from the Justice
- Print or bookmark the exact cite text for the cases you may need to read aloud
- Re-confirm Part Rules: time, location/link, lectern vs. table, oral-argument time per side
Day-of:
- Arrive 15 minutes early (or join Teams 10 minutes early)
- Sign in with the Part clerk
- Wait quietly until called
- After argument, do not interject when the Justice rules
- If the Justice reserves decision, ask if a written decision will issue or whether the parties should schedule a follow-up
Disability accommodation
Per 22 NYCRR § 50.1 + state and federal disability law, the court provides accommodations on request:
- Sign-language interpreter (book through the Justice's clerk)
- Translation (Court Interpreter Office)
- Wheelchair accessibility
- Extended argument time for cognitive disability
Request as early as possible — at least 14 days in advance is recommended.
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-statewide-format— format for any hearing-related filingsny-schedule-hearing— getting the hearing date on the calendarny-draft-motion+ny-draft-declaration— pre-hearing draftingny-submit-order— post-hearing proposed-order submissionny-quality-check— pre-hearing-filing QC
Town & Village Justice Courts (UJCA / 22 NYCRR Part 214)
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Verify the specific Town or Village Justice Court's schedule, sitting judge, and clerk hours before every filing.
At a glance
- Court system: Town and Village Justice Courts — ~1,250 courts across the state established under the Uniform Justice Court Act (UJCA) of 1966 with procedural rules at 22 NYCRR Part 214
- Civil jurisdiction: up to $3,000 (UJCA § 202)
- Small claims: up to $3,000 in informal proceedings (UJCA § 1801)
- Commercial claims: up to $3,000 for entities (UJCA § 1801-A)
- L&T (summary proceedings): no monetary cap on rent arrears; RPAPL Article 7 procedure applies; very high volume in rural and exurban towns
- Criminal: Vehicle and Traffic Law violations; lower- level misdemeanors; arraignments
- Filing fee: $20 for civil filings under UJCA § 1911
How the court works in practice
A Justice Court is typically located in the Town Hall or Village Hall. The Justice (judge) is elected; in many small towns the position is part-time and the Justice has a day job in private practice or another field. A single clerk handles intake, filings, and calendaring. Court sessions are commonly held one or two evenings per week.
Lay-judge note
Under UJCA § 105, Town and Village Justices are not required to be attorneys — many are non-lawyers. State law requires a brief training program through the OCA Justice Court Assistance Program (JCAP). The procedural rules at 22 NYCRR Part 214 are streamlined to accommodate lay-judge administration, but RPAPL Article 7 (for L&T) and the CPLR (for civil) still apply.
Multi-municipality assignments
Some judges sit in multiple courts — e.g., a Village Justice may also serve as a Town Justice in a neighboring town. Conflicts and recusals are common in small communities. The OCA's Justice Court Assistance Program manages staffing across the ~1,250 courts.
When you end up in Justice Court
The four most common civil scenarios:
1. Small claims under $3,000
Pro se plaintiff vs. pro se defendant; informal proceedings; no formal pleadings; arbitrator-style hearing within 14-30 days of filing.
2. Eastern Suffolk County civil disputes
The five eastern Suffolk towns — East Hampton, Southampton, Riverhead, Shelter Island, Southold — are excluded from Suffolk District Court coverage. Civil matters arising in those towns route to the Town Justice Court for amounts up to $3,000 and to Suffolk Supreme Court for higher amounts. There is no $15,000-cap middle tier in eastern Suffolk.
3. Town / Village L&T summary proceedings
RPAPL Article 7 nonpayment and holdover petitions filed in the town or village where the rental property is located. 14-day rent demand (post-HSTPA § 711(2)) and 30/60/90-day holdover notice (RPL § 226-c) apply. The Justice Court hears the petition; the tenant has the same defenses available in NYC Housing Court (warranty of habitability, retaliatory eviction, etc.).
4. Code-enforcement Town Court referrals
Town and Village Justice Courts hear local code-enforcement matters — zoning violations, junk-vehicle ordinances, short-term-rental disputes — referred by the municipality. This is a civil-but-enforcement-adjacent docket distinct from the consumer civil matters above.
Distinctives
Procedure is leaner than other civil courts
Justice Court civil procedure is deliberately streamlined. 22 NYCRR Part 214 mirrors Part 212 (Long Island District Court) with further simplifications:
- Pleadings can be very short
- Discovery is rare and requires court permission
- Motion practice is limited; most disputes resolve at the first or second appearance
- Trial is usually a 1-2 hour bench trial
Appeal goes to County Court, not Appellate Division
Appeals from Justice Court civil judgments go to the County Court of the same county under UJCA § 1701, not to the Appellate Division. (Some districts route appeals to Appellate Term instead — verify per the Second Department's coverage map.)
Recording is local — not unified
Justice Court records are kept by the Town or Village — not by OCA. Pulling a record requires contacting the specific court clerk by phone (no central electronic docket). Some larger Town Justice Courts have begun publishing dockets online; most have not.
Right to Counsel and Good Cause Eviction — opt-in
Local Law 136 universal Right to Counsel applies only in NYC. Outside NYC, RTC is opt-in by municipality and is not available in most Justice Courts. The 2024 Good Cause Eviction Law is opt-in by municipality outside NYC — verify whether the Town or Village has adopted before drafting a Good Cause defense or holdover petition.
Witness fees + costs are token
UJCA § 1903 caps witness fees at $5/day; subpoena fees at $5/document. The court's general operating cost structure is intentionally low.
Filing checklist
- Summons + Complaint — UJCA § 401; short form; $20 filing fee (UJCA § 1911); affidavit of service under CPLR 308 service rules
- Predicate notice — for L&T, 14-day rent demand under RPAPL § 711(2) or 30/60/90-day holdover notice under RPL § 226-c
- Answer — defendant has 20 days from personal service or 30 days from substituted service
- First appearance — typically 14-30 days from issue joined
- Trial — bench trial; 30-90 days from filing in most cases
Format compliance: 22 NYCRR Part 214 governs Justice Court filings. Use
ny-statewide-formatas the baseline; Part 214 is the leanest of the trial-court format rule sets.
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-statewide-format— baseline 22 NYCRR Part 202 format with Part 214 Justice Court adjustmentsny-nyc-civil-court— distinct court for matters inside NYCny-city-courts— distinct court for matters inside a city's territorial reachny-suffolk-dc— distinct court for the five western Suffolk towns + Brookhaven (eastern Suffolk towns route to Justice Court)ny-county-courts— appellate destination for Justice Court civil appealsny-consumer-debt— CCFA applies in Justice Court Civil Part the same way it applies elsewhereny-landlord-tenant— RPAPL Article 7 mechanics for Justice Court L&T docketny-pro-se— pro se frameworkny-file-packet— paper-filing assembly (Justice Courts are paper-only in most jurisdictions)
Pro-se resources
- NYS OCA Court Help —
nycourts.gov/courthelp/has Justice Court-specific forms - OCA Justice Court Assistance Program (JCAP) — staff available for procedural questions
- Regional legal aid offices (LawNY, LSHV, Legal Aid Buffalo, Hiscock, Legal Aid Society of NE NY) cover most upstate counties for income-qualifying defendants in L&T and major-asset civil matters
When to escalate out of Justice Court
If the dispute exceeds the $3,000 civil cap, the action must be commenced in:
- Supreme Court — general jurisdiction; no monetary
cap (use the appropriate
ny-nyco,ny-kings,ny-bronx,ny-nassau,ny-queens, orny-county-courtsskill) - County Court — civil jurisdiction up to $25,000 in counties outside NYC (rarely used as a civil forum since most counties prefer to route civil to Supreme Court)
- District Court — Nassau or Suffolk only; $15,000 cap
For L&T matters, even at low rent-arrears values, the Justice Court remains the proper forum for the town / village where the property is located.
Kings County Supreme Court
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Verify the assigned Justice's Part Rules before every filing.
At a glance
- Court: Supreme Court of the State of New York, Kings County (2nd Judicial District). The 2nd JD also covers Richmond County (Staten Island), but Richmond cases are filed in Richmond County Supreme Court.
- Courthouse: 360 Adams Street, Brooklyn NY 11201 (Cadman Plaza)
- Index-number prefix: e.g.,
5[xxxxx]/YYYYgeneral civil;5[xxxxx]/YYYYCommercial Division (with RJI flag); matrimonial uses a separate prefix - Commercial Division threshold: $150,000 (lower than NY County's $500,000)
- E-filing: NYSCEF mandatory for most civil case types
- Hearings: Microsoft Teams for routine appearances; in-person for trials and contested evidentiary hearings
Distinctives
High foreclosure / consumer-debt volume
Kings County has historically processed more residential foreclosures than any other NY county. CPLR 3408 mandatory foreclosure settlement conferences apply to every home-loan foreclosure; the Kings County Foreclosure Settlement Conference Part processes these in a centralized calendar. Pro se homeowners commonly appear here.
Consumer-debt cases under $50,000 are filed in Kings County
Civil Court (141 Livingston Street) under the CCA (Civil
Court Act), not Supreme Court. See ny-county-courts for
Civil Court / Civil Court of the City of New York coverage.
CPLR 3215(g)(3) — additional notice in consumer-credit default applications
In any consumer-credit transaction (the term echoes the new
CPLR 3015(e) and the FDCPA), CPLR 3215(g)(3) requires the
plaintiff to mail a copy of the summons with an extra notice
to the defendant at least 20 days before any default
application. Kings County clerks have historically rejected
default applications missing this notice. This rule was
expanded by the 2022 CCFA via 22 NYCRR § 202.27-a — see
ny-consumer-debt.
IAS Part assignment in Kings County
After RJI, the case routes to an IAS Part under 22 NYCRR § 202.3. Kings County Part Rules: https://ww2.nycourts.gov/ courts/2jd/kings/civil/Civil_Part_Rules.shtml — verify the assigned Justice's current rules every time, because page limits, motion-conference requirements, and submission protocols differ substantially across Parts.
CPLR 4544 — small-print contracts
Kings County consumer cases routinely involve credit-card
agreements in small print. CPLR 4544 bars admission of
any contract whose printed type is smaller than 8 points
unless a true and complete copy is provided. This is a
standard objection in Kings County consumer-debt defense —
see ny-consumer-debt.
Filing checklist
- NYSCEF: file Summons + Complaint via NYSCEF; pay $210 index-number fee
- RJI: file the RJI (UCS-840) before motion practice ($95 fee in commenced cases)
- Service: CPLR Article 3 — within 120 days under CPLR 306-b
- Preliminary Conference: scheduled by the assigned IAS Part under 22 NYCRR § 202.12
- Notice of Motion: returnable before the assigned IAS Part; conform timing to CPLR 2214(b) plus the Justice's Part Rules
Common Kings County filings
- Foreclosure settlement conference notice under CPLR 3408
- Pre-answer motion to dismiss under CPLR 3211 (often
raising statute-of-limitations defense under the new CPLR
213(a) 3-year SOL — see
ny-consumer-debt) - Order to Show Cause (CPLR 2214(d)) — common in emergency foreclosure cases (e.g., to stay sale)
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-statewide-format— baseline format ruleny-consumer-debt— foreclosure / debt-buyer defense in Kings County (often the highest-volume use case)ny-landlord-tenant— Kings County Civil Court housing practice (cross-reference for Supreme Court filers)ny-discovery— discovery mechanicsny-schedule-hearing— Part-Rule scheduling protocolsny-file-packet— NYSCEF assembly
New York Landlord-Tenant Practice
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Landlord-tenant law in New York is heavily statute-driven and has changed dramatically with HSTPA 2019 and the 2024 Good Cause Eviction Law. Verify the current text of every cited rule before relying.
NY landlord-tenant overview
| Forum | Cases |
|---|---|
| Housing Court Part of NYC Civil Court | NYC residential summary proceedings — by far the largest forum (~150,000+ filings/year pre-pandemic) |
| District Court (Nassau/Suffolk) | Suburban Long Island residential cases |
| City Courts (upstate) | Buffalo, Rochester, Syracuse, etc. |
| Town/Village Justice Courts | Rural and small-town cases |
| Supreme Court | Ejectment actions (under CPLR Article 39); complex commercial L&T; rent overcharge |
Summary proceedings — RPAPL Article 7
The fast-track eviction mechanism. Two main flavors:
Nonpayment proceeding (RPAPL § 711(2))
For tenants in default on rent. Required predicate:
- 14-day written demand for rent (RPL § 711(2); HSTPA- amended). Specifies amount due; must be served in writing by certified mail, personal delivery, or another permissible method.
- Petition + Notice of Petition — RPAPL § 731. Filed in Housing Court (NYC) or local L&T court.
- Answer: tenant has 7-10 days depending on service method (RPAPL § 743).
Holdover proceeding (RPAPL § 711(1))
For tenants whose tenancy has been terminated (lease expired, breach of lease, etc.). Required predicate:
- Notice to vacate / Termination notice:
- Month-to-month tenancy: 30 days if tenant lived under 1 year; 60 days if 1-2 years; 90 days if 2+ years (RPL § 226-c, post-HSTPA)
- For-cause termination: 10-day or 30-day cure notice depending on lease and statute
- Petition + Notice of Petition — RPAPL § 731
- Answer: tenant has 7-10 days
HSTPA 2019 — major reform
L 2019, ch 36. Key changes:
- Security deposit cap: 1 month's rent maximum (GOL § 7-108(1-a))
- Late fee cap: $50 or 5%, whichever is less; only after 5-day grace period (RPL § 238-a(2))
- Rent-overcharge lookback: 6 years (RSL § 26-516)
- Attorney's fees: bilateral fee shifting where lease has unilateral pro-landlord fee clause (RPL § 234)
- Tenant blacklist: courts may not maintain a public list of L&T defendants (RPAPL § 745-b)
- Application fees: capped at $20 (RPL § 238-a)
Good Cause Eviction Law (2024)
L 2024, ch 56, Part C. NY's first statewide "just-cause" protection. Key features:
- Applies to: most market-rate rentals in NYC + opt-in cities/towns (Albany, Newburgh, etc.)
- Excludes: small-building owner-occupied; certain newly-built; condos and co-ops; rent-regulated (already covered)
- Just-cause grounds (RPL § 211(2)):
- Nonpayment
- Substantial breach
- Nuisance
- Withholding access for repairs
- Illegal use
- Owner / family use (with conditions)
- Demolition / substantial rehabilitation
- Rent-increase limit: greater of (i) CPI + 5% or (ii) 10% — challengable in court (RPL § 213)
- Notice requirements: increase notices must reference the law's protections (RPL § 214)
Rent regulation regimes (NYC and certain suburbs)
| Regime | Covered units |
|---|---|
| Rent Stabilization | Pre-1974 NYC buildings of 6+ units; certain post-1974 with tax abatements; ~966,000 units in NYC |
| Rent Control | NYC pre-1947 buildings with continuous occupancy since 1971; few units remaining |
| Loft Law (MDL Art 7-C) | Interim multiple dwellings in commercial buildings; coverage debated |
| NYCHA / Section 8 | Public housing + voucher tenants; separate rules |
| Mitchell-Lama | Limited-equity coops/rentals |
DHCR (Division of Housing and Community Renewal) administers state-regulated; HCR Tenant Protection Unit enforces.
RPL § 235-b — Warranty of habitability
Implied in every residential lease. Covers conditions materially affecting health, safety, or use. Tenants can:
- Withhold rent (after notice + opportunity to cure)
- Repair and deduct (case law: Jangla v. Brooklyn Hous. & Family Servs.)
- Sue for rent abatement (counterclaim or affirmative action)
Common conditions: heat (RPL § 235-b + NYC Admin Code § 27-2029 — 65°F day / 55°F night in winter); hot water (RPL § 235-b); pests; mold; lead paint (Local Law 1 of 2004); peeling paint (Local Law 31 of 2020 inspection requirement).
ERAP — Emergency Rental Assistance Program
A pandemic-era state program providing up to 15 months of rent to qualifying tenants. ERAP application creates an automatic stay of eviction proceedings under L 2021, ch 56 (as amended). The program reopened periodically; verify current status before relying on the stay defense.
NYC right to counsel
NYC Admin Code § 26-1301 (Local Law 136 of 2017) created a right to free legal representation for income-eligible tenants in housing-court eviction cases. Pro bono lawyers (through Legal Aid Society, Legal Services NYC, etc.) are assigned through the Office of Civil Justice. All NYC tenants are eligible regardless of income for help applying even when over income limits.
Defenses checklist
| Defense | Authority |
|---|---|
| Defective predicate notice | RPAPL § 711; case law |
| Defective service of petition | RPAPL § 735; CPLR 308 analog |
| Failure to plead landlord-tenant relationship | RPAPL § 741 |
| Rent paid before petition | RPAPL § 711(2) |
| Constructive eviction | RPL § 235-b + common law |
| Breach of warranty of habitability | RPL § 235-b |
| Rent-stabilization defense | RSL + rent registration |
| Retaliatory eviction | RPL § 223-b |
| Discrimination | NYS Human Rights Law (Exec Law § 296); NYC Human Rights Law |
| ERAP stay | L 2021, ch 56 |
| HSTPA cap on application fee / late fee | GOL § 7-108; RPL § 238-a |
| Good Cause Eviction (post-2024) | RPL § 211 et seq. |
Counterclaims checklist
| Counterclaim | Authority |
|---|---|
| Breach of warranty of habitability (rent abatement) | RPL § 235-b |
| Repair and deduct | Common law |
| Violation of NYC Admin Code (e.g., heat) | NYC Admin Code; private right under § 27-2120 |
| Discrimination | Human Rights Law |
| Harassment | NYC Admin Code § 27-2004 (NYC) |
| Constructive eviction (damages) | Common law |
| Attorney's fees | RPL § 234 (post-HSTPA — even against pro se if lease provides) |
Reference files
references/rpapl-article-7.md— summary-proceedings textreferences/hstpa-2019.md— HSTPA reform digestreferences/good-cause-eviction-2024.md— RPL Article 6-Areferences/rpl-235-b.md— warranty of habitabilityreferences/rent-regulation.md— rent stabilization / control / Loft Lawreferences/nyc-housing-court.md— Civil Court Housing Part practicereferences/right-to-counsel.md— NYC Local Law 136references/erap.md— emergency rental assistance + stayreferences/key-cases.md— controlling precedentsreferences/online-sources-lt.md— canonical URLs
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-statewide-format— format baseline (Housing Court uses 22 NYCRR Part 208 plus Housing Court-specific local rules)ny-first-30-days— 7-10-day answer triage (RPAPL § 743)ny-discovery— discovery in summary proceedings is available but typically requires court order (RPAPL § 735(2))ny-county-courts— NYC Civil Court Housing Part is the primary forumny-pro-se— pro se practice (most NYC tenants pre-Local Law 136 were pro se)
New York Law References
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Reference catalog. Verify against current rules before relying.
Federal corpora.
ny-law-references/references/federal-debt-laws/,federal-bankruptcy/, anducc-model/are links into theclaude-legal-federal-lawsdependency. If one is missing or a dangling link (some install methods copy only this plugin's folder), read the same file fromclaude-legal-federal-lawsvia itsfederal-law-referencesskill; file names are identical.
What lives here
This is the canonical reference catalog for New York
civil practice. Other ny-* skills cross-reference these
files rather than duplicating the content.
Body files (state-curated)
references/civil-rules.md— CPLR Article-by-Article summary (Articles 1–88)references/evidence-rules.md— Guide to NY Evidence topic index + selected CPLR Article 45 / 31 evidence provisionsreferences/uniform-civil-rules.md— 22 NYCRR Part 202 (Supreme/County), Part 208 (Civil Court of NYC), Part 210 (City Courts), Part 212 (District Court)references/citation-format.md— Tanbook conventionsreferences/fees-and-costs.md— CPLR Arts 81–89 fee shiftingreferences/local-rules.md— flagship-court Part Rules and the Commercial Division Rules (22 NYCRR § 202.70)references/key-cases.md— general-civil controlling precedentsreferences/online-sources.md— canonical URLs catalogreferences/legal-data-apis.md— programmatic-access index
Reference corpora (verbatim text — populated by future
pull scripts)
references/court-rules/— 22 NYCRR (Uniform Rules) + CPLR text + Commercial Division Rulesreferences/federal-debt-laws/(symlink) — points into the sharedclaude-legal-federal-lawspluginreferences/ucc-model/(symlink) — points into the shared pluginreferences/ny-statutes-debt/— N.Y. CPLR, N.Y. Gen. Bus. Law, N.Y. Gen. Oblig. Law, N.Y. Real Prop. Acts. Law, N.Y. Real Prop. Law, N.Y. Banking Law, N.Y. UCC (Article 9 enacted at N.Y. UCC §§ 9-101 to 9-809) — relevant chapters
CPLR at a glance
The Civil Practice Law and Rules (CPLR) is New York's master civil-procedure statute. Notable architecture:
| Article | Subject |
|---|---|
| 1 | Short title; application |
| 2 | Limitations of time |
| 3 | Jurisdiction and service, appearance and choice of court |
| 4 | Special proceedings |
| 5 | Venue |
| 6 | Joinder of claims, consolidation and severance |
| 7 | Parties generally |
| 8 | Costs |
| 9 | Class actions |
| 10 | Parties generally — substitution |
| 21 | Papers |
| 22 | Stays, motions, orders and mandates |
| 23 | Subpoenas, oaths and affirmations |
| 30 | Remedies and pleading |
| 31 | Disclosure |
| 32 | Accelerated judgment |
| 40 | Trial generally |
| 41 | Trial by a jury |
| 42 | Trial by the court |
| 43 | Trial by referee |
| 44 | Trial motions |
| 45 | Evidence |
| 50 | Judgments generally |
| 51 | Enforcement of judgments |
| 52 | Enforcement of money judgments |
| 53 | Recognition of foreign country money judgments |
| 54 | Enforcement of judgments entitled to full faith and credit |
| 55 | Appeals generally |
| 56 | Appeals to the court of appeals |
| 57 | Appeals to the appellate division |
| 58 | Appellate division terms |
| 62 | Attachment |
| 63 | Injunction |
| 64 | Receivership |
| 65 | Notice of pendency |
| 70 | Habeas corpus |
| 71 | Action to recover a chattel |
| 72 | Action concerning a will |
| 75 | Arbitration |
| 76 | Special proceeding to enforce statutory right |
| 77 | Special proceeding relating to express trust |
| 78 | Proceeding against body or officer |
| 81 | Costs generally |
| 82 | Amount of costs |
| 83 | Allowance of costs |
| 84 | Taxation of costs |
| 85 | Indemnity for costs |
| 86 | Disbursements |
| 87 | Security for costs |
| 88 | Fees |
| 89 | Poor persons |
Evidence — Guide to NY Evidence
New York does not have a codified evidence code. Instead, evidence rules live across:
- Common-law decisional rules — extensive case law ("Stigemeier" hearsay rules, "Holiday" past-recollection- recorded, etc.)
- CPLR Article 45 — selected codified evidence provisions (4504 physician-patient privilege, 4518 business records, 4521 government records, 4533 authentication of writings, 4544 small-print contracts, 4545 collateral source)
- Guide to NY Evidence — non-codified but authoritative secondary source published by the NY Unified Court System Evidence Guide Committee, available at nycourts.gov/judges/evidence
The Guide is organized in eleven articles mirroring the Federal Rules of Evidence numbering:
- Art 1: General Provisions (1.00–1.13)
- Art 2: Judicial Notice (2.00–2.05)
- Art 3: Presumptions
- Art 4: Relevance and Limits (4.00–4.27)
- Art 5: Privileges
- Art 6: Witnesses
- Art 7: Opinions and Expert Testimony
- Art 8: Hearsay
- Art 9: Authentication and Identification
- Art 10: Best Evidence Rule
- Art 11: Miscellaneous
Citation format — Tanbook quick reference
- Court of Appeals:
Roe v. Doe, 1 NY3d 100, 105 (2003) - Appellate Division:
Smith v. Jones, 50 AD3d 200, 201 (1st Dept 2008) - Misc. Reports (trial level):
Roe v. Doe, 15 Misc 3d 100 (Sup Ct, NY County 2007) - Reporter abbreviations: no periods (NY, NYS, AD, Misc)
- Statutes:
CPLR 3211(a)(7)— no "N.Y." prefix; in body text use the section number only - Session laws:
L 2021, ch 593 - Pinpoint cite:
at 105(no "p.")
Composition with other ny- skills
This skill is matter-neutral and referenced by all other
ny- skills*. When a downstream skill needs the
authoritative text of a CPLR section, an evidence rule, a
22 NYCRR provision, or a Tanbook convention, it cites or
links into this skill's references/ tree.
Nassau County District Court
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Verify the specific District's local rules and the assigned Judge's Part Rules before every filing.
At a glance
- Court: Nassau County District Court — established under the Uniform District Court Act (UDCA) and codified procedural rules at 22 NYCRR Part 212
- Civil jurisdiction: claims up to $15,000 (UDCA § 202)
- Small claims: up to $5,000 in informal proceedings (UDCA § 1801)
- Commercial claims: up to $5,000 in the Commercial Claims Part (UDCA § 1801-A; available to corporations / LLCs / partnerships that cannot use small claims)
- L&T (summary proceedings): no monetary cap on rent arrears; RPAPL Article 7 procedure
- Headquarters: 99 Main Street, Hempstead, NY 11550 (First District / Main Courthouse)
- E-filing: NYSCEF available for civil matters in Nassau District Court (one of the first District Courts to expand NYSCEF coverage). L&T filings are case-by-case.
Geographic districts
Nassau District Court is divided into six geographic districts. Each has its own courthouse; choice of district is determined by where the action arose or where the defendant resides (UDCA § 213).
| District | Coverage area | Courthouse |
|---|---|---|
| First District | All of Nassau County (countywide civil and L&T) | 99 Main Street, Hempstead |
| Second District | North Hempstead Town | 435 Plandome Road, Manhasset |
| Third District | Oyster Bay Town | 99 Main Street, Hempstead (Third District Part) |
| Fourth District | Hempstead Town | 99 Main Street, Hempstead (Fourth District Part) |
| Fifth District | Long Beach + Atlantic Beach + Lido Beach | Long Beach City Court (shared facility) |
| Sixth District | City of Glen Cove | Glen Cove City Court (shared facility) |
Filing tip: Most civil and L&T filings route to the First District unless the action is town-bound (e.g., a Hempstead Town code violation in the Fourth District). When in doubt, the Nassau County Clerk's office routes filings to the correct District based on the defendant's address.
Parts division
The court operates several specialized Parts:
- Civil Part — debt-collection and contract actions up to $15,000; small-claims actions up to $5,000
- Landlord-Tenant Part — RPAPL Article 7 summary proceedings (nonpayment + holdover); the Long Island analog to NYC Housing Court
- Small Claims Part — informal proceedings for natural persons; no formal pleadings required; trial is in two weeks
- Commercial Claims Part — same as small claims but for entities; UDCA § 1801-A
- Traffic and Parking Violations Agency (TPVA) — TPVA (Hempstead) handles parking and certain traffic; criminal Parts handle DWI / misdemeanors
Distinctives
Pro se debt-defense is the norm
Nassau District Court is the principal pro se debt-defense forum in Nassau County for debts under $15,000. Pro se defendants routinely file Answers and appear at "consumer credit calendar calls." The 2022 Consumer Credit Fairness Act (CCFA) applies in full — the heightened pleading requirements under CPLR 3015(e) (account statements, itemization) and the default-judgment scrutiny under 22 NYCRR § 202.27-a are enforced at the District Court level the same way they are in Civil Court of the City of New York and Supreme Court. Note that the 3-year SOL on consumer-credit actions (CPLR 214-i, added by the CCFA) shortens many District Court debt cases.
Long Island L&T forum
The Landlord-Tenant Part is the suburban analog to NYC Housing Court. Filings under RPAPL Article 7 (nonpayment + holdover) are the highest-volume case category after debt collection. Procedure tracks NYC Housing Court's structure: 14-day rent demand notice as a precondition to nonpayment proceedings (RPAPL § 711(2), 14-day rule from the 2019 HSTPA); 30-day notice to terminate for month-to-month tenancies under 1 year (Real Property Law § 232-a / § 232-b, with the 2019 HSTPA expansion to 30 / 60 / 90 days based on tenancy length); good-cause-eviction protection where adopted by the municipality (2024 Good Cause Eviction Law applies to several Nassau County municipalities by local option).
Discovery is limited
CPLR Article 31 disclosure applies in name, but District Court Civil Part practice is faster + leaner. Document demands and interrogatories are uncommon outside the formal pre-trial conference; the court expects most cases to resolve at the first or second appearance.
Notable: NYSCEF e-filing has expanded
Nassau District Court is one of the first District Courts to fully roll out NYSCEF for civil filings. Confirm the case type is e-fileable (most consumer-credit and contract actions are; L&T and TPVA are not yet). When NYSCEF is unavailable, filings go to the District Court Clerk in person or by mail at 99 Main Street, Hempstead.
Filing checklist
- Summons + Complaint: UDCA § 401 / 402 — short-form summons + complaint with the $45 filing fee (UDCA § 1911(1))
- Service: CPLR 308 / 312 within UDCA § 403 service period (typically 120 days)
- Answer: defendant has 30 days from service in the Civil Part (CPLR 320(a) / UDCA Article 4)
- Pre-trial conference: routinely scheduled within 60-90 days of issue being joined
- Trial date: court tracks toward trial 6-12 months from filing in most cases
Format compliance: 22 NYCRR Part 212 governs filings here. Margins, page size, caption format, and verification requirements mirror 22 NYCRR Part 202 with District Court- specific adjustments. Use
ny-statewide-formatas the baseline and verify Part 212 deviations before filing.
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-statewide-format— baseline format (22 NYCRR Part 202) with Part 212 adjustmentsny-county-courts— the broader roll-up that this skill refinesny-nassau— Nassau Supreme Court (separate court; over $15,000)ny-discovery— CPLR Article 31 mechanics (District Court Civil Part uses these in modified form)ny-first-30-days— Answer / pre-answer motion triageny-consumer-debt— CCFA pleading + default scrutiny applies in Civil Partny-landlord-tenant— RPAPL Article 7 Long Island L&T Part procedure (cross-references this skill's L&T Part)ny-pro-se— pro se framework (Nassau District Court is high-volume pro se)ny-file-packet— assembling a District Court filing packet for NYSCEF or hand filing
Pro-se resources
- Nassau County Bar Association Lawyer Referral Service: 516-747-4070
- Nassau / Suffolk Law Services (NSLS) — civil legal aid for low-income tenants and consumers
- Hofstra Law Family Court Litigation Clinic — referrals for related Family Court matters
- Court of Original Jurisdiction Self-Represented Office at 99 Main Street, Hempstead
Nassau County Supreme Court
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Verify the assigned Justice's Part Rules before every filing.
At a glance
- Court: Supreme Court of the State of New York, Nassau County (10th Judicial District). The 10th JD also covers Suffolk County, but Suffolk cases are filed in Suffolk County Supreme Court (Riverhead).
- Courthouse: 100 Supreme Court Drive, Mineola NY 11501 (with the Matrimonial Center at 400 County Seat Drive)
- Commercial Division threshold: $200,000
- E-filing: NYSCEF mandatory in most case types
- Hearings: Microsoft Teams + in-person hybrid; Nassau has been an early adopter of remote settlement conferences
Distinctives
Commercial Division activity
Nassau's Commercial Division is one of the most active outside New York County, hearing complex business disputes under 22 NYCRR § 202.70 (with Commercial Division Rules applied), particularly involving Long Island corporate matters and the metro-area financial sector. The $200,000 threshold is lower than NY County's $500,000.
Matrimonial Center
Nassau operates a separate Matrimonial Center at 400 County Seat Drive, with its own calendaring and IAS routing for divorce, custody, and family-law matters. The Matrimonial Center has dedicated settlement-conference parts.
MAP / mandatory ADR
Nassau Supreme Court runs an active mediation and arbitration program. Many civil cases are routed to MAP (Mandatory Alternative Procedures) early; pro se litigants should expect a Preliminary Conference order including ADR referral.
Foreclosure volume
Like NYC counties, Nassau has substantial CPLR 3408 foreclosure-settlement-conference volume, processed through a dedicated Foreclosure Settlement Conference Part.
Filing checklist
- NYSCEF: Summons + Complaint via NYSCEF; $210 fee
- RJI: UCS-840 ($95 fee) for motion practice
- Service: CPLR 306-b — within 120 days
- Preliminary Conference: 22 NYCRR § 202.12 within 45 days of RJI
- Notice of Motion: returnable before the assigned IAS Part per Part Rules
Part Rules
Nassau County Part Rules: https://ww2.nycourts.gov/courts/10jd/nassau/civil/index.shtml
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-statewide-format— baseline formatny-discovery— CPLR Article 31 + Commercial Division Rulesny-first-30-days— answer / pre-answer motion triageny-file-packet— NYSCEF assemblyny-consumer-debt— Nassau Civil Court covers debt-buyer cases under $25,000; over that, Supreme Courtny-landlord-tenant— Nassau District Court (separate trial court) covers L&T — cross-referenceny-county-courts
Civil Court of the City of New York
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Verify the specific borough branch's local procedures + the assigned Judge's Part Rules before every filing.
At a glance
- Court: Civil Court of the City of New York — established by the NYC Civil Court Act (Civil Court Act / NYC Charter § 2300 et seq.), procedural rules at 22 NYCRR Part 208, separate trial court from Supreme Court
- Civil jurisdiction: claims up to $50,000 (Civil Court Act § 202; CPLR 325(d) transfer back from Supreme Court if removed from CivCt)
- Small Claims jurisdiction: up to $10,000 in informal proceedings (Civil Court Act § 1801)
- Commercial Claims Part: up to $10,000 for entities that can't file in Small Claims (Civil Court Act § 1801-A)
- Housing Part: covered separately in
ny-nyc-housing-court(RPAPL Article 7 summary proceedings, the largest L&T forum in the country) - E-filing: UCMS (Universal Case Management System) / CCEF (Civil Court Electronic Filing) — distinct from NYSCEF used in Supreme Court / County Court. Mandatory for most consumer-credit matters in NY County and Bronx; expanding elsewhere.
Five borough branches
Each branch operates independently with its own clerk's office, calendar, and judge assignments. Filings route to the borough where the cause of action arose or where the defendant resides (Civil Court Act § 213).
| Borough | Courthouse | Address |
|---|---|---|
| New York County | NY County Civil Court | 111 Centre Street, NY NY 10013 |
| Kings County | Kings Civil Courthouse | 141 Livingston Street, Brooklyn NY 11201 |
| Bronx County | Bronx Civil Court | 851 Grand Concourse, Bronx NY 10451 |
| Queens County | Queens Civil Court | 89-17 Sutphin Boulevard, Jamaica NY 11435 |
| Richmond County | Richmond Civil Court | 927 Castleton Avenue, Staten Island NY 10310 |
The Bronx and Queens Civil Court buildings physically share facilities with their respective Supreme Court Civil Term houses (851 Grand Concourse and 88-11 Sutphin Blvd) — the courts are still legally distinct.
Parts division
NYC Civil Court runs a deep Parts structure. The principal ones for civil practice:
- Consumer Credit Part (each borough) — the dedicated
Part for consumer-debt collection actions; the
highest-volume civil-litigation forum in the country.
Calendar calls are routine; pro se debtors appear nearly
exclusively pro se. Post-2022 CCFA the Part enforces:
- CPLR 3015(e) heightened pleading
- 22 NYCRR § 208.6-a default-judgment scrutiny (the NYC Civil Court companion to § 202.27-a in Supreme Court)
- 3-year SOL under CPLR 214-i for consumer-credit actions
- Mandatory notification-of-action mailing under CPLR 308(six)
- Civil Part — general civil litigation up to $50,000; contract, tort, replevin, statutory claims
- Small Claims Part — informal proceedings; up to $10,000; no formal pleadings; the trial is by an arbitrator (with right to a "trial-de-novo" jury trial on request) and decided within a few weeks
- Commercial Claims Part — entity equivalent of small claims, up to $10,000
- Housing Part — RPAPL Article 7 summary proceedings;
covered in
ny-nyc-housing-court
Distinctives
NYC Civil Court is the primary consumer-debt forum in the state
By volume, NYC Civil Court Consumer Credit Parts hear more debt-collection cases than the rest of New York's courts combined. The 2022 CCFA was drafted specifically to address abuses in this forum:
- Debt-buyer plaintiffs (Midland, Cavalry SPV, Velocity, Unifin, LVNV, Cach LLC) historically filed in NYC Civil Court with sparse complaints, obtained default judgments through sewer service, and enforced against bank accounts under CPLR Article 52.
- The CCFA's CPLR 3015(e) heightened pleading, 22 NYCRR § 208.6-a default scrutiny, and CPLR 214-i 3-year SOL collectively flipped the burden onto plaintiffs to prove chain of title + itemization + last-activity-date before default judgment.
- The Consumer Credit Part judges now routinely deny default judgments sua sponte when the CCFA documentation is missing.
UCMS / CCEF — distinct e-filing from NYSCEF
NYSCEF (used in Supreme + County Court) and UCMS / CCEF (used in NYC Civil Court) are completely separate systems. A pro se litigant who has used NYSCEF in a Supreme Court matter will need to register separately at [nycourts.gov/courts/nyc/civil/efiling.shtml] for UCMS access. Document types, exhibit handling, and service mechanics differ. Verify which system before assembling a packet.
Department system — not IAS
NYC Civil Court does not use the Individual Assignment System (22 NYCRR § 202.3). Cases route to Departments that handle case categories, and within each Department to calendar parts and trial parts. A motion filed today may be heard by one judge and the trial held before another. There is no "Part Rules" lookup analogous to Supreme Court.
Small Claims arbitrators are not judges
Small Claims trials are heard by arbitrators (volunteer attorneys, judges pro tem) under Civil Court Act § 1804-A, not by sitting Civil Court judges. The pro se litigant has the right to demand a trial-de-novo before a sitting judge under § 1808, but must do so before the arbitration begins. The hearing is informal; CPLR Article 45 evidence rules apply with reduced rigor.
Self-Help Resource Centers in every borough
Each borough courthouse runs a Self-Help Resource Center with paid attorneys available to answer procedural questions for pro se litigants. Hours vary by borough; usually 9 AM-4 PM weekdays. The Consumer Credit Part scheduled calendar calls often coincide with the SHRC hours.
Filing checklist
- Summons + Complaint: Civil Court Act § 401 — short- form summons + complaint with the $45 filing fee (Civil Court Act § 1911(1)) for actions up to $1,000; $45 + $20 for actions over $1,000
- Service: CPLR 308 / 312 within Civil Court Act § 403 service period (typically 120 days under CPLR 306-b)
- CCFA notice (if consumer-credit action): plaintiff must mail an additional notice under CPLR 308(six)
- Answer: defendant has 20 days from personal service or 30 days from substituted service (CPLR 320(a))
- Calendar call: Consumer Credit Parts run a weekly calendar; the case appears 30-60 days after Answer
- Trial: 6-12 months from filing in most cases
Format compliance: 22 NYCRR Part 208 governs filings. Use
ny-statewide-formatas the baseline; Part 208 mirrors Part 202 with Civil Court-specific adjustments (case caption uses "Civil Court of the City of New York" instead of "Supreme Court").
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-statewide-format— baseline 22 NYCRR Part 202 format with Part 208 Civil Court adjustmentsny-nyc-housing-court— the Housing Part covered separatelyny-county-courts— broader roll-up that this skill refines (NYC Civil Court is no longer in the roll-up's scope)ny-discovery— CPLR Article 31 mechanics (Civil Court uses discovery in modified form; demands are uncommon)ny-first-30-days— Answer / pre-answer motion triageny-consumer-debt— CCFA pleading + default scrutinyny-pro-se— pro se framework (Civil Court Consumer Credit Part is overwhelmingly pro se on defense)ny-file-packet— UCMS / CCEF assembly
Pro-se resources
- NYC Civil Court Self-Help Resource Centers (one per
borough; check
nycourts.gov/courts/nyc/civil/) - CLARO clinics (Civil Legal Advice and Resource Office) — pro se debt-defense clinics in each borough
- NYLAG (New York Legal Assistance Group) — Mobile Legal Help Center
- Legal Aid Society Civil Practice — direct legal aid for income-qualifying defendants
- NYC Department of Consumer Worker Protection — consumer complaint intake (collection-agency licensure enforcement under NYC Admin Code § 20-486 et seq.)
NYC Housing Court (Civil Court of the City of New York — Housing Part)
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Verify the borough-specific Housing Part procedures and any building-specific regulatory classification (Rent Stabilization, Section 8, NYCHA, Loft Law) before drafting an answer or petition.
At a glance
- Court: Housing Part of the Civil Court of the City of New York — established under NYC Civil Court Act § 110 with the 22 NYCRR § 208.42 Housing Part rules overlay
- Jurisdiction: RPAPL Article 7 summary proceedings; no monetary cap on rent arrears; can hear contract claims related to the tenancy
- Filing fee: $45 for the petition (Civil Court Act § 1911); waivable on poor-person status under CPLR 1101
- Headquarters per borough (each Housing Part shares
facilities with the borough Civil Court courthouse):
- NY County Housing Court: 111 Centre Street, NY NY
- Kings Housing Court: 141 Livingston Street, Brooklyn
- Bronx Housing Court: 1118 Grand Concourse, Bronx
- Queens Housing Court: 89-17 Sutphin Boulevard, Jamaica
- Richmond Housing Court: 927 Castleton Avenue, Staten Island
- E-filing: UCMS with Housing Part-specific document codes; pro se filings often accepted in person at the clerk's office
Petition types
The two principal summary-proceeding flavors under RPAPL Article 7:
Nonpayment (RPAPL § 711(2))
The landlord alleges the tenant owes rent and has not paid after demand. Required predicate notice:
- 14-day written rent demand (post-2019 HSTPA — was 3
days pre-HSTPA). The demand must:
- identify the amount due, by month
- identify the lease provision the landlord relies on
- be served personally or by conspicuous-place service under RPAPL § 735
- NOT be filed before 14 days have elapsed
- An oral demand satisfies the statute only if the rent is current — i.e., the demand was for prospective rent — which is rare; written demand is the rule.
- After 14-day window, the Notice of Petition + Petition may be filed and served.
Holdover (RPAPL § 711(1))
The landlord alleges the tenancy has expired or been terminated (lease end, lease violation, no-lease tenant holding over). Required predicate notice depends on the tenancy length (RPL § 226-c, as amended by HSTPA 2019):
| Tenancy length | Notice period |
|---|---|
| <1 year | 30 days |
| 1-2 years | 60 days |
| 2+ years | 90 days |
For lease-violation holdovers, the landlord must serve a Notice to Cure specifying the violation and giving a reasonable cure period (often 10 days for most violations in the residential context), then a Notice of Termination if not cured, before filing the holdover petition.
Distinctives
14-day rent demand is jurisdictional
Service of a defective rent demand (e.g., wrong amount, incorrect lease cite, served too soon) is a complete defense to a nonpayment petition. Post-HSTPA case law treats the 14-day demand requirement as jurisdictional — the Housing Part will dismiss without prejudice rather than excuse a defective predicate notice.
NYC Right to Counsel (Local Law 136 of 2017)
NYC Admin Code § 26-1301 et seq. provides universal right to counsel for tenants in eviction proceedings who meet income thresholds (in 2026, 200% of federal poverty guidelines). Coverage rolled out by ZIP code 2017-2022 and is now citywide. Tenant attorneys assigned through:
- Legal Aid Society Civil Practice
- Legal Services NYC
- The Bronx Defenders
- Brooklyn Defender Services
- Volunteers of Legal Service
- CAMBA Legal Services
- Mobilization for Justice
The court's intake desk routes pending RTC referrals at first appearance. Pro se tenants should request a referral before answering on the merits.
ERAP (Emergency Rental Assistance Program) — automatic stay
A pending ERAP application automatically stays an eviction proceeding under L 2021, ch 56 / Part BB. The stay runs from the date of application through agency determination. The landlord cannot proceed to judgment while the stay is active. Verify ERAP application status (NYS OTDA) before any motion or trial.
Rent regulation overlays
NYC rent regulation includes overlapping schemes — verify applicability before drafting:
- Rent Stabilization — pre-1974 buildings with 6+ units; registration with DHCR; tenants have renewal rights under 9 NYCRR § 2521.5 and the post-HSTPA 6-year overcharge lookback under RSL § 26-516
- Rent Control — pre-1947 buildings; vanishingly few units remain; max-base-rent and capital-improvement caps
- Loft Law — pre-1980 industrial buildings converted to residential; coverage determined by NY State Loft Board
- NYCHA — public housing; federal grievance-procedure preempts much state L&T law
- Section 8 — voucher tenants; "good cause" termination required under federal regulations
- Mitchell-Lama — middle-income limited-equity coops / rentals; HCR-administered
Warranty of habitability counterclaim (RPL § 235-b)
Tenants routinely raise an implied warranty of habitability counterclaim seeking rent abatement for conditions (infestations, lack of heat/hot water, mold, leaks). The abatement is calculated as a percentage of the rent for the period of impairment. The Housing Part has dedicated Repair Parts that hear consolidated habitability applications.
2024 Good Cause Eviction (NYC opt-in plus statewide)
RPL Article 6-A took effect April 2024. In NYC, applies by default to most market-rate units. The landlord must have good cause for non-renewal of an unregulated tenancy. "Good cause" grounds:
- Non-payment after notice and cure right
- Lease violation
- Landlord recovering for personal/family use
- Removing unit from rental market
- Tenant nuisance
The law caps unreasonable rent increases at the greater of 10% or 5% + CPI. Increases above the cap are presumptively unreasonable and the tenant can challenge in Housing Court.
Pathway Home + diversion programs
Several NYC programs route Housing Part cases to mediation or rental-assistance before judgment — Pathway Home, the HRA One-Shot Deal, FHEPS rental subsidies, CityFHEPS. Verify program eligibility for the tenant at first appearance.
Filing checklist (landlord side)
- Predicate notice — 14-day rent demand or 30/60/90-day holdover notice, served per RPAPL § 735
- Notice of Petition + Petition — RPAPL § 731-732, served by RPAPL § 735 (5-day rapid service or conspicuous- place with mail follow-up)
- Filing fee — $45; submit affidavit of service
- First appearance — typically 10-17 days from service; tenant may answer in writing or orally
- Adjournments for RTC referral and ERAP stay are routine
Filing checklist (tenant side)
- Verify regulation — Rent Stabilization, Section 8, NYCHA, Loft Law status before drafting answer
- Request RTC referral at first appearance — NYC Admin Code § 26-1301 universal right to counsel
- Check ERAP — automatic stay if application pending
- Affirmative defenses + counterclaims:
- Defective predicate notice
- Defective service (RPAPL § 735 hyper-technical requirements)
- Warranty of habitability under RPL § 235-b
- Retaliatory eviction under RPL § 223-b
- HSTPA security-deposit cap violation (GOL § 7-108(1-a))
- Good Cause Eviction protection for unregulated tenancies
- NYC HRL / NYS HRL discrimination
- Rent overcharge under RSL § 26-516 (6-year lookback)
- Pre-answer relief: motion to dismiss for defective predicate notice or service under CPLR 3211
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-statewide-format— baseline 22 NYCRR Part 202 format with Part 208 Civil Court / § 208.42 Housing Part adjustmentsny-nyc-civil-court— the parent Civil Court structureny-county-courts— Long Island L&T routes to Nassau / Suffolk District Court Housing Parts (seeny-nassau-dc,ny-suffolk-dc); upstate routes to City Court / Justice Court (seeny-city-courts,ny-justice-courts)ny-landlord-tenant— comprehensive L&T subject bundle (RPAPL + HSTPA + Good Cause + warranty of habitability + rent regulation regimes)ny-first-30-days— Answer / motion-to-dismiss triageny-pro-se— pro se frameworkny-discovery— disclosure in summary proceedings (limited by default; available with court permission)ny-file-packet— UCMS / Housing Part assembly
Pro-se resources
- NYC Tenant Helpline: 311 → Tenant Support
- Right to Counsel referral at every Housing Part intake desk
- Met Council on Housing — tenant counseling
- CityFHEPS / FHEPS — rental subsidy applications
- Pathway Home — pre-judgment mediation / settlement
- Office of the Public Advocate — Tenant Rights hotline
- Legal Aid Society Civil Practice — direct legal aid
New York County Supreme Court
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Verify the assigned Justice's Part Rules before every filing. Part Rules vary case-by-case in New York County and override generic uniform-rule guidance.
At a glance
- Court: Supreme Court of the State of New York, New York County (1st Judicial District)
- Index-number prefix: Commercial actions typically
65[xxxxx]/YYYY; matrimonial35[xxxxx]/YYYY; uncontested matrimonial30[xxxxx]/YYYY. The first two or three digits of the index number indicate the case type. - Courthouses:
- 60 Centre Street — primary civil courthouse; most IAS Parts; Commercial Division
- 111 Centre Street — Civil Court of the City of New
York (a separate trial court — see
ny-county-courts) plus some Supreme Court parts (Surrogate's annex, etc.) - 80 Centre Street — additional Supreme Court space
- 71 Thomas Street — Matrimonial annex
- E-filing: NYSCEF mandatory (consensual in some legacy case categories; mandatory in commercial and consumer-credit actions since 2014–2022 rollouts)
- Hearings: Microsoft Teams for most appearances post-2020; in-person for trials and contested evidentiary hearings
- Holiday list: 22 NYCRR § 202.5-b NYSCEF treats holiday
closures per NY Gen. Constr. Law § 24 — see
ny-deadlines
Assignment system: IAS (Individual Assignment System)
New York's Individual Assignment System (22 NYCRR § 202.3) routes every case to a single IAS Justice at commencement. That Justice owns the case through judgment. Practical consequences:
- The Notice of Motion is returnable before the assigned Justice's Part, not before a generic motion calendar
- Each Justice publishes their own Part Rules ("Rules of Practice for Part [##]") — page limits, deadlines for pre-motion conferences, courtesy-copy requirements, oral- argument practice. These supersede the uniform rules.
- Find the Justice's Part Rules at https://ww2.nycourts.gov/courts/1jd/supctmanh/Part%20Rules.shtml (the "1jd" path is the 1st Judicial District index)
Commercial Division (22 NYCRR § 202.70)
The Commercial Division is a separate division within Supreme Court, NY County, for commercial disputes meeting two tests:
- Subject matter — one of 28 enumerated categories in 22 NYCRR § 202.70(b), including breach of contract among merchants, UCC matters, partnership / corporate dissolution, franchise disputes, certain consumer-class actions, certain intellectual-property matters
- Monetary threshold — NY County: $500,000 (excluding punitive damages, attorneys' fees, costs, interest). Other counties have lower thresholds (Nassau: $200,000; Westchester: $200,000; Kings/Bronx/Queens: $150,000; Erie: $50,000; Albany: $50,000; etc.).
Commercial Division Rules (22 NYCRR § 202.70(g)) are substantially more rigorous than the uniform rules: 25-page limit on memoranda (Rule 17), expedited discovery, mandatory mediation (Rule 3), accelerated motion practice. Many of these rules have migrated to the broader Uniform Civil Rules over time (e.g., the 25-page limit became 22 NYCRR § 202.8-b in 2021 statewide). Always check the current text of the operative rule.
Filing checklist
- Commence the action: file a Summons and Verified Complaint (or Summons + Notice / Summons + Complaint) plus a Request for Judicial Intervention (RJI, UCS-840) plus the $210 index-number fee (CPLR 8018) and the $95 RJI fee (where applicable). Issued via NYSCEF.
- Note of Issue / RJI: filing the RJI assigns the case to an IAS Justice (22 NYCRR § 202.6). RJI not required at commencement but is required before any motion practice.
- Service: under CPLR Article 3 — Summons + Complaint on every defendant within 120 days of filing (CPLR 306-b). Affidavit of service filed via NYSCEF.
- Notice of Motion: schedule a return date under the assigned Justice's Part Rules; conform timing to CPLR 2214(b) — 8-day minimum service period, 16 days for cross- motions, longer if the Justice's Part Rules require pre- motion letters.
Discovery in NY County
- Preliminary Conference under 22 NYCRR § 202.12 — held within 45 days of RJI; sets discovery deadlines
- Compliance Conference — mid-discovery checkpoint
- Note of Issue — certifies discovery complete (22 NYCRR § 202.21); within 90 days of note of issue, parties may file dispositive motions
- Commercial Division Rule 11 allows expedited interim discovery practice
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-statewide-format— baseline format ruleny-discovery— CPLR Article 31 discovery mechanicsny-schedule-hearing— Part-Rule scheduling protocolsny-first-30-days— answer / motion-to-dismiss triage when served with an NY County complaintny-file-packet— assembling an NYSCEF packet for NY Countyny-consumer-debt— debt-buyer cases (often filed in NY County Civil Court, not Supreme Court — seeny-county-courts)
New York Personal-Injury Practice
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. PI practice in NY is highly deadline-sensitive; verify every SOL and predicate-notice clock against the canonical CPLR / Insurance Law / EPTL sources before relying on this skill.
SOL catalog (the most-used)
| Claim | SOL | Citation |
|---|---|---|
| General negligence / strict liability | 3 years | CPLR 214(5) |
| Defamation / libel / slander | 1 year | CPLR 215(3) |
| Battery / assault / false imprisonment | 1 year | CPLR 215(3) |
| Medical / dental malpractice | 2 years 6 months (30 months) | CPLR 214-a; continuous-treatment toll under Borgia v. City of New York |
| Foreign-object medical malpractice | 1 year from discovery (with 30-month cap from action) | CPLR 214-a |
| Toxic substance / latent injury | 3 years from discovery (CPLR 214-c "discovery rule") | CPLR 214-c |
| Asbestos / environmental hazard | CPLR 214-c discovery rule | |
| Wrongful death | 2 years from death | EPTL § 5-4.1 |
| Loss of consortium | derivative — tracks the underlying claim's SOL | |
| Negligent infliction of emotional distress | 3 years CPLR 214(5) | |
| Intentional infliction of emotional distress | 1 year CPLR 215(3) | |
| Action against state / municipality | 1 year + 90 days after accrual (after the GML § 50-e 90-day Notice of Claim) | CPLR 217-a / GML § 50-i |
Revival windows — historic
- Child Victims Act (CPLR 214-g, L 2019 ch 11; revival window expired August 14, 2021): one-time revival of sex-abuse claims occurring while the survivor was a minor.
- Adult Survivors Act (CPLR 214-j, L 2022 ch 203; revival window expired November 23, 2023): one-time revival of sex-abuse claims occurring while the survivor was 18+.
The revival windows have closed — but cases filed within the windows continue under the normal NY procedural framework.
No-fault threshold for MVA
Insurance Law Article 51 (the No-Fault Law) governs motor-vehicle-accident PI. A plaintiff cannot maintain a common-law negligence action against the at-fault driver unless the injury crosses the "serious injury" threshold at Insurance Law § 5102(d):
- Death
- Dismemberment
- Significant disfigurement
- A fracture
- Loss of a fetus
- Permanent loss of use of a body organ, member, function or system
- Permanent consequential limitation of use of a body organ or member
- Significant limitation of use of a body function or system
- A medically determined injury or impairment of a non-permanent nature which prevents the injured person from performing substantially all of the material acts which constitute such person's usual and customary daily activities for not less than ninety days during the one hundred eighty days immediately following the occurrence of the injury or impairment
The serious-injury threshold is the most-litigated PI issue in NY. Defense counsel routinely move for summary judgment under CPLR 3212 alleging the plaintiff doesn't satisfy any of the nine categories.
First-party PIP benefits
Independent of the threshold, the no-fault insurer provides PIP (Personal Injury Protection) benefits up to $50,000 to the injured person (passenger or pedestrian) — medical, lost wages (80% up to $2,000/month), funeral expenses ($2,000), other reasonable expenses ($25/day). Claim notice under 11 NYCRR § 65-1.1 must be made within 30 days of accident.
CPLR 1411 + Article 16 — fault apportionment
Pure comparative fault (CPLR 1411 / Article 14-A)
NY follows pure comparative fault. The plaintiff's recovery is reduced by their percentage of fault — even if the plaintiff was 99% at fault, they still recover 1%. No contributory-negligence bar.
Article 16 — limited several liability for non-economic
CPLR Article 16 (§§ 1600-1603) limits joint-and-several liability for non-economic damages (pain and suffering). A defendant who is found 50% or less at fault is liable for only their proportionate share of non-economic damages — not the full joint-and-several amount. Economic damages (medical bills, lost wages) remain joint-and-several.
Exceptions (the Article 16 "carve-outs" — joint and several still applies):
- Motor-vehicle defendants (CPLR 1602(6))
- Defendants who acted with intent or actual knowledge
- Hazardous-substance defendants
- Construction Labor Law § 240/241(6) defendants
- Concurrent-tortfeasors-by-statute defendants
Labor Law §§ 200, 240, 241
The principal construction-site liability statutes:
Labor Law § 200 — common-law negligence codified
Owners, contractors, and agents have a duty to provide a reasonably safe place to work. Plaintiff must prove the defendant had notice of the dangerous condition + the authority to control the work.
Labor Law § 240(1) — absolute liability (the "scaffold law")
Owners and contractors are strictly liable for elevation- related injuries from a defective or absent safety device:
- Scaffolds, ladders, hoists, slings, blocks, pulleys, ropes
- Plaintiff need not prove notice or negligence
- "Sole proximate cause" defense available only if the worker's own conduct was the exclusive cause (rare)
- Comparative-fault reduction does NOT apply
The scaffold law is the most plaintiff-favorable construction-site statute in the country.
Labor Law § 241(6) — Industrial Code violation
Owners and contractors must comply with specific Industrial Code (12 NYCRR Part 23) regulations. A plaintiff must identify a specific code provision that was violated and that was a substantial factor causing the injury. Comparative-fault reduction DOES apply.
Notice of Claim — GML § 50-e
Actions against the State, City of New York, school districts, public hospitals, and other municipal defendants require a Notice of Claim filed within 90 days of the accrual of the cause of action (GML § 50-e). The claim must include:
- Name + post-office address of claimant + attorney
- Nature of the claim
- Time, place, and manner of occurrence
- Items of damage / injury
Late Notice of Claim is available by court order under GML § 50-e(5) — discretionary, considers the public actor's actual knowledge of the essential facts, prejudice, and the reason for delay. Petition must be filed within 1 year + 90 days of accrual.
The 1-year + 90-day SOL under GML § 50-i runs from accrual for the action itself.
Bill of Particulars — NY-unique PI practice
NY personal-injury practice features the Bill of Particulars at CPLR § 3041-3043 — a pleading-amplification document that the plaintiff serves to specify:
- Negligent acts alleged
- Injuries claimed
- Special damages (medical bills, lost wages)
- Lost-time periods
- Future-damages claims
A defective Bill of Particulars limits the plaintiff at trial. The standard NY PI defense playbook: serve a Demand for Bill of Particulars, then move to preclude under CPLR 3042 if responses are inadequate.
Wrongful death — EPTL Article 5 Part 4
EPTL § 5-4.1 governs wrongful-death actions:
- Personal representative of the decedent is the proper plaintiff (administrator or executor)
- Distributees entitled to recovery (the spouse + children + parents in priority)
- 2-year SOL from date of death
- Damages: pecuniary loss only — not pain and suffering pre-death (a separate survival action under EPTL § 11-3.2 covers conscious pain and suffering)
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-statewide-format— caption + Notice of Motion formatny-discovery— CPLR Article 31 disclosure (PI cases typically aggressive disclosure; both parties exchange medical records under HIPAA-compliant authorizations)ny-first-30-days— Answer + affirmative defensesny-hearings— Motion-day practiceny-deadlines— SOL + Notice-of-Claim arithmeticny-fact-check— Buckley v. City of NY and other citation patternsny-nyco/ny-kings/ny-bronxetc. — venue routing (PI cases route to Supreme Court when over $25,000; Bronx + Brooklyn historically have plaintiff-favorable juries)
High-yield PI checks
- MVA? Threshold + PIP benefits + no-fault arbitration?
- Government defendant? GML § 50-e 90-day clock + late- notice analysis?
- Construction site? Labor Law 240 vs. 241(6) vs. 200 triage?
- Medical malpractice? Continuous-treatment toll + CPLR 214-a 30-month math?
- Toxic / latent? CPLR 214-c discovery rule?
- Wrongful death? EPTL 5-4.1 personal rep + 2-year SOL?
- Article 16 applicability? Carve-outs for MVA, hazmat, Labor Law 240?
- Workers' comp interplay? WCL § 11 election + § 29 subrogation lien?
- Sex-abuse claim? CVA or ASA revival window applies (now closed for new filings but in-progress filings continue)?
Pro-se resources
- NYS OCA Court Help — PI section at
nycourts.gov/courthelp/ - Pro Bono Net — PI referral network
- NY State Bar Association Lawyer Referral: 800-342-3661
- NYC Lawyer Referral: 212-626-7373
New York Post-Judgment Procedure
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Post-judgment enforcement and debtor-protection rules are heavily statute-driven in NY. Verify the current text of every CPLR Article 52 section before relying.
Motion to vacate a judgment — CPLR 5015(a)
The principal post-judgment relief mechanism. CPLR 5015(a) allows vacatur on these grounds:
| Ground | Authority | Time limit |
|---|---|---|
| Excusable default | CPLR 5015(a)(1) | 1 year from notice of entry |
| Newly discovered evidence | CPLR 5015(a)(2) | Reasonable time |
| Fraud / misrepresentation | CPLR 5015(a)(3) | Reasonable time |
| Lack of jurisdiction | CPLR 5015(a)(4) | No time limit |
| Reversal / modification of prior order | CPLR 5015(a)(5) | Reasonable time |
The most-litigated ground in consumer-debt cases:
(a)(1) — Excusable default
Must show both:
- Reasonable excuse for the default (e.g., never served; service was defective; medical emergency)
- Meritorious defense to the underlying claim
The 1-year window runs from receipt of notice of entry, not from the judgment date. Pro se defendants in consumer-debt cases often miss it; the 22 NYCRR § 202.27-a (CCFA) heightened-evidence rule for default judgments now creates additional grounds for vacatur where the original default application was inadequate.
(a)(4) — Lack of jurisdiction
If service was defective (no service, wrong address, defective substitute service under CPLR 308) — no time limit to vacate. A common pro se motion in NY Civil Court debt-collection cases where the process server filed a "sewer service" affidavit.
CPLR Article 52 — Enforcement of money judgments
Restraining Notice — CPLR 5222
A judgment creditor can serve a Restraining Notice on:
- The judgment debtor — restrains transfer of any property except as permitted (exemptions, periodic exempt income)
- A garnishee (bank, employer, tenant) — restrains transfer of money/property owed to the debtor
Duration: 1 year (CPLR 5222(b)).
Limit: A bank served with a restraining notice cannot restrain more than twice the amount of the judgment in a single account; cannot freeze more than the judgment amount.
Income Execution (Wage Garnishment) — CPLR 5231
10% gross wages cap; 25% disposable income cap under federal law (CCPA, 15 USC § 1673). Process:
- Income execution served on judgment debtor first (CPLR 5231(d)) — debtor has 20 days to pay
- If unpaid, served on employer
- Employer remits per pay period
Property Execution / Levy — CPLR 5232
Sheriff levies on property; bank accounts, autos, etc. Exempt property cannot be seized (CPLR 5205, 5206).
Exempt Income Protection Act (EIPA) — CPLR 5222-a
A 2008 reform protecting exempt income from bank-account restraint. When a Restraining Notice is served on a bank:
- The bank must give the debtor a CPLR 5222-a notice + exemption claim form (EJ-FOC-1)
- The first $3,090 (adjusted; 2024 figure) of an account containing exempt income (Social Security, SSI, VA benefits, public assistance, alimony, child support, workers' comp, unemployment) is automatically protected
- The debtor can claim additional exemption by completing the form
Pro se debtors should immediately complete the EJ-FOC-1 if their account contains exempt income.
Exemptions — CPLR 5205, 5206
Personal property exemptions (CPLR 5205):
- Necessary household furniture / appliances / clothing
- Bibles, school books, pictures (limited values)
- A wedding ring
- One motor vehicle worth ≤ $5,275 (2024 adjustment; CPLR 5205(a)(8))
- Tools of trade worth ≤ $3,825
- Cash exemption: lesser of $2,750 or amount available if no homestead claimed
Homestead exemption (CPLR 5206):
- NYC, Nassau, Suffolk, Rockland, Westchester, Putnam: $165,550 (2024)
- Albany, Columbia, Dutchess, Orange, Saratoga, Ulster: $137,950
- Rest of state: $82,775
Subpoena to bank / Information subpoena — CPLR 5224
Creditor can serve an information subpoena on a bank to discover the debtor's accounts. Debtor has 7 days to move to quash.
Turnover proceeding — CPLR 5225 / 5227
Special proceeding to compel a third party (bank, employer) to turn over specific property. CPLR 5225(b) requires a notice of motion in a special proceeding format (commenced under CPLR 403).
Satisfaction of Judgment — CPLR 5020
When the judgment is paid, the creditor must file a satisfaction. Failure to do so within 20 days of debtor's written demand exposes the creditor to $100 + costs + attorney's fees under CPLR 5020(c).
NY 20-year SOL on money judgments — CPLR 211(b)
Money judgments in NY are enforceable for 20 years from entry (CPLR 211(b)). Compare WA (10 years) / OR (10 years) / CA (10 years renewable). NY's 20-year window is the longest in the U.S. — relevant when an old judgment surfaces.
Information subpoena practice
A common post-judgment device: serve an information subpoena (plus questionnaire) on the debtor or a garnishee to discover assets. Debtor must respond within 7 days; failure is contempt (CPLR 5251).
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-statewide-format— format for the motion to vacate papersny-draft-motion+ny-draft-declaration— scaffold the motion to vacateny-deadlines— CPLR 5015(a)(1) 1-year clockny-consumer-debt— debt-buyer cases (default vacatur is the most common pro se motion type)
Pro Se Drafting for New York
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. This skill assists self-represented litigants in drafting their own court documents. It does not provide legal advice. Pro se litigants face the same rules of procedure as represented parties; verify against current rules before filing. For complex matters, or matters with substantial sums at stake, consider consulting a licensed New York attorney.
Pro se status in New York
New York courts use "self-represented litigant" or "pro se" interchangeably. CPLR 321(a) allows a natural person to appear without an attorney. A corporation, LLC, or partnership generally cannot appear pro se in Supreme Court (CPLR 321(a) — must be represented by counsel); narrow exceptions exist in small-claims practice and certain limited-jurisdiction courts.
Signature block (pro se)
Dated: [City], New York
[Month Day, Year]
_______________________________
[PRINT NAME]
Self-Represented [Plaintiff/Defendant]
[Street Address]
[City, State ZIP]
[Phone]
[Email]
Key conventions:
- Use "Self-Represented Plaintiff" or "Self-Represented Defendant" — this is the NY convention; "In Pro Per" and similar labels from other jurisdictions are not used here
- No bar number (because no attorney admission)
- Email is recommended even for paper filings — NYSCEF service goes through email, and email service after appearance is now common
- No "Esq." suffix
Verification (CPLR 3020 / 3021)
If you serve a verified pleading, the verification is the sworn statement at the end:
VERIFICATION
STATE OF NEW YORK )
) ss.:
COUNTY OF [COUNTY] )
[PRINT NAME], being duly sworn, deposes and says: I am
the [Plaintiff/Defendant] in the within action. I have read
the foregoing [Complaint/Answer/etc.] and know the contents
thereof; the same is true to my own knowledge, except as to
matters therein stated to be alleged on information and
belief, and as to those matters I believe them to be true.
_______________________________
[PRINT NAME]
Sworn to before me this
___ day of __________, [YEAR].
_______________________________
Notary Public
Practical note: pro se litigants without notary access can use a CPLR 2106 affirmation in limited circumstances — but CPLR 2106 historically was for attorneys + medical/ dental/osteopathic professionals only. CPLR 2106 was amended in 2023 (L 2023, ch 559) to allow any person to affirm "under the penalties of perjury" in lieu of an affidavit. Pro se litigants may now use an affirmation without a notary.
Pro-se drafting framework — New York adaptation
The pro-se drafting framework (from the WA / OR plugins) applies in New York with these state-specific adjustments:
- Cite the rule, not the conclusion — every legal assertion must cite a specific CPLR section, statute, or case in Tanbook format
- Cite the record, not the conclusion — every factual assertion must cite to a specific paragraph of an affidavit/affirmation or a specific exhibit page
- Use the verb "respectfully" sparingly — over-use reads pro se; reserve for genuine respectful concessions
- Use precise NY terminology — "movant" not "moving party"; "respondent" or "non-moving party" for the opposing side on a motion; "Affirmation" for attorney sworn statements (and pro se 2023+) and "Affidavit" for notarized non-attorney statements
- Avoid "motion to" + verb constructions for non-CPLR motions — use the actual CPLR section's name (e.g., "motion to dismiss under CPLR 3211(a)(7)" not "motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim")
- Avoid "declaration"; use affirmation or affidavit — "declaration" is not NY civil-practice terminology
Service of process (CPLR Article 3)
| Method | Authority | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Personal delivery | CPLR 308(1) | First choice; affidavit of service required |
| Substituted ("leave and mail") | CPLR 308(2) | At dwelling/place of business + first-class mail; service complete 10 days after filing affidavit |
| "Nail and mail" | CPLR 308(4) | After "due diligence" fails at 308(1)–(2); affix to door + first-class mail |
| Mail with acknowledgment | CPLR 312-a | Voluntary; complete on signed acknowledgment return |
CPLR 306-b: service must be completed within 120 days of filing the summons; failure causes dismissal under CPLR 306-b unless the court extends.
Pro se plaintiffs typically use a process server (NYC license required for paid servers); the process server's affidavit of service is filed via NYSCEF.
Pro se resources for New York
| Resource | URL | Purpose |
|---|---|---|
| NY Courts CourtHelp | https://nycourts.gov/courthelp | Statewide pro se portal |
| LawHelpNY | https://lawhelpny.org | Statewide legal-aid referral |
| CLARO clinics | Various NYC Civil Court branches | Free attorney advice for debt cases |
| NYC Civil Court Help Centers | At each Civil Court branch | In-person navigation help |
| NY County Pro Se Office | 60 Centre Street, Room 116 | Supreme Court pro se desk |
| Kings County Pro Se Office | 360 Adams Street, Room 296 | Supreme Court pro se desk |
| Nassau Self-Represented | https://nycourts.gov/courts/10jd/nassau | Pro se resources |
| OCA Forms | https://nycourts.gov/forms | Statewide UCS-form catalog |
Common pro se motion types
- Motion to vacate default (CPLR 5015(a)) — most common pro se motion in consumer-debt cases
- Motion to dismiss (CPLR 3211) — pre-answer challenge to pleading sufficiency or jurisdiction
- Motion for summary judgment (CPLR 3212) — must come after issue is joined (i.e., after an answer is filed)
- Order to Show Cause (CPLR 2214(d)) — for emergency relief; requires judicial signature on the OSC itself
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-statewide-format— format baseline (22 NYCRR § 202.5)ny-draft-motion,ny-draft-declaration,ny-draft-note,ny-draft-order— pro-se drafting framework-adapted scaffoldersny-first-30-days— initial response windowny-deadlines— CPLR 2103/2103-a timing rulesny-consumer-debt— debt-buyer defense (the most common pro se case type in NY Civil Court)ny-landlord-tenant— NYC Housing Court pro se practice
New York Quality Check
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Pre-filing QC catches the errors that would otherwise cause a clerk's-office rejection or a Part- Rule denial.
Two-pass QC
Pass 1 — Format compliance
Run scripts/format-check.py against the PDF for mechanical
checks:
- Paper size: 8½ × 11
- Margins: 1 inch on all sides
- Font: Times New Roman 12-pt or equivalent serif 12-pt
- Spacing: Double-spaced; quotations 50+ words may be single-spaced and indented
- Color: Black text on white
- Pagination: Bottom center or bottom right
- PDF format: Text-searchable preferred; bookmarks for multi-document filings
Manual checks (the script doesn't catch these):
- Caption box: court name, county, parties, separator ("-against-"), index number, Justice, Part — all present and correctly formatted
- Document title: descriptive ("Affirmation of [NAME] in Support of Motion") and matches the NYSCEF document type
- Signature block: pro se "Self-Represented [Plaintiff/ Defendant]" or attorney with bar number; email address prominent
- Verification (if a verified pleading): notarized or CPLR 2106 affirmed
- Exhibit cover sheets: "Exhibit A" with cover sheet preceding each exhibit
- Notice of Motion / OSC: return date and Part match
Pass 2 — Content (pro-se drafting framework) compliance
The pro-se drafting framework — the principles documented in ny-pro-se:
- Every factual statement cited to a paragraph of an affirmation/affidavit or a specific exhibit page
- Every legal assertion cited to a CPLR section, statute, or case in Tanbook format
- No legal argument in sworn papers (move to memo)
- No new facts in memo (move to affirmation)
- Plain-language sections appropriate for the audience
- Discrete, numbered points in argument
- Concession of weak points; distinguish
- Restated "ask" in conclusion
Pass 2.5 — Substantive law check
- CPLR citations match the current code (CPLR amended through L 2024)
- Tanbook citation format (NY3d, AD3d, Misc 3d; no periods)
- Statute names correct (CPLR not "C.P.L.R." in body text; "N.Y. Gen. Bus. Law" not "GBL" except in abbreviation key)
- Effective dates considered — e.g., CCFA-affected rules (CPLR 213(a), CPLR 3015(e), 22 NYCRR § 202.27-a) apply to actions commenced on or after April 7, 2022
Common NYSCEF rejections
NYSCEF clerks reject filings for:
| Reason | Fix |
|---|---|
| Caption missing Index Number | Add to caption |
| Document type wrong | Reselect from NYSCEF dropdown |
| Multiple documents in one PDF | Split per NYSCEF rule |
| Insufficient bookmarks | Add bookmarks at start of each exhibit |
| Image-only PDF (no OCR) | Re-export as text-searchable PDF |
| File size > 100 MB | Split or compress |
| Missing affidavit of service | Re-file with service affidavit |
| Improper redaction (under 22 NYCRR § 202.5(e)) | Re-redact per § 202.5(e) personal-identifying-information rules |
Part-Rule-specific checks
Some Justices' Part Rules add requirements:
| Common Part Rule requirement | Verify |
|---|---|
| Pre-motion letter required | Did you file the pre-motion letter? |
| Courtesy copy to chambers | Send paper copy + cover letter? |
| Word-count alternative used | Word-count certification at foot of memo? |
| Joint stipulation re scheduling | Filed before the motion? |
| Oral-argument request | Affirmation requesting argument? |
Pre-filing checklist
[ ] Format-check.py passes
[ ] Caption matches across all documents in the packet
[ ] Index number on every page
[ ] Pagination on every page
[ ] All exhibits attached and labeled
[ ] All cross-references resolve to the right paragraph/exhibit
[ ] All citations Tanbook-formatted
[ ] Affirmation/affidavit signed and dated
[ ] CPLR 2106 affirmation language correct (post-2023 form)
[ ] Memorandum of Law within page limit (25/15 under § 202.8-b)
[ ] Notice of Motion has proper return date + service-period
[ ] Service date on Notice of Motion ≥ CPLR 2214(b) requirement
[ ] Proposed order present (if motion seeks an order)
[ ] Affidavit of service / NYSCEF service certification ready
[ ] Justice's Part Rules consulted for special requirements
[ ] Document types correctly selected in NYSCEF
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-statewide-format— format baselineny-fact-check— content + citation verificationny-file-packet— packet-level QCny-pro-se— pro-se drafting frameworkny-law-references— citation source-of-truth
Queens County Supreme Court
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Verify the assigned Justice's Part Rules before every filing.
At a glance
- Court: Supreme Court of the State of New York, Queens County (11th Judicial District)
- Courthouse: 88-11 Sutphin Boulevard, Jamaica NY 11435
- Commercial Division threshold: $150,000
- E-filing: NYSCEF mandatory in most civil case types
- Hearings: Microsoft Teams routine; in-person for trials
Distinctives
CPLR 3408 foreclosure volume
Queens has high residential-foreclosure filing volume, processed through a dedicated Foreclosure Settlement Conference Part under CPLR 3408. Pro se homeowners commonly appear; the conference parts run a structured triage where default-judgment dismissals are routinely vacated on a homeowner request under the now-codified due-diligence requirements.
Diversity of business and consumer practice
Queens is the most ethnically diverse U.S. county, which manifests in civil practice as: significant immigration- adjacent civil matters (defamation, employment, business), substantial consumer-debt defense volume, and translator- availability scheduling complexity. The court's Pro Se Office offers language-line support.
IAS Part assignment
After RJI, the case routes to an IAS Part under 22 NYCRR § 202.3. Queens County Part Rules: https://ww2.nycourts.gov/courts/11jd/supreme/civilterm/queens_partrules.shtml
Filing checklist
- NYSCEF: Summons + Complaint via NYSCEF; $210 fee
- RJI: UCS-840 with $95 fee
- Service: CPLR 306-b — within 120 days
- Preliminary Conference: 22 NYCRR § 202.12 within 45 days of RJI
- Notice of Motion: returnable before assigned IAS Part
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-statewide-format— baseline formatny-discovery— CPLR Article 31 discovery mechanicsny-first-30-days— answer / pre-answer motion triageny-file-packet— NYSCEF assemblyny-consumer-debt— debt-buyer defense (Queens Civil Court under $25,000; Supreme Court over)ny-landlord-tenant— Queens Housing Court cross-reference
Reserve a Motion Return Date in New York
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Verify the assigned Justice's Part Rules before selecting a return date.
NY scheduling model
Once a case is assigned to an IAS Part (after RJI filing), all motion scheduling is done through that Justice's Part. New York has no central motion calendar after assignment.
Each Part has its own scheduling protocol:
- Self-select from a calendar: many Justices publish a motion calendar on their Part Rules page; the moving party picks any open date
- Email request: moving party emails the Part clerk requesting a return date; clerk responds with a date
- Phone request: some Justices' Parts still use phone scheduling
- Calendar reservation system: some Comm Div Parts and high-volume Parts use an online reservation system
How to find the protocol
- Find the assigned Justice's Part Rules:
- NY County: https://ww2.nycourts.gov/courts/1jd/supctmanh/Part%20Rules.shtml
- Kings County: https://ww2.nycourts.gov/courts/2jd/kings/civil/Civil_Part_Rules.shtml
- Bronx County: https://ww2.nycourts.gov/courts/12jd/supreme/civil/PartRules.shtml
- Nassau County: https://ww2.nycourts.gov/courts/10jd/nassau/civil/
- Queens County: https://ww2.nycourts.gov/courts/11jd/supreme/civilterm/queens_partrules.shtml
- Scroll to "Motion Practice" or "Scheduling" sections
- Note the Part email address — typically "Part##chambers@nycourts.gov" or similar
- Note any pre-motion-letter requirement — some Justices require a 2-page letter before any formal motion
Calendar selection
A safe return date is:
- At least 13 days out (8-day minimum + 5-day mail add-on if serving by mail; CPLR 2214(b) + 2103(b)(2))
- At least 16 days out if expecting a cross-motion under CPLR 2215
- On a Part-published motion day (e.g., "Motions heard on Wednesdays at 9:30 AM")
- Not on a court holiday (
ny-deadlinesfor the holiday calendar)
Chambers email template
Subject: Request for Return Date — Index No. [#####/YYYY] — [Caption]
Honorable [Justice Name],
I am writing on behalf of Defendant [NAME], who appears
in the above-captioned action pro se. I respectfully
request a return date for a motion to [BRIEF DESCRIPTION,
e.g., "dismiss the complaint pursuant to CPLR 3211(a)(5)"].
Per the Court's Part Rules, the earliest available motion
date is [DATE]. The motion papers will be served by
[METHOD] on or before [DATE], satisfying the CPLR 2214(b)
8-day minimum service period plus any applicable mail
add-on under CPLR 2103(b)(2).
If a different return date is preferred or required, I will
adjust accordingly. Please confirm the date and any other
Part-Rule requirements (e.g., courtesy copy, oral-argument
request, etc.).
Thank you for your consideration.
Respectfully submitted,
[Print Name]
Self-Represented Defendant
[Phone, email]
Index No. [#####/YYYY]
OSC scheduling
For an Order to Show Cause, the moving party brings the unsigned OSC + supporting papers to chambers ex parte:
- NY County: 60 Centre Street, Room 130 — Ex Parte Office (also accepts emergency electronic submission via designated email)
- Kings County: 360 Adams Street, Room 296 — Ex Parte
- Other counties: chambers email or Part-Rule procedure
- The Justice signs the OSC and sets the return date and any TRO terms
- The signed OSC is then served on opposing parties per the directions in the OSC
Commercial Division specific
Comm Div Parts often:
- Use online reservation systems
- Require pre-motion letters
- Permit only one motion per pre-motion-letter exchange
- Schedule a "discovery conference" before motion practice
Check 22 NYCRR § 202.70(g) Rules and the specific Justice's supplemental rules.
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-draft-note— drafting the Notice of Motion / OSC with the return dateny-deadlines— minimum-notice computationny-nyco/ny-kings/ny-bronx/ny-nassau/ny-queens/ny-county-courts— court-specific Part protocolsny-file-packet— assembling the packet for filing once the date is reserved
New York Statewide Format
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. This skill provides drafting assistance only. Verify against current rules and case law before filing.
New York has no single, all-encompassing format rule. Format requirements live across three layers:
- 22 NYCRR § 202.5 — Uniform Civil Rules for the Supreme Court and County Court: page/font/margin rules for paper filings.
- 22 NYCRR § 202.5-b — NYSCEF (New York State Courts Electronic Filing) technical requirements for e-filed documents. NYSCEF is mandatory in most Supreme Court counties.
- Part rules — every Justice of the Supreme Court publishes individual "Part Rules" (sometimes called "Rules of Practice") that override or supplement the uniform rules. Check the assigned Justice's Part Rules before every filing.
Paper / page rules (22 NYCRR § 202.5(a))
- Paper size: 8½ × 11 inch (Letter)
- Margins: 1 inch on top, bottom, and both sides
- Spacing: Double-spaced text; quotations of 50+ words may be single-spaced and indented
- Font: Typeface that produces a clear copy; the rule is silent on a specific point size, but Times New Roman 12-point or Courier New 12-point is the de facto standard. The Commercial Division (NY County, Kings County, Nassau, Westchester, Erie, etc.) requires 12-point specifically under 22 NYCRR § 202.70(g) Rule 17.
- Color: Black ink on white paper for paper filings; NYSCEF accepts black-and-white or color PDFs but the body text must be readable monochrome.
- Page numbering: Bottom center or bottom right; format per Part Rules (some Justices require "Page X of Y").
- Stapling / binding: Paper filings — top-stapled, no fancy binding. NYSCEF — single PDF per document.
NYSCEF technical requirements (22 NYCRR § 202.5-b)
NYSCEF is mandatory in: NY County, Kings, Bronx, Queens, Richmond (commercial only), Nassau, Suffolk, Westchester, Rockland, Erie, Monroe, Onondaga, and most other Supreme Court counties. Civil Court of the City of New York uses a parallel system (UCMS / CCEF).
- File format: PDF (text-searchable preferred; image- only PDFs allowed for true-paper exhibits)
- Bookmarks: Required for documents with multiple exhibits; bookmark to first page of each exhibit
- File size: 100 MB per upload cap
- Naming: Descriptive document title; no special characters
- Signature: An "/s/ Name" typed line plus an
e-filed by [Name]line on the cover page; NYSCEF stamps the document automatically - Document codes: NYSCEF requires selecting a document type from a controlled list (Affirmation, Affidavit, Memorandum of Law, Notice of Motion, Order, etc.). Pick the closest match.
Line numbering (pleading paper)
Apply continuous line numbering down the left margin of every generated New York pleading. Line numbers count every line of the body and restart on each page.
22 NYCRR § 202.5 (paper) and § 202.5-b (NYSCEF) do not
themselves require line numbering, and a New York filing
without it is rule-compliant and routine; NYSCEF accepts PDFs
with or without line numbering. But line-numbered pleading
paper is universal practice across the claude-legal
marketplace: it lets the court and opposing counsel cite to an
exact location ("page 4, lines 12–15") and never harms a New
York filing. Apply it by default to every motion,
affirmation, memorandum, notice, and proposed order. Exhibits
and attachments are exempt.
Two distinct numbering mechanics in New York — both should be ON by default:
- Paragraph numbering under CPLR 3014 — sequentially numbered paragraphs in the body of every pleading; verified pleadings under CPLR 3020 retain the sequential paragraph numbering. This is the NY-pleading content mechanic.
- Line numbering — line numbers in the left margin enabling page+line pinpoint citation. This is the layout mechanic added here.
For programmatically generated .docx documents, apply line
numbering through the section's lineNumbers property:
import { LineNumberRestartFormat } from "docx";
sections: [{
properties: {
page: { /* size + margins */ },
lineNumbers: {
countBy: 1, // number every line
restart: LineNumberRestartFormat.NEW_PAGE, // restart 1.. each page
},
},
// ...
}]
This emits <w:lnNumType w:countBy="1" w:restart="newPage"/>
into the section's <w:sectPr>. The numbers render in the
left margin and do not shift the 1-inch text margin.
Do NOT set start explicitly. An explicit start: 1
renders off by one in LibreOffice (the first body line shows
"2"). Omit start — it defaults to 1 in OOXML.
Margin rule (double vertical line)
Draw a double vertical rule — two thin parallel lines
(~0.75 pt each, with a ~7 pt gap between them) — down the left
margin between the line numbers and the body text. It is the
standard companion to line-numbered pleading paper. Like line
numbering, 22 NYCRR § 202.5 and § 202.5-b do not require
it, but it is universal convention across the claude-legal
marketplace. Apply it by default to every line-numbered
pleading; exhibits and attachments are exempt.
Implement it as two independent full-height line shapes
anchored in the page header, so they repeat on every page —
not as an OOXML double page border, whose style couples
the inter-line gap to the line weight (widening the gap
thickens both lines into heavy bars).
Draw each line as a thin filled rectangle (VML v:rect).
One shape per <w:pict> — multiple <v:rect> elements in
a single <w:pict> will not all render; each rectangle needs
its own <w:pict> inside its own <w:r> run.
docx-js has no first-class API for header-anchored VML
shapes. Add them with the docx skill's unpack → edit → pack
workflow: generate the file with docx-js (give each section an
empty Header so a word/header1.xml part exists, and keep the
lineNumbers section property from above), then rewrite the
header XML and repack:
python scripts/office/unpack.py out.docx unpacked/
# ... inject the rule into unpacked/word/header*.xml (helper below) ...
python scripts/office/pack.py unpacked/ out.docx --original out.docx
Inside each unpacked/word/header*.xml, declare the VML namespace
on the root <w:hdr> and add the two runs — one v:rect per
<w:pict> per <w:r> — inside the header paragraph. A document
can have several header parts (first-page / even / default, or one
per section); add the runs to each distinct word/header*.xml,
giving every v:rect a unique id. This stdlib helper (no
python-docx) does it and is idempotent:
import pathlib, re
def _runs(i):
outer = ('<w:r><w:pict><v:rect id="VRuleOuter%d" '
'style="position:absolute;margin-left:60pt;margin-top:21.6pt;'
'width:0.75pt;height:748.8pt;'
'mso-position-horizontal-relative:page;'
'mso-position-vertical-relative:page;z-index:-251658240" '
'fillcolor="black" stroked="f"/></w:pict></w:r>') % i
return outer + (outer.replace('VRuleOuter%d' % i, 'VRuleInner%d' % i)
.replace('margin-left:60pt', 'margin-left:67pt'))
word = pathlib.Path('unpacked/word')
# 1. Double rule: one set of shapes per distinct header part (unique ids).
for i, hdr in enumerate(sorted(word.glob('header*.xml'))):
xml = hdr.read_text(encoding='utf-8')
if 'VRuleOuter' in xml: # idempotent
continue
if 'xmlns:v=' not in xml:
xml = re.sub(r'(<w:hdr\b)',
r'\1 xmlns:v="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:vml"', xml, count=1)
xml = xml.replace('</w:p>', _runs(i) + '</w:p>', 1) # first header para
hdr.write_text(xml, encoding='utf-8')
# 2. Keep line numbers off header/footer text.
for f in list(word.glob('header*.xml')) + list(word.glob('footer*.xml')):
xml = f.read_text(encoding='utf-8')
xml = re.sub(r'(<w:pPr(?:\s[^>]*)?>)(?!<w:suppressLineNumbers/>)',
r'\1<w:suppressLineNumbers/>', xml)
xml = re.sub(r'(<w:p(?:\s[^>]*)?>)(?!<w:pPr)',
r'\1<w:pPr><w:suppressLineNumbers/></w:pPr>', xml)
f.write_text(xml, encoding='utf-8')
The <w:lnNumType> line-numbering element is already emitted by
docx-js's lineNumbers section property (above), so the patch only
touches the header / footer parts.
Geometry (US Letter, 1-inch margins, line-number distance
360 twips = ¼″): body text starts at 72 pt and the line-number
gutter at ~54 pt, so the two rules at margin-left 60 pt and
67 pt sit ~7 pt apart, clear of both. The gap is the difference
of the two values; margin-top:21.6pt + height:748.8pt spans the
full page height; width:0.75pt is the line weight.
Verify with python scripts/office/validate.py out.docx then
python scripts/office/soffice.py --headless --convert-to pdf out.docx; confirm two thin parallel lines with a clear gap between
the numbers and the text on every page and that the header /
footer text is not line-numbered. Then open the .docx in
Microsoft Word, where VML renders slightly differently and the
output must still be correct.
The New York caption (CPLR 305(a) and 2101)
SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF [COUNTY]
----------------------------------------- X
[PLAINTIFF NAME(S)], :
: Index No. [#####/YYYY]
Plaintiff(s), :
: [DOCUMENT TITLE]
-against- :
: Hon. [JUSTICE NAME]
[DEFENDANT NAME(S)], : Part [##]
:
Defendant(s). :
----------------------------------------- X
Notes:
- "-against-" is the New York convention for the party separator. Not "v." or "vs."
- Index Number: assigned at the time of action
commencement under CPLR 306-a. Format
[######/YYYY](e.g.,651234/2024). Required on every paper after commencement. - The "X" enclosure on the left side is traditional; the dotted-line ladder on the right is common but not mandated.
- County name appears in all caps below the court name.
- "Hon. [Justice]" and "Part [##]" are added once a case is assigned; can be omitted before assignment.
Document title conventions
NY uses descriptive document titles centered below the caption box, in bold or underlined or all-caps:
- NOTICE OF MOTION — formal scheduling document (CPLR
2214); see
ny-draft-note - VERIFIED COMPLAINT — verified-pleading prefix (CPLR 3020) when the complaint is sworn-to
- COMPLAINT — unverified pleading (less common in consumer-debt and matrimonial matters)
- AFFIRMATION OF [NAME] IN SUPPORT OF [MOTION] — sworn
statement by an attorney (CPLR 2106); see
ny-draft-declaration - AFFIDAVIT OF [NAME] IN SUPPORT OF [MOTION] — sworn statement by a non-attorney (CPLR 2309)
- MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT OF [MOTION] — legal argument; not required if all law is in the affirmation but Commercial Division Rule 17 prefers a separate memo
- PROPOSED ORDER — see
ny-draft-order
Verified vs. unverified pleadings (CPLR 3020)
CPLR 3020(b) requires verification when:
- The complaint alleges an account-stated claim (most consumer-debt complaints) — CPLR 3020(d)(2)
- The pleading must be served on the State of New York or a State official sued in an official capacity
- Either party has demanded verification
CPLR 3020(a) says a verified pleading may be served on any opposing party who must then answer with a verified answer (CPLR 3020(a)). This creates a tactical decision: verifying your complaint forces the defendant to verify their answer, which can deter frivolous denials.
Verification is a sworn statement at the foot of the pleading: "[Affiant] swears the following pleading is true to the affiant's own knowledge, except as to matters alleged on information and belief which the affiant believes to be true." Signed and notarized (CPLR 3021).
Citation format — Tanbook
The New York Law Reports Style Manual ("Tanbook") is the official citation manual for New York state court filings. Key conventions vs. Bluebook:
- Court of Appeals:
Roe v. Doe, 1 NY3d 100, 105 (2003)— note the missing periods (NY3dnotN.Y.3d) - Appellate Division:
Smith v. Jones, 50 AD3d 200, 201 (1st Dept 2008)—AD3d, department in parens - Supreme/County Trial:
Roe v. Doe, 15 Misc 3d 100 (Sup Ct, NY County 2007)— published trial decisions go toMisc 3d(Miscellaneous Reports, 3rd Series) - Statutes:
CPLR 3211(a)(7)— no italics, no "N.Y." prefix in body text; "N.Y. C.P.L.R. § 3211(a)(7)" in out-of-state Bluebook context - Sessions Laws:
L 2021, ch 593— chapter laws - Public Authorities:
Public Authorities Law § 1276 - Spaces in citations: no spaces in compound abbreviations
(
NYS2dnotN.Y.S. 2d) - Pinpoint cites:
at 105for parallel reporter; no pinpoint with "p." or "pp."
State context
| Layer | Authority |
|---|---|
| Format rule | 22 NYCRR § 202.5 (paper) + § 202.5-b (NYSCEF) |
| Civil rules | CPLR (Civil Practice Law and Rules) |
| Evidence | Guide to NY Evidence + selected CPLR evidence sections (no codified code) |
| Statute | N.Y. CPLR; N.Y. Gen. Bus. Law; N.Y. Gen. Oblig. Law; N.Y. Real Prop. Law; N.Y. Real Prop. Acts. Law; etc. |
| Style manual | New York Law Reports Style Manual (Tanbook) |
| E-filing | NYSCEF (Supreme/County); UCMS/CCEF (NYC Civil Court) |
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-nyco/ny-kings/ny-bronx/ny-nassau/ny-queens/ny-county-courts— venue-specific overlays (Part Rules, courthouse logistics, scheduling)ny-pro-se— pro se conventionsny-draft-motion,-declaration,-note,-order— scaffolders that use these format conventionsny-law-references— full CPLR + Tanbook + 22 NYCRR reference corporany-quality-check— pre-filing QC against this format rule
Post-Hearing Order Submission in New York
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. The 60-day settle-order clock is jurisdictional in many courts. Missing it forfeits the right to settle the order.
When this skill applies
After the Justice rules on a motion, one of three things happens:
- Short-form Decision and Order — the Justice writes the decision on the proposed order itself; no further submission needed. The order is filed by chambers via NYSCEF.
- Decision directs settle order — "Settle order on notice" or "Settle order on submission"; the prevailing party must submit a proposed order within 60 days.
- Decision is self-executing — no order needed (rare).
This skill covers #2: the settle-order procedure.
The 22 NYCRR § 202.48 framework
Day 0: Justice issues Decision directing settle order
Day 0–60: Prevailing party drafts proposed order
Day X: Prevailing party serves proposed order on opposing
party (≥10 days before submission)
Day X+5: Opposing party may serve a counter-order
Day X+10: Prevailing party submits proposed order to chambers,
attaching counter-order (if served) and a cover
letter discussing differences
Day ≤60: Prevailing party submits to chambers; missing this
deadline is fatal absent extension
On notice v. on submission
| Direction | Procedure |
|---|---|
| "Settle order on notice" | Serve proposed order on opposing party 10 days before submission; opposing may serve counter-order within 5 days |
| "Settle order on submission" | Submit proposed order to chambers without separate service (NYSCEF service of the filing is sufficient) |
Proposed-order content
The proposed order should track the Justice's decision exactly:
- Use the decision's exact language for the relief granted
- Do not add relief not granted in the decision
- Do not omit relief granted in the decision
- Use the decretal "ORDERED that..." format
See ny-draft-order for the proposed-order template.
Chambers transmittal letter
When submitting on notice (or on submission), include a cover letter:
[Date]
Hon. [Justice Name], J.S.C.
Supreme Court, [County]
[Courthouse Address]
Re: [Caption], Index No. [#####/YYYY]
Submission of Proposed Order
Dear Justice [Name]:
Enclosed for the Court's signature is a proposed Decision
and Order in the above-captioned matter, submitted on
notice pursuant to 22 NYCRR § 202.48 and the Court's
Decision dated [DATE]. The proposed order tracks the
Court's directives in [GRANTING / DENYING] Defendant's
motion under CPLR [SECTION].
[If on notice and opposing served a counter-order:]
A copy of the proposed order was served on Plaintiff's
counsel on [DATE] (attached as Exhibit 1). Plaintiff's
counsel served a counter-order on [DATE] (attached as
Exhibit 2). The principal difference between the two
proposed orders is [DESCRIBE]. The undersigned
respectfully submits that this Court's proposed order
should be entered because [REASON].
Respectfully submitted,
[Print Name]
Self-Represented Defendant
[Phone, email]
Counter-order procedure
If the opposing party served a counter-order:
- Review both proposed orders side by side
- Identify differences — language, scope, conditions
- Submit both to chambers with a cover letter discussing the differences
- Chambers selects (or modifies) one of the proposed orders and enters it
Post-signature: Notice of Entry
After the Justice signs and the order is entered (filed on NYSCEF by the clerk):
- NYSCEF notifies all parties automatically
- Prevailing party files a Notice of Entry (CPLR 5513(a)) — triggers the 30-day appeal clock
- Notice of Entry:
SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF [COUNTY]
----------------------------------------- X
[CAPTION] Index No. [#####/YYYY]
Hon. [JUSTICE]
[Plaintiff(s),]
NOTICE OF ENTRY
-against-
[Defendant(s).]
----------------------------------------- X
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that the annexed is a true copy of the
Decision and Order of the Hon. [Justice], dated [DATE], and
filed and entered in the Office of the Clerk of the Court
on [DATE].
Dated: [...]
[Signature]
Filed via NYSCEF as document type "Notice of Entry."
Common errors
| Error | Consequence |
|---|---|
| Missing 60-day deadline | Right to settle order deemed abandoned (CPLR analog — Funk v. Barry, 89 NY2d 364) |
| Submitting order that goes beyond the decision | Justice rejects or modifies |
| Failing to serve 10 days before submission (on notice) | Justice may refuse to sign |
| Submitting without cover letter discussing counter-order differences | Justice can sign either; favorable side often loses |
| Failing to file Notice of Entry | 30-day appeal clock may run anyway upon NYSCEF entry |
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-draft-order— proposed-order contentny-hearings— post-hearing follow-upny-deadlines— 60-day clock + appeal clockny-fact-check— pre-submission QC
Suffolk County District Court
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Verify the specific District's local rules and the assigned Judge's Part Rules before every filing.
At a glance
- Court: Suffolk County District Court — established under the Uniform District Court Act (UDCA) and codified procedural rules at 22 NYCRR Part 212
- Civil jurisdiction: claims up to $15,000 (UDCA § 202)
- Small claims: up to $5,000 in informal proceedings (UDCA § 1801)
- Commercial claims: up to $5,000 in the Commercial Claims Part (UDCA § 1801-A)
- L&T (summary proceedings): no monetary cap on rent arrears; RPAPL Article 7 procedure
- Headquarters: 400 Carleton Avenue, Central Islip, NY 11722 (First District / Cohalan Court Complex)
- E-filing: NYSCEF expanding in Suffolk District Court civil filings; check NYSCEF case-type matrix before attempting
Coverage area — five western towns + Brookhaven
Suffolk District Court has jurisdiction only over the five western towns plus Brookhaven:
- Town of Babylon
- Town of Huntington
- Town of Islip
- Town of Smithtown
- Town of Brookhaven
The five eastern towns — Riverhead, Southold, Shelter Island, Southampton, and East Hampton — are outside the District Court's jurisdiction. Civil matters arising in those towns route to the Town Justice Courts (Uniform Justice Court Act, civil jurisdiction up to $3,000). This is a frequent surprise for pro se litigants who file in Central Islip a case that actually belongs in (e.g.) Southampton Town Justice Court.
| District | Coverage | Courthouse |
|---|---|---|
| First District | Town of Babylon | 400 Carleton Avenue, Central Islip (Cohalan Complex) |
| Second District | Town of Babylon | 400 Carleton Avenue, Central Islip |
| Third District | Town of Huntington | 30 Center Drive, Central Islip |
| Fourth District | Town of Smithtown | 30 Center Drive, Central Islip |
| Fifth District | Town of Islip | 30 Center Drive, Central Islip |
| Sixth District | Town of Brookhaven | 30 Center Drive, Central Islip |
Most filings actually transit through one of the two Central Islip courthouses (Cohalan Complex at 400 Carleton, and 30 Center Drive). The District designation drives the calendaring and judicial assignment, not the physical location.
Parts division
Suffolk District Court operates the same Parts as Nassau:
- Civil Part — debt-collection and contract actions up to $15,000
- Landlord-Tenant Part — RPAPL Article 7 summary proceedings (nonpayment + holdover); the Suffolk County L&T forum for the western towns + Brookhaven
- Small Claims Part — informal proceedings; up to $5,000
- Commercial Claims Part — entities; UDCA § 1801-A
- Criminal Parts — misdemeanors + violations + arraignments
- TPVA — Traffic and Parking Violations Agency
Distinctives
Suffolk's jurisdictional split is unique on Long Island
Unlike Nassau (where the District Court covers the entire county), Suffolk's District Court covers only the five western towns plus Brookhaven. The eastern towns (Riverhead, Southold, Shelter Island, Southampton, East Hampton) maintain their own Town Justice Courts with the $3,000 small-civil limit. Pro se debt-defense practice therefore looks different in eastern Suffolk than in western Suffolk:
- Western Suffolk + Brookhaven: cases up to $15,000 land in Suffolk District Court (Central Islip); CCFA + 22 NYCRR Part 212 apply
- Eastern Suffolk: cases up to $3,000 land in Town Justice Court; cases over $3,000 must route to Suffolk Supreme Court, not the District Court
CCFA + 22 NYCRR § 202.27-a apply in full
The 2022 Consumer Credit Fairness Act (CCFA) applies in full at Suffolk District Court Civil Part the same way it applies in Nassau District Court and NYC Civil Court. CPLR 3015(e) heightened pleading (account statements, itemized default-rate calculation, chain of title for assigned debt) is enforced at default-judgment time. The 3-year SOL on consumer-credit actions (CPLR 214-i) shortens many actions filed in the wake of the 2022 reforms.
Cohalan Court Complex is the principal courthouse
The John P. Cohalan Jr. Court Complex at 400 Carleton Avenue, Central Islip is the primary courthouse — it houses both Suffolk District Court (First + Second Districts) and the Suffolk County Supreme Court Civil Term. The complex is colloquially "Central Islip" and the two courts are sometimes confused; verify the named court on the summons.
L&T Part procedure
Suffolk District Court's Landlord-Tenant Part runs RPAPL Article 7 summary proceedings under the same procedural framework as Nassau and NYC Housing Court. The 2019 HSTPA amendments — 14-day rent demand, 30/60/90-day termination notice based on tenancy length, § 234-a caps on late fees, and the rent-deposit protection scheme — apply across Suffolk County L&T practice. Note that Good Cause Eviction (2024 statewide opt-in) has been adopted by several Suffolk County villages and cities (Islip, Babylon Village among them); confirm the relevant municipality's election before drafting a holdover petition that would now require Good Cause grounds.
Discovery is limited
CPLR Article 31 disclosure formally applies; in practice Suffolk District Court Civil Part rarely sees written interrogatories or document demands outside the pre-trial conference order. Most disputes are resolved at the first two appearances on the consumer-credit calendar.
Filing checklist
- Summons + Complaint: UDCA § 401 / 402 — short-form summons + complaint with the $45 filing fee (UDCA § 1911(1))
- Service: CPLR 308 / 312 within UDCA § 403 service period (typically 120 days)
- Answer: defendant has 30 days from service in the Civil Part (CPLR 320(a))
- Pre-trial conference: routinely scheduled within 60-90 days of issue being joined; held at Central Islip regardless of District
- Trial date: 6-12 months from filing in most Civil Part cases
Format compliance: 22 NYCRR Part 212 governs Suffolk District Court filings. Use
ny-statewide-formatas the baseline.
Composition with other ny- skills
ny-statewide-format— baseline 22 NYCRR Part 202 format with Part 212 District Court adjustmentsny-county-courts— broader roll-up that this skill refinesny-nassau-dc— the parallel Nassau District Court skillny-discovery— CPLR Article 31 mechanicsny-first-30-days— Answer / pre-answer motion triageny-consumer-debt— CCFA pleading + default scrutiny in the Civil Partny-landlord-tenant— RPAPL Article 7 procedure for the Suffolk L&T Partny-pro-se— pro se framework (Suffolk DC is high-volume pro se)ny-file-packet— packet assembly
Pro-se resources
- Suffolk County Bar Association Lawyer Referral Service: 631-234-5577
- Nassau / Suffolk Law Services (NSLS) — civil legal aid; serves both counties
- Touro Law Center Civil Practice Clinic — Central Islip; pro se support
- Self-Represented Litigants Office at Cohalan Complex
Sponsors
Details
- Marketplace
- codearranger/claude-legal
- Source
- plugins/ny-court-docs
- Category
- Legal
- Keywords
- new-york, legal, pleadings, pro-se, cplr, 22-nycrr-202, guide-to-ny-evidence, tanbook, new-york-county, kings-county, bronx-county, nassau-county, queens-county, supreme-court, individual-assignment-system, commercial-division, nyc-civil-court, nyscef, county-courts, civil-rules, evidence-rules, discovery, hearings, post-judgment, fact-check, deadlines, 5-day-mail-rule, fdcpa, reg-f, ccfa, consumer-credit-fairness-act, cplr-213a, cplr-3015e, gbl-349, gbl-600, consumer-protection, debt-collection, landlord-tenant, rpapl-article-7, hstpa, good-cause-eviction, rpl-235-b, rent-stabilization, nyc-housing-court, right-to-counsel, erap